Strategic Aspects of POP monitoring
Ñòðàòåãè÷åñêèå àñïåêòû ìîíèòîðèíãà ÑÎÇ
by Hoffmann M.,
Galagan A.A., Mykhaylenko V. P., Godina O. O. and Seleznev, A. N.
Centre of
Environmental Monitoring of Ukraine (CEMU), Kyiv
Ðåçþìå
Â
ðàáîòå îáñóæäàþòñÿ âîïðîñû ãåîãðàôè÷åñêîãî ðàñïðåäåëåíèÿ è
áèîàêêóìóëÿöèè ÑÎÇ â çàâèñèìîñòè îò èõ ôèçèêî-õèìè÷åñêèõ è
ìèêðîáèîëîãè÷åñêèõ ñâîéñòâ. Ïðåäñòàâëåíû ïåðâè÷íûå ðåçóëüòàòû
ìîíèòîðèíãîâûõ èññëåäîâàíèé ÏÕÁ, íà÷àòûõ Öåíòðîì â äåëüòå Äóíàÿ.
Îáñóæäàþòñÿ âîïðîñû ðàñïðåäåëåíèÿ è äåãðàäàöèè ÏÕÁ â èññëåäîâàííûõ
îáðàçöàõ íà ïðèìåðå ãîìîëîãîâ, ñóùåñòâóþùèõ â âèäå 209 ðàçëè÷íûõ
êîíãåíåðîâ. Ïîêàçàíî âëèÿíèå êîëè÷åñòâà àòîìîâ õëîðà íà èõ
áèîàêêóìóëÿöèþ è ïîñëåäóþùóþ äåãðàäàöèþ. Ïðèâåäåííûå ðàññóæäåíèÿ
ìîãóò áûòü ïîëåçíû äëÿ ñîñòàâëåíèÿ ïëàíà ìîíèòîðèíãîâûõ
èññëåäîâàíèé.
1. Introduction
Persistent organic pollutants (POPs) are known to be dangerous
not only because of their toxicity and resistance against
degradation. One of the main problems is their worldwide
distribution in the environment, in food chains and even in
humans. In the US and the EC, POP concentration in human fat
tissue and breast-milk has reached unexpected high concentrations.
It was discussed if breast-feeding of babies can still be
recommended. If one considers human bodies (hypothetically) as
waste, they would have been to be treated as “special refuse”
requiring a waste deposit place for dangerous materials.
Fortunately, newer investigations have shown that the
concentration of PCBs for example has already decreased in western
countries due to counter measures.
Counter measures require sophisticated action plans that are
based on the knowledge of POP occurrence in our environment. To
gain this knowledge, it is necessary to monitor POPs all over the
country in various environmental media for some time. This would
be a huge task and would require a corresponding financial basis.
It is therefore necessary to reduce the investigation volume and
to set priorities.
Setting monitoring priorities concerns several aspects as
-
Place of production
-
Transport and storage
-
Place of use
-
Physical, chemical and biological influences on the
further fate and distribution
2. Physico-chemical and biological
behaviour of POPs
This presentation will highlight a few aspects only that are
connected to the fourth item (see above). As an example, PCB have
been chosen for further consideration in this paper. Fig. 1 shows
the potential distribution paths of PCBs [1].

Fig. 1: Pathways of PCB
distribution in the environment [1]
The potential distribution of PCBs through wind and water
currents and erosion depends from the physico-chemical
characteristics of those compounds.
- Structure and size of molecules
- Temperature of freezing and boiling
- Evaporation curve and volatility from water
- Fat and water solubility (measured as octanol-water
partitioning coefficient)
- Adsorption and desorption
- Density, viscosity, permeability
- UV and light sensitivity
- Hydrolyse (depending on pH)
The further fate of PCBs and also other POPs depends on their
resistance against abiotic degradation (connected to the above
mentioned parameters) and against biotic degradation. The
biological degradability very much depends from the same
parameters as temperature, solubility, adsorption, permeability
etc. One of the main factors however is the degree and type of
chlorination. This factor has an influence on the distribution of
POPs and their possible toxicity and degradation. It is therefore
also an important strategic aspect for designing a monitoring
program. Again PCB have been selected as example because they are
widespread and highly dangerous for human health. The following
figure shows the structure formula of the molecule.

Fig. 2: PCB molecule with figures indicating
the possible Cl-positions [2]
Polychlorinated Biphenyls (PCB) appear in the form
of 209 Congeners (different molecules) with molar masses between
189 and 499 depending on the number of chlorine atoms; the table
lists the possible number of congeners.
Table 1: PCB homologes and number of congeners in each homolog [2]
Homolog |
Cl
Substituents |
PCB
Congeners |
Monochlorobiphenyl |
1 |
3 |
Dichlorobiphenyl |
2 |
12 |
Trichlorobiphenyl |
3 |
24 |
Tetrachlorobiphenyl |
4 |
42 |
Pentachlorobiphenyl |
5 |
46 |
Hexachlorobiphenyl |
6 |
42 |
Heptachlorobiphenyl |
7 |
24 |
Octachlorobiphenyl |
8 |
12 |
Nonachlorobiphenyl |
9 |
3 |
Decachlorobiphenyl |
10 |
1 |
Because of the big number of possible variants, a system of
sequential numbers, called "BZ Numbers" [3], for the 209 PCB
congeners was introduced providing a method of identifying a given
congener simply, precisely, and accurately. Today, the scheme of
the International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry (IUPAC) is
commonly used. It overtook the same BZ numbers but changed the
name of congeners in several cases.
PCB are produced and used as a mixture of congeners and can be
found in special oils, colours, transformers, also in households,
e.g. as softener in plastics. If the congener mixture is “highly
halogenated” (up to 60 % of chlorine content) it will not be
flammable anymore. This is why PCB were used mainly in open and
closed systems to protect against fire. In Germany for example
since 1972, the use of PCB is restricted to closed systems, in
1983 the production of PCB was terminated. Congeners with 1 to 4
Cl-atoms (< ~ 30 % Cl) are called “weakly halogenated”. Compared
with “weakly halogenated” PCB, “highly halogenated” PCB are
- less soluble in water (more lipophil)
- stronger enriched in the food chain
- less degradable by bacteria.
This is the reason why the proportion of “highly halogenated”
PCB (compared to “weakly halogenated” PCB) increases in the food
chain. After sufficient time for degradation, for example in river
sediments, the proportion of “weakly halogenated” PCB can be
increased. The following table shows examples of PCB accumulation
in various materials.
Table 2: Examples of PCB
concentrations detected in environmental samples and milk [1]
Type of
sample |
mg/kg |
seawater (in
mg/L) |
(0.000 002) |
sea sediment |
0.02 |
sea mammals |
160 |
freshwater sediment |
0.02 |
macrophytes (water plants) |
0.04 |
plankton |
0.39 |
mussels |
0.6 |
fish |
3.2 - 4.0 |
eggs of Podiceps cristatus
(L.) (fish-eating bird) |
56 |
cow milk |
0.01 - 1.6 |
human breast milk |
0 - 10 |
The toxicity of PCB varies very much depending on the position
of the chlorine atoms. If they are in the position 2, 6, 2’ and 6’
(compare fig.2) the PCB are ortho-substituted. They are known to
have neurochemical and neurobehavioural effects. Non-ortho or
mono-ortho substituted PCB show toxicological effects similar to
those of dioxins. Some animals as dolphins are unable to degrade
those non-ortho substituted compounds and are therefore highly
endangered to accumulate lethal quantities [4].
3. Degradation
The degradation of POPs, especially of DDT and PCB, is known to
be difficult and very slowly. This difficulty is increased after
adsorption on soil particles and protection against UV radiation.
The degradation of DDT is a question of decades that of PCB lasts
even longer time. The process can be divided into following steps:
- hydrolyse
- dechlorination
- oxidations and reductions

Fig. 3: Example scheme of
PCB degradation [1]
The following statements are related on the degradation of PCB.
In general one can
say that
- the higher the chlorine contents of the compound, the more
difficult the degradation process.
- The location of the Cl-atoms on the molecule is very
important too: the p- and the m-configuration facilitate the
degradation.
- If two neighbouring C-atoms are free of chlorine, the
degradation will be easier. Free 3,4-positions are optimal for
degradation.
- Hydroxy-derivates can be more toxic than the original
compound.
4. Recommendations for the monitoring
The monitoring program should follow the usual international
standards for planning, sampling, stabilisation and transport of
samples [5, 6 and so on]. Like heavy metals POPs are enriched on
adsorbing surfaces (clay, phytoplankton), the uptake through
macrophytes is less important. Therefore, in case of water
samples, it is recommended to analyse suspended matter (gained
through centrifugation) or otherwise, if the whole water sample is
analysed, the amount of suspended matter or phytoplankton should
also be controlled.
Sediment samples have to be carefully selected. In natural
waters, the local and spatial distribution of the different
sediment types should be known and a decision been made on the
depth of sediment sampling (depending on the investigated
problem). In the laboratory, sediment samples should be sieved to
exclude the biggest fraction (according to international standards
> 2 mm) and additional determinations of “Co-factors” should be
carried out as particle size distribution, content of organics
etc. for further ecological interpretation.
If mussels are collected, the species should be identified and
their age. Both parameters have an influence on the fat content.
The analytical procedures and information on the equipment
complete the picture. As it is very labor intensive to analyse all
209 congeners, seven guide-PCB have been selected that were
frequently produced and often found in environmental samples:
According to an international agreement this concerns the PCB
IUPAC Nr. 28, 52, 101, 118, 138, 153, 180. For the sum of these
guide congeners (“S PCB7”) the European OSPAR commission has
defined threshold values for fish and mussels. For sediments,
German investigators have found that S PCB7 is critical if 450
mg/kg (dry weight) are exceeded; in case of higher values PCB can
be expected in fish as well [7]. Comparisons with literature data
will only be possible if all monitoring methods are accurately
harmonised.
-
First results of Danube
delta monitoring and comparisons
Monitoring of a selected number of POPs in the frame of the
Danube delta monitoring programme [8, 9] is one of the tasks that
have been overtaken from the Centre of Ecological Monitoring of
Ukraine. Sampling was started in autumn 2004 and will be
continued 3 times per year until 2006. The analyses of PCB were
carried out by the L.I.Medved Institute of Ecohygiene and
Toxicology, Kyiv. Results of sediment analyses are related to the
dry weight of the complete sample, mussel results are related to
the wet weight of the soft part and water samples have been used
unchanged. Beside the compounds listed in the following table, 8
different poly-aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH) have been additionally
analysed.
Table 3: Results of PCB
analyses, given in mg/kg, from different sample types collected in
the Ukrainian part of the Danube delta. (PDK = 0.06 mg/kg;
Sanitary norm
¹4433-87
related to soil samples)
|
Sample -à
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
/Homolog |
Sediment
02 |
Sediment
03 |
Sediment
04 |
Mussel
02 |
Mussel
03 |
Water
02 |
Water
03 |
Water
04 |
|
Monochlorobiphenyl |
<0,0001 |
<0,0001 |
<0,0001 |
0,0114 |
0,0065 |
<0,0001 |
<0,0001 |
<0,0001 |
|
Dichlorobiphenyl |
<0,0001 |
<0,0001 |
<0,0001 |
<0,0001 |
<0,0001 |
<0,0001 |
<0,0001 |
<0,0001 |
|
Trichlorobiphenyl |
0,0100 |
0,0143 |
0,0086 |
<0,0001 |
<0,0001 |
0,0004 |
0,0005 |
<0,0001 |
|
Tetrachlorobiphenyl |
0,0049 |
0,0027 |
0,0049 |
0,0072 |
0,0009 |
0,0001 |
<0,0001 |
<0,0001 |
|
Pentachlorobiphenyl |
0,0063 |
0,0083 |
0,0065 |
0,0017 |
0,0020 |
0,0003 |
0,0002 |
<0,0001 |
|
Hexachlorobiphenyl |
0,0036 |
0,0025 |
0,0014 |
0,0063 |
0,0066 |
0,0003 |
0,0001 |
<0,0001 |
|
Heptachlorobiphenyl |
0,0060 |
0,0040 |
0,0042 |
0,0184 |
0,0071 |
0,0001 |
<0,0001 |
<0,0001 |
|
Octachlorobiphenyl |
<0,0001 |
<0,0001 |
<0,0001 |
<0,0001 |
<0,0001 |
<0,0001 |
<0,0001 |
<0,0001 |
|
Σ PCB |
0,0308 |
0,0318 |
0,0256 |
0,0450 |
0,0231 |
The results show that highly chlorinated congeners as
octachlorobiphenyl have not been detected. The same is true for
nonachlorobiphenyl and decachlorobiphenyl that are not listed in
the table. The sum of PCB concentrations in the mussels
(Sinanadonta woodiana ) differ very much. In comparison with the
sediment analyses they contain more highly chlorinated compounds
(heptachlorobiphenyl) than the sediments. This can be connected to
their higher fat content. On the other hand, sediments contain
more weakly chlorinated compounds as trichlorobiphenyl. The reason
could be the less lipophil character of those compounds or the
result of the beginning bacterial degradation.
The water samples are also contaminated, but for an assessment
of results it is necessary to clarify further details and to await
future monitoring results.
Literature
- SCHWEDT, G. (1996): Taschenatlas der Umweltchemie – G.
Thieme Verlag, Stuttgart. ISBN 3-13-103111-5 (in German)
- U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) (2005):
Polychlorinated Biphenyls (PCBs), website, url:
http://www.epa.gov/toxteam/pcbid/defs.htm
- BALLSCHMITER and ZELL (1980): Analysis of polychlorinated
biphenyls (PCB) by glass capillary gas chromatography.
Fresenius Z. Anal. Chem. 302:20-31. 1980.
- BODO, B. A. (1998): An Assessment of Environmental and
Aquatic Ecosystem Contamination by Persistent Organochlorine
Pollutants (POPs) in the Russian Federation – GEMS, Burlington,
Canada
- EN ISO 5667-3 (in English), (2002) : German title :
Wasserbeschaffenheit – Probenahme – Teil 3: Anleitung zur
Konservierung und Handhabung von Proben (ISO/DIS 5667-3:2002)
- EN ISO 5667-19 (in English), (2002): German title:
Wasserbeschaffenheit – Probenahmeverfahren – Teil 19: Anleitung
zur Probenahme von Sedimenten in der marinen Umwelt (ISO/DIS
5667-19:2002
- Umweltbundesamt FG II 3.6 (2000): Erfahrungsaustausch
„Marines Sediment Monitoring“, 4.7.-5.7. 2000 Koblenz –
Conferece minutes of the AG Qualitaetssicherung des
Bund/Laender-Messprogramms Nord- und Ostsee (in German)
- KVET, J. and SALATH, T. (2003): Mission Report Danube
Biosphere Reserve / Kyliiske Mouth Ramsar Site Ukraine 27-31
October 2003
- Ministry of Environment of Ukraine: Conclusion by the
Ministry of environment of Ukraine of the state environmental
review of the working design documents on the project
"construction of the Danube-black sea deep-water navigation
route in the Ukrainian part of the Danube delta: phase 1";
http://www.ukraine-eu.mfa.gov.ua/cgi-bin/valmenu_miss.sh?1p0201.html
|