1. In the Beginning was Nothing. |
||
This section has been updated to take into account the new scientific evidence presented in the channel 4 documentary, 'The Day the Earth was Born'. This has not affected the fundamentals of this work.
1.1: The Formation of the Earth.
The solar system was created from the
debris of a cosmic explosion. The Earth and its neighbouring planets mercury,
venus, and mars, coalesced from this debris at the same time, and in the
same way, over a long period of time. It has been estimated that the Earth
was formed roughly 4,550,000,000 years ago. The early Earth was a fiery
place where volcanic eruptions greeted continual showers of meteorites,
"Infant Earth was a huge ball of rock covered with molten boiling
lava." Movie
- 212 kb and 13 seconds long.
1.2: The Earth Becomes Molten.
The Day the Earth was Born proposes that 25 million years after its formation, the Earth became a molten ball of rock with temperatures around 1200C, "Four and a half billion years ago the Earth was an undifferentiated sphere of rock. Volcanoes spewed vast amounts of lava onto the hot, seething surface. Our hostile planet was about to endure the first of several momentous events that would change it forever. Radioactive elements trapped when the planet was formed were heating it from inside. At the same time, Earths gravity was pulling in huge quantities of debris from space, a bombardment that generated excessive amounts of heat on the surface. The combined effect was catastrophic. At eight minutes past midnight on the Earth clock, (about 25 million years after the formation of the Earth i.e. 4,525,000,000 years ago) the entire planet was like a furnace."
1.3: The Iron Catastrophe: the Migration of the Elements.
In this molten state, iron melted and
sank towards the centre of the Earth, "We think the earth, at some
point, was totally molten, a big droplet of melt just floating in space.
When you have a totally molten droplet like this, the heaviest elements,
and that includes things like iron, would sink to the centre of this droplet
and the lightest elements, things rich in carbon and water, for instance,
the light elements, would float to the top and float there like algae
on a lake." (Michael Zolensky, Nasa)." earth003web.mov
- 192 kb and 6 seconds long.
"This gigantic migration of the elements is known as the iron catastrophe. The sinking iron accumulated at the heart of the Earth and created a molten core three-quarters the size of the moon." (Clip 004).
1.4: The Creation of the Earths Magnetic Field.
The iron catastrophe turned out to be
a blessing in disguise for the life that was to eventually emerge on Earth.
It was one of a myriad number of factors that would later help to ensure
the survival of life on the planet, "As the liquid iron swirled around
it produced an invisible force that even today helps keep us alive: the
Earths magnetic field. Convection currents inside the liquid core
behaved like a dynamo and generated electric currents. These transformed
our planet into a giant magnet with north and south magnetic poles."
earth004web.mov - 188
kb and 7 seconds long. "Without the liquid iron core the early
atmosphere would have been stripped away and life could never have evolved
on our planet. Thats because space is lethal. Its full of
highly dangerous solar particles that can be ten times more deadly than
the radiation from a nuclear explosion. These particles originate from
the sun when it spews out massive solar flares. A devastating solar wind
streams towards the Earth at 250 miles per second. Thats a million
miles an hour. If it ever reached the surface of our planet it would strip
away the atmosphere in a few thousand years. But the Earths magnetic
field creates a protective shield and deflects the solar particles. Without
the molten core, today our planet would be a sterile rocky sphere with
little or no atmosphere. The tragic fate that befell our neighbouring
planet, mars." earth005web.mov
- 756 kb and 23 seconds long.
1.5: The State of the Earths Atmosphere after the Iron Catastrophe.
"The time had reached 16 minutes past midnight (about 50 million years after the formation of the Earth i.e. 4,500,000,000 years ago). The iron catastrophe was over, leaving the rocks at the surface depleted in iron. Large areas were cooling and solidifying but the Earth was still hostile and uninhabitable. Incessant volcanic eruptions poured hot gases into the thick, turbulent atmosphere. This alien landscape was enveloped in a noxious mass of hydrogen sulphide, methane, and steam. Humans could not have survived here. There was no oxygen to breathe and no ozone layer to block the lethal ultra-violet radiation."
1.6: The Creation of the Moon.
1.6.1: The Moon makes the Earth Habitable.
It took another catastrophe to bring about
the creation of the moon. In 1974 Bill Hartmann (of the Planetary Science
institute) proposed that the moon was created when a rocky planetesimal
left over from the formation of the solar system smashed into the Earth,
"The time was approaching 16 minutes past midnight on our 24 hour
clock. The rogue object, about the size of mars, was moments away from
collision with Earth. The heat of the impact melted both the planetesimal
and the outer layers of the Earth. Together they fused into one planet,
a new larger Earth. Vast amounts of molten rock were ejected into orbit.
Over the next few thousand years, the debris coalesced to form the moon."
earth007web.mov - 1012
kb and 34 seconds long. Art bell & whitley strieber also believe
the moon was created this way. They speculate that the impact of the collision
created what is now the pacific ocean."
According to The Day the Earth was Born,
"The moon was much closer to Earth than it is today and it appeared
15 times as large. As a result of the massive collision, the Earth was
spinning five times faster than it does today. Each day was just five
hours long. The proximity of the moon created an enormous gravitational
pull on the surface of the Earth. The ground rose and fell by as much
as 200 feet when the moon passed overhead. The drag on the Earths
crust slowed our planets speed of rotation and forced the moon to
orbit further and further away. It has been moving outwards ever since."
earth008web.mov - 736
kb and 44 seconds long. Art bell & whitley strieber argue, "So
we ended up with a planet with a huge moon that was orbiting it more and
more slowly."
1.6.2: The Earths Rotational Winds.
Art bell & whitley strieber argue, "Over time, the gradually increasing drag of the moons gravity slowed down the rotational wind of the earth, which would otherwise blow in excess of two hundred miles an hour." 1.6.3: The Earths Tilt.
After the Earth's impact with the planetesimal
the planets axis became tilted. "The immense collision that formed
the moon also caused our planets axis to tilt over at an angle of
23 degrees." earth009web.mov
- 556 kb and 15 seconds long. The degree of tilt changes from one
extreme to the other over tens of thousands of years so that as the Earth
orbits the sun it constantly shows a slightly different face to the sun.
This tilt is what causes the Earth to experience a variety of seasons
giving it a much more equable climate than would be the case without
such a tilt. See the video clip from aubrey manning's bbc2 documentary, 'Earth Story', earthstory04.mov
- 1 mb and 26 seconds long.
1.6.4: The Earths Wobble.
The Earth revolves around the sun whilst
rotating around its tilted axis. But the Earths axis does not remain
in an unchanging tilted position. It also wobbles - in the same way as
a spinning top - because of the gravitational pull of the other planet's
in the solar system. (See the video clip from aubrey manning's bbc2 documentary, 'Earth Story', earthstory05.mov
- 692 kb and 16 seconds long). Without the moon, the Earth could have wobbled either into
a perpendicular position (which would mean no seasons on Earth) or onto its side (which would mean only one side of the Earth receiving any sunlight). The creation of the moon dramatically avoided such extremes. 'The
Day the Earth was Born' concludes, "Without the stabilizing influence
of the moon, the Earth would wobble dramatically about it axis, the planet
would experience wild fluctuations of weather, making it impossible for
anything but the most primitive life forms to survive." (See the following videos taken from Aubrey Manning's bbc2 documentary, 'Earth Story':
1.6.5: The Moons Benefits for the Earth.
The creation of the moon was another factor that would later help the planet to become more habitable. It reduced the Earths rotational winds. It tilted the Earths axis changing the face of the Earth receiving solar radiation and thereby minimizing the extremes of the Earths climate. The moon also reduced the Earths wobbling motion which further helped to stabilize the Earths climate. Art bell & whitley strieber conclude, "The balance of the earth-moon system is exquisite. Were it not for the moon being just the size that it is and orbiting the earth as it does, nothing more complex than a lichen would ever have evolved here." By themselves neither the planetesimal nor the Earth would have been capable of sustaining life. The collision between them resulted in the formation of the moon which, in effect, sacrificed all of its own chances of sustaining life in order to make the Earth habitable. The barren, lifeless, inhospitable, moon made it possible for life to emerge and survive on Earth.
|
1.7: The Formation of the Earths Crust.
Simon Wilde of Curtin University found zircon crystals in the jack hills of western australia. They are the only remnants of minerals left over from the Earths earliest period. He has been analyzing these crystals to speculate about the conditions prevailing on the early Earth. According to The Day the Earth was Born, "Simons discovery suggests that the Earth must have recovered very rapidly after the trauma of the moons formation. The age of the zircons revealed our planet must have cooled and formed a crust as early as 12 minutes to one in the morning on our clock (about 150 million years after the formation of the Earth i.e. 4,400,000,000 years ago). These tiny crystals are last surviving fragments from the first hour of the Earths life."
1.8: The Great Bombardment.
The Earth had been created from an accretion
of meteorites and, for hundreds of millions of years after its formation,
it continued to be bombarded by meteorites, debris from the explosion
that created the solar system, "For the first 600 million years of
its life (up until 3.10am on the Earths 24 hour clock), our planet
was constantly battered by comets and asteroids. This is known as the
great bombardment. These missiles could measure 300 miles across."
earth018web.mov - 428
kb and 29 seconds long.
1.9: The Bombardment brings Water to Earth.
American geologist Stephen Mojzsis at the University of Colorado, Boulder, USA, also carried out experiments on the zircon crystals found in the jack hills of western australia, "In january 2001 stephen announced he had made a revolutionary discovery. The oldest zircon crystals contained a type of oxygen called oxygen 18. Oxygen 18 could only have been present if the crystals had grown in the presence of large quantities of water. Geologists had previously believed that large amounts of water first appeared around one billion years after the formation of our planet. The oxygen 18 revealed that water was present on the surface of the Earth much sooner, as early as 200 million years after its formation. The time was still only 12 minutes to one in the morning." He argues, "By 200 million years after the formation of the Earth (about 4,350,000,000 years ago or 3 minutes past one on the 24 hour clock) you can imagine a landscape of islands and small continents bathed by a primitive ocean where in these zircons were formed." (Stephen Mojzsis).
Some commentators argue that volcanic eruptions created islands poking through a global ocean. Richard fortey speculates, "The earliest continents were probably small and temporary (microcontinents) separated by ocean basins .. Volcanic islands rose above the primordial seas, belching sulphurous smoke and fumes and releasing more gases from the interior of the Earth." According to j john sepkoski jr, the early Earth .. "was an alien planet, most of it ocean, with scattered chains of volcanic islands." It was an Earth quite unlike that which oomans would recognize, "Brown seas reflected a pinkish-orange sky .."
The question that Mojzsiss discovery led to
was where did the water come from at such an early point in the Earths
history? "Early volcanic activity may have erupted huge amounts of
steam into the atmosphere but some scientists argue that there would have
been too little time for the oceans to have formed in this way. Some scientists
believe that much of the Earths water came from outer space. According
to Bill Hartmann, "We all hear about the impact 65 million years
ago that wiped out the dinosaurs and youre getting that kind of
impact about once a month on the early Earth. But this rain of debris
left over from the formation of the solar system continues for several
million years." Comets contain dust and frozen water vapour left
over from the birth of the solar system. Like giant dirty snowballs roughly
half their mass is water." earth011web.mov
- 212 kb and 13 seconds long. One scientist has even proposed that
all water came from outer space but, so far, he has failed to find evidence
to support his theory. "One of Nasas top comet experts, Michael
Mumma, believes that comets could be source of water in our oceans."
It is not known how much water came from outer space.
1.10: The Bombardment brings Life to Earth.
If there had been any life on the planet before the Earths collision with the planetesimal, it would have vanished after the impact, "When a giant body collided with our planet soon after its birth, the outer layers were completely vapourized creating our moon. Any complex Carbon molecules that existed on Earth would have been entirely destroyed by the massive impact."
The Day the Earth was Born proposes that the building blocks of life could have come from outer space, "So one theory as to where they came from which is rapidly gaining support suggests the molecules were delivered as ready made package s from outer space."
There is a range of evidence pointing in this direction,
"Huge amounts of debris left over from the creation of the solar
system are still floating in space. But most of it is in the form of lumps
of rock orbiting in the asteroid belt. One vital piece of evidence that
supports the theory that the ingredients of life came from space is a
very special meteorite picked up in Mercheson, australia in 1969. This
was the first time that amino acids had ever been detected in any material
from space. Amino acids are Carbon molecules that combine to form the
proteins that are vital to all living organisms. Nasas michael zolensky
has been researching the mercheson meteorite for twenty years. He believes
that meteorites like mercheson would have been so commonplace in the early
history of the Earth that they could have delivered vast quantities of
amino acids from space." "More than 70 varieties of amino acids
have been found inside meteorites and 8 of them are the fundamental constituents
of proteins found in living cells. During the great bombardment, throughout
the early hours of the morning, millions of asteroids and comets may have
seeded the Earth with the stuff of life."
It may be suspected that when comets smashed into the Earth their cargoes of organic compounds would have been destroyed on impact. However, Jennifer Blank, a geophysicist at the Lawrence Livermore National laboratory, in California, USA, has shown that such collisions could have helped to fuse simple organic compounds into more complex molecules, "Jennifers experiment proves that not only can organic molecules survive an impact, but the immense pressures created can also produce complex molecules one stage closer to the origin of life."
The theory that the building blocks of life may have come from space is given credence by the proposition that much of the Earths water also came from outer space.
There is still controversy, however, over where
life first developed on Earth. Some scientists believe it may have trickled
down into cracks in the Earths crust whereas others believe it may
have happened in the oceans, "From the moment our Earth was born,
it was bombarded by giant asteroids and comets. On our 24 hour clock the
most violent period of bombardment lasted from midnight until almost half
past three in the morning (660,500,000 million years after the formation
of the Earth). Until recently scientists assumed that life must have started
several hundred million years after this massive assault had finished.
But now they believe that life began during this great bombardment. For
they have discovered that life was already thriving on the planet as early
as three minutes to four." (750 million years after the formation
of the Earth i.e. 3,750,000,000 years ago).
As Bacteria colonized more and more of the oceans and increased
in numbers, a genetic mutation resulted in some types of bacteria acquiring the
ability to carry out Photosynthesis. J john sepkoski jr believes Photosynthesis
started soon after the Earth became cool enough for life, “Some of the
oldest rocks on Earth (were) laid down 3.8 billion years ago. Some chemical
analyses suggest there is a 12C surplus in these rocks, and
if this is true life must have put it there. As evidence of Photosynthesis
it would be startling because it comes a mere 200 my at most after the
Earth grew cool enough to live on.”[9]
The first Photosynthesizer is believed to be Cyanobacteria, “Today
the green and purple sulfur bacteria still use hydrogen sulphide as their
electron donor in photosynthesis. In the early days photosynthesis was
largely dependent on a steady source of hydrogen sulphide, and the gas
was converted into yellow sulphur deposits on the ground or into globules
in the water that were later oxidized to make ocean sulphate.”[10]
Cyanobacteria absorbed hydrogen sulphide and Carbon dioxide and released oxygen into
the environment creating strange structures known as stromatolites
in the shallow oceans.[11] As new types of Bacteria began to emerge some
of these may also have developed the ability to carry out Photosynthesis.[12] Eventually,
Bacterial Photosynthesizers started using water instead of hydrogen sulphide.
1.11: The Early Greenhouse Effect.
Early Earth hardly seemed conducive to life, "Early Earth was hostile: an extreme place for life to emerge. It was smothered in a thick, turbulent atmosphere. There was no oxygen and the ultra-violet radiation was lethal. The young sun was weaker than it is today. Its feeble light would have barely penetrated the noxious atmosphere. Carbon dioxide would have mixed with the pungent smell of hydrogen sulphide."
Much of the heat in the Earths atmosphere came from meteorite impacts, volcanic eruptions, nuclear reactions in the mantle, and the greenhouse effect produced by vast quantities of Carbon and water in the atmosphere. Lovelock believes that nearly 30% of the atmosphere consisted of Carbon whether in the form of Carbon dioxide, Carbon monoxide, or Methane. The atmosphere contained only minute traces of oxygen. Both Carbon and water created a powerful greenhouse effect retaining most of the solar radiation reaching the Earths surface. Despite the fact that the sun was far weaker than it is today, the Earth retained far more solar radiation than it does now. If it wasnt for Carbons ability to allow solar radiation to pass through the Earths atmosphere and block long wave radiation from the Earths surface, the Earth would eventually have frozen. Few of the planets in the solar system are close enough to the sun to remain warm solely from solar radiation. Despite the heat being added to the atmosphere through meteorite impacts, volcanic eruptions, and nuclear reactions in the mantle, it was only because of the vast quantities of Carbon in the atmosphere that the Earth did not freeze after the end of the great bombardment. The rate at which the suns solar output was increasing would not have been enough to have warmed the Earth to prevent it from freezing.
2. The Impact of Photosynthesizers on Earth.2.1: Life Emerges onto the Surface of the Earth.
Whenever, and wherever, life may have begun
on Earth it eventually moved to the surface of the oceans. According to
The Day the Earth was Born, "On our 24 hour clock, it
was now 5 oclock in the morning. (950,000,000 after the formation
of the Earth i.e. about 3,600,000,000 years ago). The great bombardment
was over. Most of the debris in the solar system had been swept up and
there were far fewer violent impacts on Earth. Microbial life was able
to emerge from its protective hiding places. It began to flourish close
to the surface and take advantage of a new, powerful, source of energy
the sun. These bacteria evolved a green pigment, chlorophyll, which
enabled them to harness the suns energy through Photosynthesis and
convert Carbon dioxide into Carbohydrates. As the Earth cooled, this new
generation of cells began to spread across the oceans. Immense colonies
of green slime took over the world and the greatest transformation in
the history of our planet was set in motion." earth026web.mov
- 556 kb and 32 seconds long. J john sepkoski jr believes Photosynthesis
started soon after the Earth became cool enough for life, "Some of
the oldest rocks on Earth (were) laid down 3.8 billion years ago. Some
chemical analyses suggest there is a 12C surplus in these rocks, and if
this is true life must have put it there. As evidence of Photosynthesis
it would be startling because it comes a mere 200my at most after the
Earth grew cool enough to live on."
2.2: The First Photosynthesizers.
The first known Photosynthesizer was Cyanobacteria. This micro-organism relied on the absorption of hydrogen sulphide from the atmosphere to convert sunlight into energy, "Today the green and purple sulfur bacteria still use hydrogen sulphide as their electron donor in photosynthesis. In the early days photosynthesis was largely dependent on a steady source of hydrogen sulphide, and the gas was converted into yellow sulphur deposits on the ground or into globules in the water that were later oxidized to make ocean sulphate." These micro-organisms created strange structures known as stromatolites in the shallow oceans.
(Further videos of stromatolites: earth027web.mov - 1.7 mb and 60 seconds long; earth029xweb.mov - 640 kb; earth016web.mov - 968 kb and 23 seconds long.) 2.3: The Rusting of the Earth: the Photosynthetic Creation of Banded Iron Formations (bifs).
As new types of Photosynthesizing Cyanobacteria
began to emerge, some developed the ability to carry out Photosynthesis
using water instead of hydrogen sulphide thereby releasing oxygen into
the environment. The oxygen released by Photosynthesizers did not immediately
begin to accumulate in the atmosphere/stratosphere. It oxidized (rusted)
the iron dissolved in the seas which then sank to the ocean floor. "It
was still only 5.45 in the morning (1,000,000,000 after the formation
of the Earth i.e. about 3,550,000,000 years ago) and the most significant
change in our planet was about to begin. Stromatolites had spread out
across the entire planet. To derive their energy they absorbed sunlight
and Carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and produced a waste gas that would
transform the entire planet - oxygen. earth028xweb.mov
- 520 kb. At first, all the oxygen was absorbed into the oceans. Underwater
volcanoes were spewing out iron from erupting lava. The iron dissolved
in the sea water and chemically reacted with the oxygen. It fell as minute
iron oxide particles to the ocean floor. Over the next 700 million years
the planet literally rusted. All the iron was turned into oxide building
up layer after layer of what would become the most significant mineral
deposits on Earth iron ore." earth028web.mov
- 1mb and 19 seconds long.
Around the world, geological strata can be found
today which consists of layers alternating between high and low concentrations
of iron. These are known as banded iron formations (bifs). "As the
water temperature changed with the seasons, the production of oxygen by
the cyano-bacteria.varied. Different amounts of iron oxide were deposited
at different times of the year creating these distinct layers in the rock.
This was a global phenomenon. Vast amounts of iron ore were laid down
in similar deposits all over the world." earth029web.mov
- 1mb and 31 seconds long. On our day long clock it took more than
7 hours for all the iron to be removed from the oceans - until 1pm in
the afternoon. (2,470,000,000 after the formation of the Earth i.e. about
2,080,000,000 years ago)" (Clip 029). "The increasing populations
of cyanobacteria on the unlit bottoms of the new shallow seas relentlessly
pumped out free oxygen, and the Earth rusted."
It has been estimated that, "Most of our bifs were deposited between 2.5 and 1.8 billion years ago ..." What this suggests is that there couldnt have been any significant accumulation of oxygen in the atmosphere until after 1.8 billion years ago. For nearly a billion years, marine Photosynthesizers had released vast quantities of oxygen creating an estimated 600 trillion tons of iron oxides.
The oxygen released by Photosynthesizers also reacted with atmospheric hydrogen to form water; some reacted with the sulphur released by Cyanobacteria; and the remainder reacted with the rocks and minerals ejected by volcanoes. "When volcanic upsurges brought raw iron and other unoxidized minerals or gases to the surface, these would react chemically to pull free oxygen out of the environment."
2.4: The Oxygenation of the Atmosphere.
It was only after the oxygen released
by Photosynthesizing micro-organisms had oxidized vast quantities of hydrogen,
sulphur, and iron, that it was possible for oxygen to accumulate in the
oceans/atmosphere, "Once the reduced iron ran out, there was no other
chemical sink big enough to hold the continuing biological surge of oxygen
and this gas built up, first dissolved in water and then escaping into
the atmosphere." Lynn margulis & james lovelock argue, "Prokaryotic
microbes (Cyanobacteria) were almost certainly responsible for the original
transition to the oxygen-containing atmosphere about 2000 million years
ago ..." Unfortunately, the precise rate at which oxygen accumulated
in the atmosphere is not known. "When there was no iron left to react
with, the excess oxygen from the stromatolites began to build up in the
atmosphere. Slowly but surely the planet was transformed. Over the next
8 hours the microbes raised the level of oxygen from less than 1 per cent
to the present level of 21per cent. The time was 9pm. Without the cyanobacteria
there would be no oxygen and Earth would still be smothered in noxious
gases. There would be no plants and animals, and humans would never have
evolved."
2.5: The Photosynthesis of Water and the Release of Oxygen.
Lovelock argues that Photosynthesis is the only source of oxygen on Earth, "No one now thinks seriously of oxygen as anything other than a vegetable product. It is easy to forget, though, that 20-30 years ago serious papers were published suggesting that oxygen mainly came from photo-dissociation of water vapour in the upper atmosphere of the Earth." Clive carpenter supports the hypothesis, "Photosynthesis is the source of all the oxygen in the atmosphere." It should be pointed out that there are still commentators who believe that .. "loss of water as vapour was split in the stratosphere and hydrogen escaped." 2.6: The Photosynthetic Preservation of Water on Earth.
Lovelock proposes that Photosynthesizers preserved water on Earth. There is considerable disagreement about this proposition.
2.6.1: The Views of Conventional Science about Water.
The conventional scientific assumptions about the presence of water on Earth are firstly, that the water cycle is the dominant feature of the Earth; secondly, that the water cycle rather than Photosynthesis, stabilizes the Earth's climate; and, thirdly, that water is the primary life sustaining process on Earth - Photosynthesis being of only secondary importance.
The first proposition seems obvious because, when seen from space, the planet seems dominated by water - the dazzling blue of its vast oceans, the vibrant white clouds covering vast expanses of the Earths atmosphere or the huge patches of ice covering the poles. It is hardly surprising that science fiction writers and space agencies regard the Earth as a blue Planet, "How inappropriate to call this planet Earth when clearly it is ocean, arthur c clarke has remarked."
As regards the second proposition: the oceans, ice sheets, and clouds, all have a major impact on the climate. For example, "Today cloud cover bounces about a third of the suns heat back into space. If there were no cloud cover global temperatures would soar."
The third proposition is exemplified by nasa, "Those scientists who hold that the laws of physics and chemistry alone are sufficient explanation of Earths thermostat, are in the majority. Their view was encapsulated by nasa: The earth would still have remained habitable even if it had never been inhabited."
Stephen drury suggests that, throughout the Earths history, volcanoes pumped water from the Earths mantle into the atmosphere. He does not believe that Photosynthesis played a dramatic role in preserving water on Earth, "As far as our planet goes, there has never been a shortage, for it (water) belches from volcanoes continuously. So water has been destined to accumulate in the outer Earth since the planet stabilized. (Some water vapour is broken up by ultra-violet radiation which allows hydrogen to escape into space). The existence of oceans bears witness to the overwhelming preponderance of mantle supply over loss by this means from the Earth."
2.6.2: Lovelocks Views about the Preservation of Water.
According to lovelock, if it wasnt for Photosynthesizers, the planet would have rapidly lost its water, "Water on the Earth enabled life, but without life the Earth would now be dry."; .. "without life and oxygen, the oceans of the Earth would in a billion years (of the origins of the Earth) have vanished forever."
Lovelock shows that the main components of the Earths water cycle, clouds, ice sheets and oceans, are all dependent on Photosynthesis. He argues that clouds are not created by water evaporation. The water that evaporates from the oceans forms large water droplets that fall back to the ocean. It is only when condensation nuclei are present that water droplets are small enough to create clouds. These condensation nuclei come from microscopic marine algae, "Without these nuclei, the product of ocean life, the Earth might have few clouds and perhaps be 10-20C hotter than it is now." He concludes, "Here perhaps was the most important scientific discovery that either of us made. Without the clouds over the ocean, life as we know it would not exist. This is because oceans cover 70% of the surface of the Earth, and they are dark, and absorb sunlight strongly, whereas clouds are white and reflect sunlight." In other words, it is Photosynthesizers which create the clouds that cool the Earth, not the oceans. Photosynthesis determines the climate through the water cycle.
2.6.3: The Views of Greens.
Surprisingly, decentralist greens, most of whom are opposed to space technologies, also propound the view of the Earth as a blue Planet. In previous publications it has been argued that such greens arent green at all but should be regarded as blues.
2.7: The Role of Photosynthesizers in Maintaining the Quantity of Water on Earth.
Lovelock also raises the issue as to whether Photosynthesizers are responsible for keeping a constant level of water on Earth thereby preserving not merely marine life, but most other life, on Earth, "Keeping the Earth moist, keeping it suitable for organisms, is a cliff hanging existence. If about 25% of the water now in the oceans had dried away, ocean life would not be possible for most organisms." This is a question which, as far as is known, he has not answered. 2.8: The Photosynthetic Preservation of Hydrogen.
Photosynthesizers preserved water on Earth and, in effect, prevented hydrogen, one of the lightest elements on Earth, from floating through the atmosphere and escaping into space. They played two critical roles in preventing the escape of hydrogen. Firstly, they extracted hydrogen (in the form of water) from the atmosphere to form Carbohydrates and, secondly, they released oxygen into the environment which reacted with hydrogen to form water. If hydrogen had escaped from the planets atmosphere then eventually the Earth would have lost all its water. If, in the future, the Earth should ever lose its capability for Photosynthesis then hydrogen would resume its drift through the atmosphere and be lost to space and the Earth would begin to dry up. The role of Photosynthesizers on Earth is a contentious issue. It is commonly accepted that they are closely integrated with the water cycle: Terrestrial Photosynthesizers extract water from the atmosphere and release it back into the atmosphere as a result of respiration. Forests release nuclei which form clouds over the continents. Marine Photosynthesizers release dimethyl sulphide which creates marine clouds. However, geophysiologists do not go beyond such propositions to support the proposition that Photosynthesizers prevented the escape of hydrogen from the Earth and thereby preserved water on Earth. They argue that if it wasnt for Photosynthesis there wouldnt be any oceans, clouds, or even life on Earth. They believe the Earth is a green planet - not a blue one. Most scientists find such contentions too controversial. 2.9: The Indirect Role of Photosynthesis in the Creation of Granite Continents.
The preservation of water on Earth, courtesy of Photosynthesis, was vital for enabling volcanic islands to grow into continents. Volcanic eruptions contain basalt which, when heated in water, forms granite - the basis of the Earths continents. 2.10: The Photosynthetic Role in the Creation of Eukaryotic Life Forms.
The presence of free oxygen in the oceans/atmosphere led to a major genetic leap, the emergence of eukaryotic cells, "The world became oxygenated enough through the Photosynthesizing mats (created by Cyanobacteria) to be suitable for their development (nucleated cells) about 2,000 million years ago." Bacteria, prokaryotic life forms without nucleated cells, gave rise to a more complex form of life - Protista, eukaryotic life forms with nucleated cells. 2.11: The Photosynthetic Burial of Carbon - One Billion Years Ago.
The first Protista life forms were soft bodied marine invertebrates - some of which also acquired the ability to carry out Photosynthesis. Cyanobacteria and Photosynthesizing protista extracted Carbon from the atmosphere but after these individual micro-organisms died, the Carbon contained in their bodies was returned to the atmosphere. It is believed that about a billion years ago, some of the Photosynthesizing marine Protista developed the ability to grow shells using the Carbon acquired through Photosynthesis. This completely changed the destination of the Carbon contained in their bodies which had a fundamental impact on the Earths atmosphere and climate, "Although merely protoctists, foraminifera are one of the most diverse groups of fossil forming small organisms. An astounding variety of magnificent shells are made by these complex single-celled beings .." As a consequence, the shells of dead Algae sank to the ocean floor permanently removing Carbon from the atmosphere. The burial of Carbon shells liberated an equivalent quantity of oxygen allowing it to accumulate in the atmosphere. Oxygen didnt start accumulating in the Earths atmosphere until after banded iron formations ceased to appear approximately 1.8bya. But it wasnt until 1 bya ago that micro-organisms developed shells which permanently buried Carbon on the ocean floor thereby ensuring the accumulation of oxygen in the atmosphere. 2.12: The Photosynthetic Creation of Sedimentary Layers of Rock.
Over millions of years, vast quantities of Algal shells accumulated on the ocean floor and were crushed, under their own weight and the water above them, into layers of limestone rock. Sedimentary rocks cover vast areas of the ocean floor .. "calcium carbonates, which cover 10% of the continental crust, were generated by life ..." Over the course of time, as the Earth has changed, sedimentary layers of rock at the bottom of the Earths oceans have ended up in rather incongruous places. Some have been exposed by falling ocean levels and currently form the landscape of many countries e.g. the white cliffs of dover. Others have been ended up on the tops of mountains after collisions between tectonic plates e.g. sedimentary rocks can be found on the top of the himalayas. (See the video clip taken from Aubrey Manning's bbc2 documentary, 'Earth
Story': earthstory03.mov
- 196 kb and 8 seconds long). 2.13: Photosynthesizers Colonizing the Land, 439mya.
As basaltic islands grew into granite continents they were invaded by micro-organisms and Plants. Michael benton states, "The first plants moved on to land during the silurian period (439-409mya), with simple small forms like Cooksonia ..."
2.14: The Greening of the Earth.
Richard fortey suggests the greening of the land wasnt completed until after the silurian period, "There have been many changes since the greening of the Earth in the devonian (409-363mya)." The greening of the Earth was important because it boosted the scale of global Photosynthesis. Richard fortey alleges the invasion of the land by micro-organisms and Plants was followed shortly thereafter by marine Animals, "So the backboned animals followed shortly after the plants made their excursions on to land."
Fortey concludes that, "There cannot be a more important event than the greening of the world, for it prepared the way for everything that happened on land thereafter in the evolutionary theatre." It has to be countered that the most important event was the development of Photosynthesis. The greening of the oceans was just as important as the greening of the land. 2.15: The Photosynthetic Role in the Creation of Animals, 1bya-600mya.
After a vast period of time during which the Earth was dominated by micro-organisms, Photosynthesizers helped to bring about a critical evolutionary change. The oxygen generated by Photosynthesizers brought about a second genetic change, the emergence of Animals .. "there are no documented cases of any metazoa (animals) that can complete their life cycles in the total absence of O2. All Animals are composed of cells that divide by mitosis. The mitotic cell division itself requires O2." All Animals need oxygen to breathe but, more fundamentally, Animal cell division would never have been possible without the presence of oxygen in the atmosphere. It is suspected the first eukaryotic Animal cells appeared a billion years ago but the fossil evidence of Animals doesnt start until much later .. "Yet no metazoans - multicellular animals - appear in the rocks of the fossil record until about 600my ago, a silence of hundreds of millions of years ..." The first fossils are referred to as the ediacaran fauna, "Animals evolved from their protoctist ancestors sometime in the late Proterozoic aeon, that is, the late Riphean or early Vendian era."
3. Photosynthesis and the Creation of a Stable Climate.
3.1: Photosynthesis and the Oceans.
Earth, venus, and mars, were formed at the same time and through the same processes. After they cooled, they were covered in something resembling a global ocean and had massive quantities of Carbon in the atmosphere. Venus and mars lost their surface water but retained all the Carbon in their atmospheres. On the other hand, the Earth still has its oceans but has little Carbon in the atmosphere. The reason for these differences is that, on Earth, Photosynthesizers extracted Carbon from the atmosphere and conserved water on Earth. Over the aeons, the Earths Photosynthesizers have reduced the concentration of Carbon dioxide in the atmosphere from 30% to 0.04%, "Mars and venus, and the hypothetical dead Earth devoid of life, all have chemically stable atmospheres composed of over 95% Carbon dioxide. Earth as we live on it, however, has only 0.03% of this stable gas in its atmosphere. The anomaly is largely due to .. the process of photosynthesis. Bacteria, algae and plants continuously remove carbon dioxide from the air via photosynthesis and incorporate the Carbon from the gas into solid structures such as limestone reefs and eventually Animal shells." In the early days of the solar system, on each planet, there were natural movements of Carbon from the atmosphere to the oceans and then back again into the atmosphere but, by itself, this flux would never have been powerful enough to dramatically, and permanently, reduce the concentration of atmospheric Carbon. What extracted Carbon from the Earths atmosphere and, in due course, permanently buried it on the ocean floors, was Photosynthesis. There is no other permanent means of extracting Carbon from the atmosphere than Photosynthesis. It is true that the oceans, like a sponge, absorb huge quantities of Carbon but it invariably ends up in some sort of balance with the concentration of Carbon in the atmosphere. Much more critically, if Photosynthesis did not preserve water on Earth then would be no oceans to extract Carbon from the atmosphere.
3.2: Bringing Carbon Down to Earth.
Tim radford estimates that, throughout the Earths history, Photosynthesizers have extracted a gargantuan 10,000,000,000,000,000 tons of Carbon from the atmosphere. Photosynthesizers have brought Carbon down to Earth and transformed it into life forms, soils, mountains, cliffs, land, sea floors, etc. 3.3: Photosynthesizers cooling the Earth.
There was one other major consequence of Photosynthesizers extracting Carbon from the atmosphere - the cooling of the Earth. Photosynthesizers ability to extract Carbon from the atmosphere has been vital in cooling the Earth - although it was only when Photosynthesizers acquired the ability to grow shells, permanently removing Carbon from the atmosphere, that they could play a long term role in keeping the Earth cool. The suns luminosity has been increasing ever since it became a star. When the Earth was formed the sun was far cooler than it is now and less solar radiation reached the Earth. Over the Earths lifetime, solar radiation has increased by roughly 30%. The early Earth was hot not merely because of meteorite impacts, volcanic eruptions, and nuclear radiation in the mantle, but because the vast quantities of Carbon in the atmosphere retained much of the low level solar radiation reaching the Earth. The increase in solar radiation over the last four and a half billion years should have led to a significant increase in the Earths average temperature. It did not primarily because Photosynthesizers extracted Carbon from the atmosphere, buried it on the ocean floor, and thereby reduced the greenhouse effect. It was only because life extracted Carbon from the atmosphere that the Earth remained cool enough for life to spread around the planet thereby continuing to cool the Earth. In sum, it was Photosynthesis which created the Earths climatic stability. Without Photosynthesis the Earths atmosphere would still be dominated by Carbon - just like that on venus and mars. Its average temperature would be in triple figures, "Without life the Earth would have an atmosphere comparable to venus, with 98% carbon dioxide, 1.9% nitrogen, a trace of oxygen, an atmospheric pressure 60 times that of the living Earth and an average surface temperature between 240C and 340C." 3.4: The Danger posed by the Overpowering Nature of Photosynthesis and the Appearance of Ice Ages.
3.4.1: Reflections on the Past.
Photosynthesizers transformed the Earth from a planet which could provide a habitat only for simple life forms into one which was suitable for complex life forms. It transformed the Earth from being virtually uninhabitable into a luxuriously habitable planet. But Photosynthesizers also posed a danger to the Earth by extracting all the Carbon from the Earths atmosphere they could plunge the planet into an ice age or, quite possibly, a permanent deep freeze. Although the Earth has experienced ice ages from time to time none of them became permanent. Fortunately for the Earths climatic stability, increasing numbers of life forms fed on Phytomass and released Carbon dioxide or methane back into the oceans/atmosphere. Micro-organisms living in the muds and sediments at the bottom of lakes, marshes, rivers, and the oceans, release vast quantities of methane into the atmosphere and boost the greenhouse effect. This was, and still is, a vital part of the Earths climate stabilization system, "A world with photosynthesizers only is unstable. They would soon have locked up in their bodies most of the available carbon. Their removal of carbon dioxide would have so weakened the greenhouse that the world would have frozen, and life ceased. This never happened. There co-existed with the photosynthesizers simple fermenters, the methanogens. These organisms processed the organic matter made by the photosynthesizers and returned the carbon to the air as a mixture of methane and carbon dioxide, restoring the greenhouse." If, early in the Earths history, Photosynthesizers had removed all the Carbon from the atmosphere, the Earth would have frozen because solar radiation wasnt intense enough by itself to keep the Earth warm. 3.4.2: Reflections on the Present.
All life absorbs Carbon from the environment and releases it back into the environment - including Photosynthesizers. The Earth needs Carbon producers as a counterweight to Carbon absorbers, Photosynthesizers. What it doesnt need is unrestrained Carbon pollution. In the past, large parts of the Earth froze when Photosynthesizers removed too much Carbon from the atmosphere. Although the suns solar radiation has increased significantly over the last few aeons it still doesnt provide enough heat by itself i.e. without the aid of greenhouse gases, to prevent the Earth from lapsing into a global ice age. But the depth of a present day ice age would be nowhere near as deep and long-lived as that which could have been created in the past because of the greater intensity of solar radiation. Solar radiation is destined to go on increasing until it burns up the Earth. However, at present, the dangers facing life on Earth have nothing to do with the Earth burning up because of increasing solar radiation nor the planet freezing to death because of the absence of greenhouse gases. The danger is a runaway global burning disaster brought about by increasing anthropogenic greenhouse gases and the anthropogenic scalping of the Earths Photosynthetic cover. 3.5: Comparing the Earth to its Neighbouring Planets.
It is not known whether the Earth was the only planet in the solar system to develop life-forms nor whether it was the only planet to have Photosynthesizers. It is possible that mercury, venus, and mars, all had life forms including Photosynthesizers. There may be dozens of factors which were critical for the survival of Photosynthesizers on Earth e.g. the moons influence over the Earth. Whatever they were, once Photosynthesizers had established themselves on Earth they were able to keep the planet cool - this is the main role they have fulfilled for the last couple of aeons. Perhaps there was also another stroke of luck in that during the aeons when Photosynthesizers were gently, imperceptively, cooling the Earth, no species emerged which fed on Photosynthesizers and threatened their survival on Earth.
Lovelock believes that gaia started with the arrival of life i.e. Bacteria, "The Archean saw early bacterial life forms and the birth of Gaia." But, more precisely, it began with the emergence of Photosynthesizing Bacteria. Without Photosynthesizers it is unlikely that Bacteria, and the more complex forms of life, would have survived on Earth for many years. Gaia may have started with the first life forms but the Earths climate and its life support system, whilst dependent on life, were created by Photosynthesizing Bacteria. 3.6: The Earths Average Temperature.
The history of the Earths global temperatures is not known with any degree of accuracy. It is difficult assessing the precise contribution of all the different, and sometimes opposing, factors influencing the Earths early climate. However, in broad terms, it can be summarized as follows. During its formation and for millions of years thereafter, the Earths temperatures were fiery. Meteorite impacts, continual volcanic eruptions, high levels of nuclear radiation in the mantle, and dense levels of Carbon in the atmosphere, kept the Earth hot. Although the sun was much cooler than it is now, the Earth had so much Carbon in its atmosphere it was able to retain a much larger proportion of solar radiation. Gradually, however, as meteorite impacts, volcanic eruptions, and nuclear radiation, contributed less and less to global average temperatures, the Earth began to cool. It cooled enough for the formation of a global ocean. If the Earth hadnt had so much Carbon in its atmosphere then it is likely it would eventually have frozen - at that time solar radiation was not sufficient by itself to keep the Earth warm. It was the presence of vast quantities of Carbon in the Earths atmosphere that prevented global freezing. As the aeons passed the suns continually increasing solar radiation would have caused the Earth to overheat if the large amounts of Carbon in its early atmosphere had persisted. This didnt happen because Photosynthesizers extracted Carbon from the atmosphere and cooled the climate. The Earth has thus never become either too hot, or too cold, for life to survive. On the one hand, the Earth faced the threat of a permanent ice age if Photosynthesizers extracted all the Carbon from the Earths atmosphere. On the other, it faced the threat of a runaway global burning disaster if polluters dumped too much Carbon back into the Earths atmosphere.
4. Photosynthesizers Continue to Shape the Earth.4.1: Photosynthesis and the Earths Ph.
The Earths Photosynthesizers also help to preserve the Earths ph balance ensuring that it never becomes too alkaline or too acidic. Lynn margulis argues, "The breathable oxygen, the humid air, and mildly alkaline oceans result from the growth and metabolism of uncountable and always changing numbers of bacteria, plants, and algae, which produce oxygen using solar energy." 4.2: Photosynthesis and the Oceans Ph.
Photosynthesis also helps to maintain the oceans ph balance, "By laying down limestone skeletons, Polyps remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and thus play a major part in lowering the temperature of the Earths surface. According to jim lovelock, they may also play a role in regulating the salt balance of the oceans. Given that the seas receive copious quantities of mineral salts every year through run-off from the land, it has always been a mystery how salt levels in the sea have remained so constant. Coral reefs may provide part of the answer. As they build up over thousands of years, they form lagoons and closed seas, effectively creating natural evaporation basins. Exposed to the sun, these basins eventually dry out, leaving behind enormous salt deposits. Large quantities of salt are thus removed from the seas. Significantly, all the major salt deposits on land are contained within limestone barriers - which suggests that this process has been going on for millenia."
In his last publication, lovelock admitted he doesnt understand all the mechanisms involved in keeping the oceans ph balance, "I still do not know how ocean salinity stays below 5%; it is one of the puzzles posed by the notion of gaia." It ought to be repeated that he also doesnt understand how the Earth maintains a roughly constant level of water on Earth. These issues could be linked. 4.3: The Creation of Coal and Oil, 360mya.
In the Carboniferous period (363-290mya) large Trees began to emerge. The first big Trees were the gymnosperms which extracted huge amounts of Carbon from the atmosphere. When the climate changed and Forests sank into swamps Phytomass was eventually crushed into layers of coal, oil, and gas, "Their production (gymnosperms) was so rapid that the swampy environment of their growth would soon become oxygen deficient. Some of the organic Carbon is preserved in the form of thick coal seams." Thomas algeo suggests that .. "in the short interval from 400 to 380 million years ago, the size of the biggest land plant soared from inch-short dwarfs to hundred-foot giants, an amazing case of evolution in action." 4.4: The Photosynthetic Role in the Creation of the Stratospheric Ozone Layer.
During the Paleozoic era, Photosynthesizers continued to release oxygen into the environment but, much more critically, the demise of shell forming Photosynthesizers led to the burial of Carbon on the sea bed thereby setting free the oxygen component of Carbon dioxide. The accumulation of oxygen in the troposphere led to the emergence of the stratospheric ozone layer. It is not known whether the stratospheric ozone layer emerged in parallel with the build up of tropospheric oxygen or developed only after oxygen had reached saturation point in the troposphere. 4.4.1: The Views of Conventional Science about the Stratospheric Ozone Layer.
Conventional scientists believe it was only after the formation of the stratospheric ozone layer that Plants and Animals emerged from the oceans to colonize the land. They believe that ultra-violet radiation posed a serious threat to life on Earth - not forgetting that solar radiation at that time was less intense than it is now. Richard fortey represents this viewpoint, "The explanation that the level of oxygen had reached a critical level for the respiration of large Animals has a pleasing continuity with the role of the humble, inconspicuous photosynthesizers, which had transformed the atmosphere through the previous vast stretches of geological time .. Oxygen may have increased to a point where it was sufficient to supply a protective ozone layer high in the atmosphere, which served to shield vulnerable animal tissues from harmful radiation." 4.4.2: Lovelocks Views about the Stratospheric Ozone Layer.
In contradistinction to this conventional view, lovelock believes that lifes colonization of the land was not threatened by ultra-violet radiation and that the creation of an oxygen atmosphere and a stratospheric ozone layer occurred after the colonization of the land. J john sepkoski jr argues that Photosynthesizing Cyanobacteria, which lived in the shallow waters producing stromatolites, were not damaged by ultra-violet radiation, "Ultra-violet radiation from the sun does not harm cyanobacteria that exude their insulating mucus, a very efficient sunscreen."
Lovelock also believes that oomans are not threatened by the current anthropogenic depletion of the stratospheric ozone layer. He points out that there is a sevenfold difference between the amount of ultra-violet radiation at the poles and the level at the equator and concludes, "In spite of this large range of intensity, there is nowhere a region where the growth of vegetation is limited by ultraviolet. There are no ultraviolet deserts on Earth ..." 4.5: The Creation of a Stable Oxygen Atmosphere over the last 300 Million Years.
Dorian sagan & lynn margulis believe that Photosynthesizers have stabilized the level of atmospheric oxygen for the last 300 million years. If oxygen declined too much then the higher Animals would have been asphixiated. On the other hand, if it rose too much there would have been large scale conflagrations, "Thus the quantity of oxygen in the atmosphere must have remained relatively constant since the time that air-breathing Animals have been living in Forests - which has been over 300 million years." 4.6: The Role of Photosynthesis in the Creation of Soils, 400mya.
The first Plants to colonize the land had virtually no roots, "The earliest land plants were confined to a rhizome, an underground stem that could put out shoots but did not sink a solid grip into the ground." When these Plants died they decayed and created soils. The decomposition of terrestrial Photosynthesizers led to the creation of soils, "No cubic centimetre of the soil and sediment beneath is without its billions of microscopic organisms: the top soil has its photosynthesizing bacteria and nitrogen fixing microbes often attached to the roots of plants; its fungi, stones, moulds and teeming invertebrate life. The air in the soil is rich in carbon dioxide pumped down by life; dissolved in water near the rock surface, this causes rock weathering, speeded by microorganisms. Without life there would be no soil, but only regolith, the rock rubble of dead planets." Tyler volk states,"Without life and thus soil, every sunny day would be a drought, every rain a flash flood." As soils became deeper, Plants grew bigger, more complex, and their roots became longer. 4.7: Photosynthesis Boosts Rock Weathering.
Terrestrial Plants, especially Trees, absorb Carbon from the atmosphere and then pump it through their roots into the soil. In the soil it forms Carbonic acid. This reacts chemically with rocks creating chemicals and minerals which are nutrients for Photosynthesizers. Some of these nutrients leech through the soil to the sea where they are absorbed by marine Photosynthesizers. This boosts the burial of Carbon on the sea floor. The bigger the Photosynthesizers, the deeper their root systems, the greater the amount of Carbon pumped into the soil, the greater the extraction of nutrients, the greater the quantity of nutrients leeching into the sea, the greater marine Photosynthesis. The process of rock weathering is beneficial not only to terrestrial Photosynthesizers but to marine Photosynthesizers.
|
||
JOURNAL of CARBONOMICS - Issue 1 / Issue 2 / Issue 3 / Issue 4 / Issue 5 / Issue 6 / Issue 7 / Issue 8 / Issue 9 / Issue 10 |
JOURNAL of CARBONOMICS COUNTRIES - Issue 1 (Britain). |
JOURNAL of CARBONOMICS INDUSTRIES - Introduction |
GUIDES TO CARBONOMICS - Carb Overview - - Carb Summary - - Importance of the Carbon Spiral |
MUNDI CLUB HOME AND INTRO PAGES - Mundi Home - - Mundi Intro |
JOURNALS - Terra / Terra Firm / Mappa Mundi / Mundimentalist / Doom Doom Doom & Doom / Special Pubs / Carbonomics |
TOPICS - Zionism / Earth / Who's Who / FAQs / Planetary News / Bse Epidemic |
ABOUT THE MUNDI CLUB - Phil & Pol / List of Pubs / Index of Website / Terminology / Contact Us |
All publications are copyrighted mundi
club © You are welcome to quote from these publications as long as you acknowledge the source - and we'd be grateful if you sent us a copy. |
We welcome additional
information, comments, or criticisms. Email: carbonomics@yahoo.co.uk The Mundi Club Website: http://www.geocities.com/carbonomics/ |
To respond to points made on this website visit our blog at http://mundiclub.blogspot.com/ |