The Square of Opposition

  • The Square of opposition has categorical statements at its corners:


  • Those categorical statements help us make syllogisms, like this one:
    • All Socrateses are men.
    • All men are mortal.
    • Therefore, all Socrateses are mortal.

  • We test syllogisms for validity with Venn diagrams or with the Rules of Validity.

  • We will need to be able to convert statements into categorical form.
    The sun is shining.A: All things like the sun are shining things.
    Fred can sing.A: All things like Fred are singers.
    Some people cannot play the guitar.O: Some people are not guitar players.
    Napoleon was a great general.A: All things like Napoleon are great generals.

  • Some statements share important characteristics.
    • A & E statements are Universals.
    • I & O statements are Particulars.
    • A & I statements are Affirmatives.
    • E & O statements are Negatives.

  • In the Modern Square of Opposition, the only relationship that holds between statements is that of Contradictories.
    • A & O statements are Contradictories to each other.
    • I & E statements are also Contradictories to each other.

Square | Existential Import | Immediate Inference | Distribution | Question? | Self-tests | Logic Page 1