Darold Leigh Henson's Review of
William Maxwell: A Literary Life
The following review of Dr. Barbara Burkhardt's
biography of William Maxwell was invited by the Journal of Illinois
History and appears in its spring, 2006, issue: Vol. 1, No. 1, pp.
72-74. Mr. Maxwell (1908-2000) was born and raised in Lincoln, Illinois, and
he used his hometown as subject matter in many short stories and novels and
one book-length family history.

William Maxwell: A Literary
Life
By Barbara Burkhardt. Urbana
and Chicago: University of Illinois Press, 2005. Pp. xiv, 308. $34.95.
The
frieze of the Illinois State Library, opened in 1990 and facing the state
Capitol, inscribes the names of thirty-five distinguished Illinois authors,
including that of William Maxwell (1908-2000). Maxwell, a native of Lincoln,
Illinois, led a dual literary life. For forty years (1936--1976), he was a
well-respected fiction editor of The New Yorker magazine. His career
as an author of autobiographical short stories and novels was even longer,
beginning with his first novel, Bright Center of Heaven (1934), and
ending with Billie Dyer and Other Stories (1992). Commonly acclaimed
as his masterpiece, So Long, See You Tomorrow (1980) won Maxwell the
prestigious William Dean Howells Medal from the American Academy of Arts and
Letters. Yet, despite these distinctions, no book-length study of his life
and work had appeared until Barbara Burkhardt published William Maxwell:
A Literary Life in 2005. She is a tenured faculty member in the English
Department of the University of Illinois at Springfield.
Readers of the Journal of Illinois History will be especially
interested in Professor Burkhardt's book because much of William Maxwell's
material is based on his childhood memories of Lincoln, Illinois, the first
town named for Abraham Lincoln, in 1853, before he became famous. In many
ways, Lincoln, Illinois, has always been representative of Midwestern small
towns. A thorough researcher and skillful writer, Burkhardt effectively
accommodates readers ranging from academic specialists in American
literature to educated laypersons. Also, readers both familiar and
unfamiliar with Maxwell will find Burkhardt's book engaging and informative.
In
the Introduction, Burkhardt precisely states her thesis: ". . . [H]e
[Maxwell] experimented with narrative technique, bringing new form to his
subjects as his view of them evolved over time. Early on [Virginia] Woolf
and company stirred him to create a distinctive form of the
tradition-breaking Modernism they practiced: He brought tough subjectivity,
in-depth psychological probing, and unremitting intensity to the substance
of his life and Midwestern homeland. Then, in small stages over many
decades, he pushed past his own practice to arrive at a distinctive form of
American Postmodernism that questions and foregrounds how we come to
understand the past, challenges how we can over know what 'really' happened
. . ." (page 8). Burkardt explains that Maxwell continually adapted his
material: "Each of his works brings new form, new possibilities to his
signature subjects--childhood and family life, the Midwest, the agony and
acceptance of loss--while navigating the delicate balance between human will
and fragility, between the concurrent tragedy and privilege of living" (page
8).
The
chapters of her book are chronologically sequenced to reflect Maxwell's
artistic development: "Childhood: A Lifetime of Material, 1908-33"; ". . .
Bright Center of Heaven, 1933-34"; ". . . They Came Like Swallows,
1934-38"; ". . . The Folded Leaf, 1938-45"; ". . . Time Will
Darken It, 1945-48"; ". . . The New Yorker and The Chateau,
1948--61"; ". . . Ancestors, 1961--71"; "Maxwell's New York,
1974--76"; So Long, See You Tomorrow, 1972--80"; and "Late Short
Works, 1980-92."
Each
chapter benefits from the prodigious research that Burkhardt began near the
time she first interviewed Maxwell in 1991, and these interviews continued
"once or twice a year" until six months before he died in 2000 (page 4). Her
scholarship also led her to investigate key sources of intellectual and
artistic influence on Maxwell: Virginia Woolf, Elinor Wylie, W.B. Yeats,
Walter de la Mare, Zona Gale, Louise Bogan, and the Freudian psychiatrist
Theodor Reik. Burkhardt's research included access to correspondence between
Maxwell and his father and stepmother, and this information helps Burkhardt
discuss the ways in which Maxwell uses them (and others) in his fiction and
memoir.
Burkhardt notes that despite Maxwell's focus on domestic life, his material
extends "beyond the home and into the community" (page 105) of the early
twentieth century. In her chapter on Time Will Darken It, Burkhardt
discusses how Maxwell's portrayal of Martha King and Nora Potter shows
females struggling with the limitations of gender roles imposed by society.
In several passages Burkhardt discusses the relationship between members of
the white upper middle class and their black servants. Yet, her biography
does not attempt a full discussion of social classes in Maxwell's canon.
This reviewer's reading of Maxwell's Lincoln-based works finds that various
main characters represent both town and country dwellers, and they span the
entire range of the middle class: upper, center, and lower.
More
than a year after its publication, William Maxwell has received
mostly high praise. Chris Lehmann's review in Washingtonpost.com
quotes and agrees with Burkhardt's claim that "perhaps no body of American
writing so fully captures the development of one person from childhood
through advanced years" (pp. 9-10). The privileged relationship between
Burkhardt and her subject, however, leads Morris Dickstein to qualify his
compliment. He writes in The New York Times that her book is "a
valiant attempt to chart the relations between the stories Maxwell told and
the stories he lived. It has all the benefits and some of the drawbacks of
an insider's project." Dickstein implies that Burkhardt is unwilling to
identify any weaknesses in Maxwell's art. Curiously, no negative criticism
of Maxwell appears in Dickstein's review. In a passage quoted from So
Long, See You Tomorrow, Burkhardt acknowledges Maxwell's self-awareness
that discovering and expressing the truth of human nature and life through
creative writing are difficult. Humility and wisdom are endearing qualities
in Maxwell that Burkhardt often cites. Just as Maxwell empathizes with those
who live by "the true feeling of the heart" (Ancestors, p. 252),
Burkhardt celebrates Maxwell's love of life and literature, and this
biography should inspire people to read Maxwell again and again.
Darold Leigh Henson,
Professor Emeritus of English
Missouri State University
Springfield
Links
Information about the Journal of Illinois History:
Quarterly of the Illinois State Historical Library (published by
the Illinois Historic Preservation Agency), including how to subscribe:
http://www.state.il.us/HPA/journal.htm
Site
dedicated entirely to William Maxwell: A Literary Life, including
passages from other reviews:
http://www.aliterarylife.com/
Summary of Darold
Leigh Henson,
"Social Consciousness in William Maxwell's Writings Based on Lincoln,
Illinois," which appeared in the Journal of the Illinois State Historical
Society (winter, 2005-06: 254-286).
University of Illinois Press Web page focusing on William Maxwell: A
Literary Life, including online ordering form:
http://www.press.uillinois.edu/s05/burkhardt.html
|