"Anyone
who attempts to construe a personal view of God which conflicts with
Church dogma must be burned without pity." - Pope Innocent
III
The Inquisition was an ecclesiastical court and process
of the Roman Catholic Church setup for the purpose towards the
discovery and punishment of heresy which wielded immense power and
brutality in medieval and early modern times. The Inquisitions function
was principally assembled to repress all heretics of rights, depriving
them of their estate and assets which became subject to the ownership
of the Catholic treasury, with each relentlessly sought to destroy
anyone who spoke, or even thought differently to the Catholic Church.
This system for close to over six centuries became the legal framework
throughout most of Europe that orchestrated one of the most confound
religious orders in the course of mankind.
Inquisition Procedure
At root the word Inquisition signifies as
little of evil as the primitive "inquire," or the adjective
inquisitive, but as words, like persons, lose their characters by bad
associations, so "Inquisition" has become infamous and hideous as the
name of an executive department of the Roman Catholic Church. All
crimes and all vices are contained in this one word Inquisition.
Murder, robbery, arson, outrage, torture, treachery, deceit, hypocrisy,
cupidity, holiness. No other word in all languages is
so hateful as this one that owes its abhorrent preeminence to its
association with the Roman Church.
In the Dark Side of Christian History,
Helen Ellerbe describes how the same men who had been both prosecutor
and judge decided upon the sentence of heresy. Once an Inquisitor
arrived to a heresy-ridden district, a 40 day period of grace was
usually allowed to all who wished to confess by recanting their faith.
After this period of grace had finished, the inhabitants were then
summoned to appear before the Inquisitor. Citizens accused of heresy
would be woken in the dead of night, ordered, if not gagged, and then
escorted to the holy edifice, or Inquisition prison for closer
examination.
In 1244, the Council of Harbonne ordered
that in the sentencing of heretics, no husband should be spared because
of his wife, nor wife because of her husband, and no parent spared from
a helpless child. Once in custody victims waited before their judge
anxiously, while he pondered through the document of their accusation.
During the first examination, enough of their property was likewise
confiscated to cover the expenses of the preliminary investigation. The
accused would then be implicated and asked incriminating and luring
questions in a dexterous manner of trickery calculated to entangle
most. Many manual's used and promulgated were by the grand inquisitor
Bernardus Guidonis, the Author of Practica Inquisitionis (Practice of
the Inquisition) and the Directorium Inquisitorum (Guideline for
Inquisitors) completed by Nicolaus Eymerich, grand inquisitor of
Aragon. These were the authoritative text-books for the use of
inquisitors until the issue of Torquemada's instructions in 1483, which
was an enlarged and revised Directorium. A Chapter of the Manual is
headed "of the torture" and contains these small reflections:
"The torture is not
an infallible method to obtain the truth; there are some men so
pusillanimous that at the first twinge of pain they will confess crimes
they never committed; others there are so valiant and robust that they
bear the most cruel torments. Those who have once been placed upon the
rack suffer it with great courage, because their limbs accommodate
themselves to it with facility or resist with force; others with charms
and spells render themselves insensible, and will die before they will
confess anything.
the author gives
further directions: “When sentence of torture has been given, and while
the executioner is preparing to apply it, the inquisitor and the grave
persons who assist him should make fresh attempts to persuade the
accused to confess the truth; the executioners and their assistants,
while stripping him, should affect uneasiness, haste, and sadness,
endeavoring thus to instill fear into his mind; and when he is stripped
naked the inquisitors should take him aside, exhorting him to confess,
and promising him his life upon condition of his doing so, provided
that he is not a relapsed (one delated a second time), because in such
a case they cannot promise him that."
Later afterwards in the sixteenth century, Cardinal
Giovanni Caraffa, a zealot for the purity of Catholicism who later
became the pope himself, also held a stern and gloomy view of moral
rectitude for heretics. In 1542, he was appointed by pope Paul III to
administer the Inquisition. The manuscript life of Caraffa gives the
following rules drawn up by Caraffa himself: "Firstly when
the faith is in question, there must be no delay; but at the slightest
suspicion, rigorous measures must be resorted to with all speed.
Secondly, no consideration is to be shown to any prince or prelate,
however high his station. Thirdly, extreme severity is rather to be
exercised against those who attempt to shield themselves under the
protection of any potentate, and fourthly, no man must lower himself by
showing toleration toward heretics of any kind."

The inquisition put their victims
to the test (here using the rack) Most defendants confessed in the long
run in order to escape the great anguish and bitter torture. Once found
guilty (regardless) they were handed over to the civil authorities to
be "relaxed" (that is of course, burnt alive)
Refusing to confess at the first hearing,
saw heretics being remanded to the prisons for several months. The
dungeons were situated underground, so that the outcries of the subject
might not reach other parts of the building. In some medieval cells,
the inauspicious were bound in stocks or chains, unable to move about
and forced to sleep standing up or on the ground. In some cases there
was no light or ventilation, inmates were generally starved and kept in
solitary confinement in the dark and allowed no contact with the
outside world, including that of their own family. In 1252, Pope
Innocent IV officially authorised the creation of the horrifying
Inquisition torture chambers. It also included anew perpetual
imprisonment or death at the stake without the bishops consent.
Acquittal of the accused was now virtually impossible. Thus, with a
license granted by the pope himself, Inquisitors were free to explore
the depths of horror and cruelty. Dressed as black-robed fiends with
black cowls over their heads, Inquisitors could extract confessions
from just about anyone. The Inquisition invented every conceivable
devise to inflict pain by slowly dismembering and dislocating the body.
Many of the devices were
inscribed with the motto "Glory be only to God." Bernardus
Guidonis, the Inquisitor in Toulouse instructed the layman as to never
argue with the unbeliever, but as to "thrust his sword into the
man's belly as far as it will go." George Ryley Scott describes how
the inquisitors, gorged with their inhumanity, and developed a degree
of callousness rarely rivaled in the annals of civilization, with the
ecclesiastical authorities condemning every faith outside of
Christianity as demonic.
Even the very fact of having a charge
brought against you, and of being summoned to the Inquisition was
sufficient to strike abject terror into the bravest man or woman. For
very few who entered the doors of that halls of torment emerged whole
in mind and body. If they escaped with their life, they were, with rare
exceptions, maimed, physically or mentally forever. Those who did
happen to endure the dungeons generally went mad in captivity,
screaming out in despair to escape their purgatories. Others willingly
committed suicide during their confinement. The defendant were known to
incriminate themselves at any chance they had to escape the horrors. As
Henry Charles Lea describes, one of the conditions of escaping the
penalities was that they stated all they knew of other heretics and
apostates, under the general terror, there was little hesitation in
denouncing not only friends and acquaintances, but the nearest and
dearest kindred--parents, children, brothers and sisters--this
ultimately and indefinitely prolonged the Inquisitions through their
associates. In the ages of faith, when the priest, was little less than
a god himself, a curse from his lips was often more feared than
physical torments. To even establish an accusation against a bishop
itself required 72 witnesses; against a deacon was 27; against an
inferior dignitary was 7, and for non-members of the clergy, 2 was
sufficient to convict. Whole communities went mad with grief and fear
of the thought towards being denounced to the Inquisition. It spread
all over Europe. Men, women, and children, all legally murdered on
evidence by a church, which today would only be accepted unless the
court and jury specifically composed of the inmates of a lunatic
asylum.
During
the course, defendants had no rights to counsel or advice, and was even
denied the right to know the names of their accusers. No favorable evidence or character witnesses were
permitted. In any case, one who even spoke for an accused heretic would
be arrested as an accomplice. Never would a prisoner of the
Inquisition have seen the accusation against himself, or any other. All efforts relating to time, place, and person were
carefully concealed. Henry Charles Lea describes however that evidence
was accepted from witnesses who could not legally testify in any other
kind of trial; such as condemned criminals, other heretics, or children
even as young as the age of two. The Inquisitor Jean Bodin (1529-96)
Author of De La Demonomanie des Sorciers (Of the Demonomania of
Witches) especially valued child witnesses for extracting confessions,
as they were easily persuaded to confess. Children though, were no
exception for being prosecuted and tortured themselves. The treatment
of witches' children was particularly brutal. Suspicion alone of
witchcraft would warrant torture. Once a girl was nine and a half, and
a boy was ten and a half, they were both liable to inquiry. Younger
children below this age were still nevertheless tortured to elicit
testimonies that could be used against their own parents. A famous
French magistrate was known to have regretted his leniency when,
instead of having young children accused of witchcraft burned, he had
only sentenced them to be flogged while they watched their parents
burn. The children of those parents murdered usually were force to beg
in vain upon the streets, for no one dared feed or shelter them thus
incurring a suspicion of heresy upon themselves. The suspicion was
sufficient enough to drive away even the closest kindred and friends of
the unfortunate. Sympathy for them would be interpreted as sympathy
with their heresy.

Put to the
torture using the Pulley--the accused confessed to anything and
everything that their tormentors wanted them to admit.
The pulley or strappado was the first
torture of the Inquisition usually applied. Executioners would hoist
the victim up to the ceiling using a rope with their hands tied
securely behind their back. They were then suspended about six feet
from the floor. In this position, heavy iron weights, usually amounting
to about 45 kg, were attached to their feet. The executioners would
then pull on the rope, then suddenly allowing it to slack causing the
victim to fall. The rapid descent would then come to an abrupt stop,
bewildering every joint and nerve in the system. In most cases it
entailed dislocation. This process was repeated again and again heavier
and more intense until the culprit confessed or became unconscious.
Christian Monks would stand by to record any confessions, with even
records today displaying the transformation of the monks steady
handwriting to vigorous shaking after they recanted inside the
dungeons. If a relapsed heretic refused to recant and endure the
torture, the contumacious sufferer was then carried to the scaffold and
his body bound to a wooden cross. There the executioner, with a bar of
iron, would break each leg and arm in two places and left to die. If
the heretic was slow to expire, the executioner would then partake to
strangulation, and their body was bound to a stake and burnt outside.
Papal Inquisition (1233)
At the close of the 12th century, heresy was spreading rapidly in
Southern France. Papal legates were sent by Pope Innocent III into the
disaffected district to increase the severity of repressive measures
against the Waldenses. The pope's inquisitors tried, condemned, and
were massacred offenders inflicting the death penalty with the
concurrence of the civil powers.
The Inquisition was also destined to become a permanent institution,
with the vigor and success of the Papal Legatine Inquisition assuring
this. The Fourth Lateran Council took the initial steps with Pope
Innocent III presiding, where the synodal courts were given something
of the character of inquisitorial tribunals. Synods were to be held in
each province annually, and violations of the Lateran canons rigorously
punished. The condemned were to be left in the hands of the secular
power, and their goods were to be confiscated. The secular powers were
admonished and induced, and, should it prove necessary, be compelled to
the utmost of their power to exterminate all who were pointed out as
heretics by the church. Any prince declining not to purge his land of
heresy was to be excommunicated. If he persisted, complaint was to be
made to the pope, who was then to absolve his vassals from allegiance
and allow the country to be seized by Catholics who should exterminate
the heretics. Those who joined in the crusade for the extermination of
heretics were to have the some indulgence as the crusaders who went to
the Holy Land.
In the face of this inexpugnable record, how futile it is for modern
church apologists to pretend that Rome did not shed blood, and was not
responsible for the atrocities of the Inquisition. The Council of
Toulouse in 1229 adopted a number of canons tending to give permanent
character to the Inquisition as an institution. It made or indicated
the machinery for questioning, convicting, and punishing. Heretics were
to be excluded from medical practice; the houses in which they were
found to be razed to the ground; they were to be delivered to the
archbishop, or local authorities; forfeiture or public rights could be
removed only by a papal dispensation; any one who allowed a heretic to
remain in his country, or who shielded him in the slightest degree,
would lose his land, personal property, and official position; the
local magistracy joined in the search for heretics; men from the ages
of 14, and women from 12, were to make oath and renew it every two
years, that they would inform on heretics. This made every person above
those ages a bloodhound to track to torture and kill. Local councils
added to these regulations, always in the direction of severity and
injustice. The organic development of the Papal Inquisition proceeded
rapidly. It was found that bishops, for the various reasons, would not
always enforce the cruel canons of the councils. So Pope Gregory IX in
August, 1231, put the Inquisition under the control of the Dominicans,
and order especially created for the defense of the church against
heresy. Dominican inquisitors were appointed for Aragon, Germany,
Austria, Lombardy, and Southern France.
The chronicle of the inquisitor Guilhem Pelhisso shows the most tragic
episodes of the reign of terror which wasted Languedoc in France for a
century. Guillaume Arnaud, Peter Cella, Bernard of Caux, Jean de St
Pierre, Nicholas of Abbeville, Foulques de St Georges, were all the
chief inquisitors who played the part of absolute dictatorship, burning
at the stake, attacking both the living and the dead. One of the
leading head Inquisitors of Germany was Conrad of Marburg. Stern in
temper and narrow in mind, his bigotry was said to be ardent to the
pitch of near insanity. Conrad was urged by Pope Gregory IX as to "not
to punish the wicked, but as to hurt the innocence with fear." History
shows us how far these Inquisitors answered to this ideal. Conrad
murdered and terrified countless people in pursuit of his duties,
regarding mental and physical torture as a rapid route to salvation. He
was given full discretionary powers, and was not required to hear the
cases, but to pronounce judgment, which was to be final and without
appeal-justice to those suspect of heresy. He was authorised to command
the aid of the secular arm, to excommunicate protectors of heresy, and
to lay interdict on whole districts. During his reign, he claimed to
have uncovered nests of "Devil worshippers" and adopted the motto "I
would gladly burn a hundred innocent if there was one guilty among
them.” Stimulated by this shining example, many Dominicans and
Franciscans merged with him, and became his eager assistants. He also
sentenced the feline cat to be forever viewed as a tool of
manifestation for witches and sorcerers. During the persecution of
heresy in the Rhineland's by Conrad, one obstinate culprit actually
refused to burn in spite of all the efforts of his zealous
executioners. A thoughtful priest brought to the roaring pile a
consecrated host. This at once dissolved the spell by a mightier magic,
and the luckless heretic was speedily reduced to ashes.
Other such inquisitors included Peter of Verona in
Italy, Robert the Bulgar in northeast France, and Bernardus Guidonis in
Toulouse. Guidonis, was considered the most experienced inquisitor of
his day, condemning roughly 900 heretics, with recorded sentences
pronounced after death against 89 persons during a period of 15 years.
Not only was their property confiscated and their heirs disinherited,
but they were subject to still further penalties. In the north of
France, the Inquisition was marked by a series of melancholy events.
Robert le Bougre, spent six years going through the Nivernais,
Burgundy, Flanders and Champagne, burning at the stake in every place
unfortunates whom he condemned without judgment.
Spanish Inquisition (1478-1834)
In 1478, the Spanish Inquisition was established with the papal
approval of pope Sixtus IV. The reform and extension of the ancient
tribunal which had existed from the thirteenth century was mainly to
discover and eliminate Jews and Muslims secretly taking up their
beliefs in private. The conduct of this holy office greatly weakened
the power and diminished the population of Spain. It was considered the
most deadliest and notorious of all Inquisitions, as firstly being, it
was the most highly organised and secondly, it was far more exposed and
open with the death penalty than that of the papal Inquisition. This
holy office became veiled by secrecy, unhesitatingly kept back,
falsified, concealed, and forged the reports of thousands of trials.
The first two Inquisitors in the districts of Seville
were appointed in 1480 by King Ferdinand and Queen Isabella to round up
the most wealthiest heretics; the reason for this, was that the
property of those accused, were shared equally between the Catholic
throne and the Dominicans. The Catholic Spanish government also
directly paid the expenses, and received the net income of the
Inquisition itself from the accused. According to civil law, people
convicted of religious treason were sentenced to death and their goods
confiscated while the Catholic Church feasted on their estate.
Additional Inquisitors were named, including Tomas Torquemada, who the
following year was appointed Inquisitor General for all of Spain.
Tomas, who's duty was to organise the rules of inquisitorial procedures
in Seville, Castille and Aragon. He believed punishment of heretics,
was the only way to achieve political and religious unity in Spain.
Those refusing to accept Catholicism where lead to the stake and burnt
alive in a procession and Catholic ceremony known as "auto-de-fe'" (act
of faith).
The conclusion of
an "auto de fe". Huge public burnings took place of those convicted of
Heresy.
Roman Inquisition (1542-1700)
In the early 1500's and 1600's, the Catholic Church went through a
reformation. It consisted of two related movements: (1) a defensive
reaction against the Reformation, a movement begun by Martin Luther in
1517 that gave birth to Protestantism, and (2) a Catholic reform which
saw Protestants declare war on Catholics. The Roman Catholic Church
called the Council of Trent partly as a defense against Protestantism.
In 1542, Pope Paul III (1534-49) established the Holy Office as the
final court of appeal in trials of heresy. The Church also published a
list of books that were forbidden to read. Heretical books were
outlawed, and searched out by domiciliary visits. Every book that came
was scrutinized minutely with the express object of finding some
passage which might be interpreted as being against the principles or
interests of the Catholic faith. The secular coadjutor were also not
allowed to learn to read or write without permission. No man was able
to aspire to any rank above that of which he already holded. The church
insisted on this regulation as a means to obtaining a perfect knowledge
of its subordinates. The censorship of books took three forms: (I)
complete condemnation and suppression; (2) the expunging of certain
objectionable passages or parts; and (3) the correction of sentences or
the deletion of specific words as mentioned. A list of the various
books condemned upon any of these three heads was printed every year,
after which anyone found to be in the possession of a volume coming
under section (I) or an unexpurgated or uncorrected copy of a volume
coming under section (2) or (3) was deemed guilty and liable to serve
punishment. The author and the publisher of any such book often spent
the remainder of their lives in the dungeons of the Inquisition. Its
overall goal was to eradicate Protestant influences in Europe.
A number of wars resulting from religious conflicts
broke out as well as the Catholic governments tried to stop the spread
of Protestantism in the country. Such attempts led to the civil war in
France from 1562 to 1598 and a rebellion in the Netherlands between
1565 and 1648. Religion was a major issue in the fighting between Spain
and England from 1585 to 1604. It was also a cause of the Thirty Years'
War 1618 to 1648, which centered in Germany, that eventually involved
all of the great nations of Europe halving its population. The estimate
of the death toll during the Inquisitions ranged worldwide from 600,000
to as high in the millions covering a span of almost six centuries.
Victor Hugo estimated the number of the victims of the Inquisition at
five million, it is said, and certainly the number was much greater
than that if we take into account, as we should, the wives and
husbands, the parents and children, the brothers and sisters, and other
relatives of those tortured and slaughtered by the priestly
institution. To these millions should properly be added the others
killed in the wars precipitated in the attempt to fasten the
Inquisition upon the people of various countries, as the Netherlands
and Germany.
|