Welcome to the Review Section
of the site, here I will write reviews on the fanfiction that is on this
site. I will of course also except Reviews from you, if you do
want to write a review just write it and e-mail it to me at yuffiekisargi@hotmail.com.
I will have my own marking system but don't worry about suiting your review
to my system, do your own scheme if you so wish.
Lastly the reviews I post
here are by no means the correct view, I will try my best to be fair although
I can't promise to give every story superb/flattering marks. The reviews
will be under the marking system at the bottom of the page.
Here's the marking system:
Story/Basic Theme:
This will be marked out of 30 and the marks will be awarded by how good
I think the basic theme is and where I think the story is going, for example:
"Cloud buys some fruit":
This would get 1/30. There are no original ideas and it is boring.
"Vincent realises he
is another Sephiroth clone and goes in search of an answer to life": This
would get around 20/30. An original story but no real excitement.
Hope you get the idea.
Quality of Writing: This will also be marked out of 30 and the marks will be awarded for how good the standard of writing is. Some stories can be written beautifully with good descriptions and a good standard of atmosphere. Others are written poorly so that it is hard to tell what is happening or who is talking.
Universe: This
is marked out of 30 and is basically how well the author sticks to the
Characters and the surroundings of the original game. Not essential, but
if the some of the characters act completely differently it can be slightly
annoying, for example:
Yuffie acting in a shy,
quiet manner or Vincent dancing on tables.
Also if the world around
the characters is too different from the game it can be disorientating
or even just a bit silly.
Overall Enjoyment: This final section is also marked out of 30 and points are awarded for my overall impressions of the story and how much I enjoyed reading it.
Total Score: This is just a total score comprising of all four sections added together which will be a final score out of 120.
The Reviews will be placed
in alphabetical order by The name of the fic. To read a review click on
the name of the story.
A Flower In The Night By Rinoa Valentine- December 2000 Reviewed January 2001
A Secret Wish By Bill Carns - September 2000 Reviewed January 2001
The Reborn Saga By Samuel Gayton - September 2000 Reviewed January 2001
Insurrection
By Adam Jones -August
2000 Reviewed February 2001