STINGER MANPADS: SHARPENING THEIR COMBAT "EDGE"

MANPADS team prepares to repel a ground attack!

In the Spring '98 issue of ADA magazine online; EARLY ENGAGEMENT: Executing Combined Arms Stinger Ambushes by Captain Edward J. O'Neill, he speaks about how Stinger Man-Portable Air Defense Systems (MANPADS) use camouflage to evade detection by enemy aircraft in order to shoot them down:

"Hinds continue to wreck havoc in the brigade’s rear area. The sound of exploding Hemmits and ammunition in the ammunition holding area has finally convinced the brigade commander to send Stinger teams out to gain early engagement. The short-range air defense battery's 2nd Platoon leader works with the battalion S3, S2, fire support officer and S3 Air, to devise a plan to infiltrate two Stinger teams along air avenue of approach number three and four. It is believed these are the main ingress routes for the Hinds.

The platoon leader briefs and rehearses the Stinger teams. They are inserted at night via UH-60. Each team has four missiles and communications equipment to request assistance and send reports. After selecting positions, they cache their missiles and dig fighting positions, using natural camouflage to conceal their locations. The teams know that the best protection from the enemy is to avoid detection.

Early warning flashes across the teams' Hand Held Terminal Units (HTUs), alerting the teams to take action. It’s a 30-second sprint to their firing positions The HTUs depicts a pair of hostile rotary wing aircraft. The gunners shoulder their weapons and begin to search and scan. The team chiefs visually identify the aircraft as Hinds. They issue the firing commands, and the gunners send their missiles downrange for the intercept. Two Hinds are destroyed with the first volley. Team chiefs shoulder the next weapon, but the remaining two Hinds turn back, deterred by this unexpected threat."

THERMALS WORK BOTH WAYS

Its a good mission profile depicted above except for one thing: if the enemy helicopters have Forward Looking Infared (FLIR) they will spot the Stinger MANPADS team first from superior ranges and destroy them. This is exactly what AH-64A Apache gunships did for us sweeping the drop zones clear of enemy ADA 23mm guns in Panama before the Rangers and 82d Airborne jumped.

Apaches can self-deploy long distances to provide CAS to the Airborne

The AC-130 "Spectre" gunship does the same for longer range missions. The "edge" we have is seeing the enemy first with FLIR, and this advantage is held by our Avenger HMMWVs, Abrams and Bradley AFVs, too. It can be also used against us. Its wrong to assume we will "own the night" indefinately.

Stinger MANPAD teams need to employ anti-FLIR camouflage techniques and use their own FLIR devices to perfect them. This means covering their fighting positions with mylar "space" blankets to reflect their heat back and purchasing commercially-available MIL-SPEC "thellie" camouflage suits that render themselves invisible to FLIR detection.

Teledyne Brown Engineering: http://www.tbe.com/products/bushy/bushy.html

Perfect these techniques using OH-58D Kiowa Warrior scout helicopters with FLIR during freeplay field training exercises in order to insure the MANPADS teams have the "edge" they need in actual combat.

Kiowa Warriors have FLIR in a mast mounted sight so it can lurk below the treetops

BETTER HUMAN-INTERFACE WITH THE STINGER BEFORE LAUNCH

The Stinger missile is very long and thus, it needs a long tube to carry it. When I contacted the manufacturer, General Dynamics they said that even though there is dead space in the tube its too late to make it collapse like a LAW or a SMAW-D to make it more portable. Thus, the battle-proven Stinger which has killed aircraft from the Falklands to Afghanistan (mule carried no less!) has to be kept assembled to be ready to fire and its a real "bear" to keep on your shoulder.

First, put a curved foam pad that would slide up/down the missile tube to act as a shoulder pad/rest, not unlike bike frame pads for carrying them short distances over your shoulder. This would ease the strain of the 15 pound, 5 foot long missile on your shoulder for long engagements and faster target acquisition, steadier aiming and firing for better accuracy.

Next, the missile tube should have a "double-sling"--this is a sling that seperates into two straps so the Stinger can be carried "backpack" style away from the legs for better foot mobility while assembled.

HUMAN-POWERED VEHICLES FOR BETTER MOBILITY WITHOUT FLIR DETECTION

In the above scenario, MANPADS team members were inserted by helicopter and then walked to their firing positions. Having such transportation is unlikely in a pitched battle with competing demands for our own helicopters. If the MANPADS team uses a 4x4 HMMWV or any ground vehicle, its infared signature must be camouflaged or else it gives the MANPADS team away. What is needed is a mobility device that gives off no heat signature---human powered vehicles--bikes and carts.

There has been a long history of HPVs in military use: The Swiss today have 3 Bicycle-Infantry Regiments, Yamashita's Army over-ran Singapore/Malaya using bikes in the jungle, we used carts throughout WWII, particularly "Darby's Rangers" who could "speed-march" 10 miles in just 87 minutes. Being able to rapidly close on an enemy after insertion outside of sensor range by a motor air/ground vehicle is an important tactic to gain surprise on today's battlefield--a trademark in fact of the IDF Paratroopers.

Darby's Rangers in WWII

Darby's Rangers flying across the ETO battlefield

Of the two types of HPVs, the folding All/Extreme Terrain "Mountain Bike" is the best for it can give the MANPADS team 10-25 mph mobility to rapidly reposition themselves in the area they are defending to meet enemy air attacks. Used in conjunction with anti-FLIR techniques, they remain "invisible" to enemy aircraft detection; covering their A/ETBs with a space blanket when not moving.

1st TSG (A) Paratrooper cycling off the drop zone with a pair of night vision goggles to test night movement techniques

In terrains where the A/ETB cannot be cycled, it can be pushed like a cart. Stinger missiles tubes carried upright on the right/left and the rucksack on the top metal rack on the A/ETB.

C.O.M.E.T. enterprises padded airdrop bag for the folded A/ETB

The "folding" feature allows the A/ETB to compact for delivery by helicopter and fixed wing aircraft using parachutes. The folded A/ETB can be attached to the individual Paratrooper as a lowering line load in an airdrop bag or inside A-21 containers as door bundles recovered later on the Drop Zone (DZ). A single FIM-92 Stinger missile system can be jumped now attached to the individual Paratrooper using the Stinger missile jump pack or the new "AirPac" weapons case depicted below:

You have to stand tall to jump the Stinger!

The narrow tire ATB with solid foam inserts is impervious to any kinds of flats. The 10-inch wide "fat tire" ETB can be cycled over even soft sand and snow, giving FAAD teams superior, "stealthy" maneuverability than an enemy would expect them to have.

UT 2000 ATAC in action!

For situations where an extreme number of missiles need to be taken with the FAAD team not requiring rapid movement, the All-Terrain All-purpose Cart or "ATAC" would be employed. The ATAC that should be used is the UT 2000 system which is two backpacks that join to make a cart or sled body that can hold equipment, ammo or a wounded Soldier. With oversized wheels that can be placed at different spots to balance the load over the axle, the ATAC can be towed hands-free using a quick-release waist belt. The ADA Soldier can quick-release the waist belt and employ IMT and can always fire his shoulder weapon. If terrain not passable by rolling or sliding is encountered, the UT 2000 ATAC comes apart into manpacks to carry the Forward Area Air Defense (FAAD) team's loads, the cart itself is not dead weight. If FAAD teams with ATACs employ anti-FLIR techniques, they will be invisible as long as they cover the ATAC with a "space blanket" when static.

ATACs would be parachute delivered by A-21 door bundle using the truck bed liner plastic to insure clean exit through the jump door, or inside A-22 containers as part of the Container Delivery System (CDS) rolling out the rear ramp of designated aircraft. The ATAC can be fully loaded and roll off the rear ramp of CH-47D Chinook or out sideways from UH-60L Blackhawk aircraft.

ATACs and A/ETBs can roll off the rear ramps of Chinooks

ANTI-ARMOR ROLE FOR STINGERS?

If a dual anti-air/anti-tank warhead like the Canadian ADATS missile has now, were developed for the Stinger, MANPADS teams could also protect against enemy ground AFV attacks at the same time.

Legendary weapons theorist, Carlton Meyer (inventor of firing 2.75" rockets from Avenger HMMWVs) writes:

"Another recommendation to the corps was to test Stingers in the anti-armor role. If they can lock onto heat from an aircraft at 5 miles, at what range can they lock onto heat from a tank or APC engine. Stingers can be fired in a seek mode (no heat lock-on prior to visual launch). Perhaps they can engage tanks at over 5 miles. Can the impact of a supersonic Stinger knock out an APC, or a tank from a flanking shot? What about Stingers with shaped anti-armor warheads rather than anti-aircraft burst warheads. Shaped warheads should prove more effective against armored helicopters. The Avenger could rapidly fire eight fire-and-forget anti-armor missiles at an armored force, making it far more capable than current TOW systems."

IFF: WHO ARE THE GOOD GUYS?

FAAD teams lurking on the outer edge of the Airhead security line may be misidentified and engaged by our own aircraft especially if they are FLIR invisible. To prevent this and provide a clearly visible Landing Zone marker panel for insertions/extractions FLIR reflective VS-21 panels should be purchased as expendable items. These are IR reflective orange and camouflage on the opposite side nylon panels that can be turned over when a friendly aircraft radios in for authentication before landing. As an aside, at least one Soldier in every FAAD team should be sent to U.S. Army PATHFINDER school to fully exploit the air-ground delivery means available to light ADA systems like MANPADS and Avenger HMMWVs.

The future of war is AIRBORNE. The side that controls the AIR, controls the peace!

Murphy is in the sky!

Want Pvt Murphy in your pocket?

Return to U.S. Army Airborne Equipment Shop 1