Family Tree Maker(TM)
Warts
GenealogyLibrary
GenLib is a subscription service which makes available online
a large number of genealogy books that users can search and extract text.
Currently (April, 1999), there are more than 1700 books in the library,
and three additional books are added each business day.
|
Opinion
The many quality problems leads me to believe
that this ongoing work is not subject to any review whatever.
The total lack of repair of reported problems leads me
to believe that there is no established mechanism to apply "fixes". |
|
Search
|
|
Problems with tools that are
supplied to help you find information within the library and within the
books that it contains. |
|
-
A search shows the hits with the found search
arguments highlighted in the text. The search engine uses variations on
the arguments, such as singular/plural variations, but hits based on such
variations are not highlighted. The effect is that sometimes you can go
to a found page and see no highlighted text to identify what was found.
-
Search of the library for a name will list
found titles. One can then click on each title to list the specific hits
therein. Sometimes a title appears in the first list but a click on it
comes up dry. E.g. Search for "Abigail Fowler"
(Show Titles), then Show hits in "American
Ancestry, Columbia County, New York State". Result will be another search,
with no result found.
-
Search within a particular book, the hits
(found pages) are presented in descending (inverse) page order.
|
Show Titles
Note that if the initial
search uses the Show Text option, the Columbia County book does not appear
in the list. It is my belief that this is another manifestation of problem
#1. |
|
-
The GenLib repository has no mechanism to
find a particular book by either title or author. With a thousand volumes,
finding a book in the very limited classification
scheme is seldom successful. One must guess in which of the categories
the book may have been placed — a frustrating task when the book you are
seeking may easily have been placed in a number of the supplied categories.
This
book, for example, could well be filed in any of these categories:
-
History: United States (Civil War)
-
People: Surnames (Durfee) People:
-
Biographies (Durfee, Thomas)
-
Records: Bible Collections
-
Records: Court and Civil Proceedings
-
Places: United States (CT, RI or VT)
Using the supplied search mechanism will find the citations to the book
you seek as well as the book itself.
|
classification
This
book
24Jan1999
Note that the reference
number" in the example, "R100706", is of little use as there is no way
to use that to find the book, so it can hardly be called an "access number". |
|
-
Few books have had the
images from the original
scanned in (advertising hype notwithstanding). Of those that have been
included, problems of quality abound, including fuzzy
images and needlessly rotated images.
|
fuzzy |
Quality
|
|
-
Titles: "Connecticut Society of the Colonial
Danes
of America". Danes? " Silly,
but it will cause searches to fail, and how many people have blindly copied
it into their citations? (It should be "Dames", of course.)
-
Duplication: Books R100586 (1408) and R100917
(1701) are the same book! One has the
title taken from the title page, the other from the spine.
|
Danes?
same
book
|
-
Keyword Index: is plagued by many misspellings.
This
study of possible ways of misspelling "family" is missing only
"fambly" to make it complete.
|
This
study |
Navigation
|
|
Problems
related to moving about within the library and its books. |
|
-
Missing pages in
the original volumes are not noted. This
book is missing pages 64-76 (names between
Noland,
Rosette and Scott, Eveline), with no explanation.
-
Keyword Index:
The Keyword Index
is much more useful than the Subject Index, but it is buried with no link
provided from the GenLib home page.
-
Subject Index:
The Subject Index is of limited use for finding the many books which could
logically be placed in a number of subject categories; Each book is place
in only one category, with no consistency. So a specific book you
seek could be found just about anywhere.
|
This
book
Keyword
Index
|
-
Pagination of many books do not match
the originals, resulting in navigation and citation problems. About
1/3 of the books have incorrect
page numbers.
-
Subject
Index: Numerous books are placed in the wrong category outright.
Examples:
-
Several books about Wyoming county,
PA, are misfiled under the state Wyoming.
-
The book "The Descendants of Adam
Mott" is filed in "Top : Subjects : People : Surnames : A" rather than
"M"
-
The book "Founders of Old Dunstable"
is filed under "Surnames : S" (the author's name is Stearnes) rather than
"Places : Massachusetts"
-
"The Benson Family Records"
is filed among the "R" surnames.
-
Virkus's well known "Abridged Compendium"
is found among the "V" surnames.
-
"RYCKEN, HENDRICK, 1663, SUYDAM
FAMILY" erroneously filed under the "R" surnames, when it principally
concerns the Suydam family.
-
Subject
Index: No attempt is made to alphabetize the books listed within subject
categories. This is especially important within the Surname lists.
|
page
numbers
Pagination
I started reporting
specific pagination problems to Support in June of 1998 ( ),
but stopped after a few months when it became apparent that no fixes were
ever going to be made. Indeed, whatever flaw in their process permits these
to happen has not been corrected, as they still regularly appear with each
crop of new books. [RAD 10/1999] |
|
-
Subject
Index: Spurious categories. One wonders
how "Record : Marriage Records" (one book) is different from "Records :
Marriage" (764 books).
|
One
wonders |