ALEXANDRA
***
Russia/France/Italy
Alexander Sokurov presents a war film bereft of warfare in his
characteristically dreamy, meditative fashion. Russian opera diva Galina
Vishnevskaya plays Alexandra, who visits her beloved grandson at his army
base, which is technically situated in Chechnya, though it stands in for
every squalid war zone in the world. Sokurov's anger - disguised as it is
with serene music and photography - isn't necessarily directed at the
state of things in Chechnya but at the state of things in the world and in
history as brought on by man's ('man' as in 'not woman', not 'man' as in
'mankind') hollow, destructive war instinct. And although it meanders and
too often coasts on the surreal imagery of a babushka hobbling about a
military zone, the picture is marked by the elegance and sincere humanity of
his best work.
wr/dir: Alexander Sokurov
cast: Galina Vishnevskaya, Vasily Shevtsov, Raisa Gichaeva
THE
ASSASSINATION OF JESSE JAMES BY THE COWARD ROBERT FORD
***˝
USA
In revising the cult-friendly allure of Jesse James and his death through
existential malaise, ruthless skull-obliterating and a moody-muddy palette,
Andrew Dominik is openly riffing on the likes of Terrence Malick, Sam
Peckinpah and Robert Altman. On the one hand, this is commendable, but on
the other hand, if he wasn't calling on such forbidding connotations, his
own film could much more comfortably be categorised as a success. This way
its shortcomings are all the more conspicuous: the unproductive
book-on-tape voiceover; the polite, generic score; the role of women
restricted to voiceless housewifery; the conspicuous abundance of rippling
wheat fields; the turgid, squinting wisdom-dispensing. The movie is as
infatuated with itself as it is with Jesse James and Robert Ford.
As Jesse James Brad Pitt hogs most of the monologues and top
billing, but it's Casey Affleck as Bob Ford who delivers the depth, gives
the movie oxygen and some murky, arresting humanity. Effacing any trace of
ego, he's as subtle and natural when his voice shivers as the star-struck
teenager, when it catches as the put-upon youngest brother and when it
rips as the charred national pariah. A thing of unassuming beauty, his
performance counterpoints the movie's mannered lyricism and pushes it onto
a human plane.
wr/dir: Andrew Dominik
ph: Roger Deakins
cast: Casey Affleck, Brad Pitt, Sam Rockwell, Mary-Louise
Parker, Sam Shepard, Jeremy Renner, Garret Dillahunt, Paul Schneider, Ted
Levine, James Carville, Zooey Deschanel, Nick Cave
ATONEMENT
***
UK/France
In the sections where director Joe Wright keeps his showboating tendencies
in check his adaptation of Ian McEwan's absorbing if overtly mannered WWII
meta-morality-tale flows elegantly. But beyond the first third Wright
rarely remembers to restrain himself or his unfortunate tendency to
squeeze out poignancy and advertise subtext. That, and the central romance
comes off lop-sided. McAvoy is adequate but Knightley, looking morbidly
skeletal, is too strained by her practiced if admittedly polished
elocution to give off much warmth.
dir: Joe Wright
cast: James McAvoy, Keira Knightley, Saiorse Ronan, Romola
Garai, Vanessa Redgrave, Harriet Walter, Brenda Blethyn, Juno Temple,
Benedict Cumberbatch, Alfie Allen, Felix von Simson, Charlie von Simson
BEAUFORT
**˝
Israel
In May 2000 Israel was forced to evacuate its mountaintop fortress in
Southern Lebanon and, if you were to believe Israel's official Academy
Award submission for the year, the soldiers that still remained were
exclusively the most photogenic men in the country.
Like all credible anti-war filmmakers, Joseph Cedar avoids
pointing fingers and taking sides and focuses instead on the frail, weary
humanity of his soldiers. The script he has co-written with Ron Leshem and
adapted from his own novel is moderately sober, all them pretty men in the
cast are solid performers and the sets - which, for obvious reasons, had
to be custom-built - are detailed and scream big budget. And therein lies
the problem. The grit feels manufactured. The picture is glazed in a
Hollywood sheen that is polished, eminently exportable and ideally suited
to a video clip. And when it comes to earnest drama, it only
takes away from the immediacy.
dir: Joseph Cedar
cast: Oshri Cohen, Itay Tiran, Eli Eltonyo, Itay Turgeman, Ohad
Knoller, Arthur Faradjev, Gal Friedman, Danny Zahavi, Daniel Bruk
BEFORE
THE DEVIL KNOWS YOU'RE DEAD
*˝
USA
An offensively grandstanding, fatalistic mediocrity where two morbidly
maladjusted brothers - who, between them, have acted on every
self-destructive impulse known to Paul Haggis - decide to rob their Mom
and Dad's jewellery store. The plot jumps back and forth in time, but
don't panic, intertitles and a drum roll announce every flashback for your
convenience. This snazzy stylistic tic - one of many embraced by the
once-brilliant Sidney Lumet - fits beautifully within the film's
overarching principle of exposition-hysteria-then-more-exposition.
Self-loathing-heroin-abusing-Father-hating-yuppie-embezzling
older brother Philip Seymour Hoffman opines in one of several strained
monologues: "I don't add up." So, do take note, when he says and
does things without a coherent motive, it's not because he's six
stereotypes crudely stitched together. It's because he's so mind-bendingly
real, man.
Ethan Hawke spends the film jittering uncontrollably - lest
you shift your attention to a cast mate - as the younger brother, who
would make an infinitely more convincing junkie, though you never see him
injecting anything conspicuous.
Albert Finney plays a father guilty of never expressing
emotion, with the gusto of an Oscar-hungry father more likely to have
traumatised his children into inertia through expressing his emotion too
much. (In his defence, it's easy to see how his scenery-chewing genes
could lead to a chronically jittery Ethan Hawke). Marisa Tomei spends half
her screen-time topless (and the other half - awkward), playing a plot device to ratchet up the
melodrama. The supporting cast also includes ghetto stereotypes, the ever
dependable Rosemary Harris (who gives the film's single grounded
performance in its single grounded scene), a shrill ex-wife who repeats
roughly three lines of dialogue incessantly and at the same pitch, as well
as a little girl to remind Hawke and the audience by phone: "But Dad!
You promised to pay for my excursion to see The Lion King!"
dir: Sidney Lumet
wr: Kelly Masterson
cast: Philip Seymour Hoffman, Ethan Hawke, Albert Finney, Marisa
Tomei, Rosemary Harris, Aleksa Palladino, Michael Shannon, Amy Ryan, Brian
F. O'Byrne, Blaine Horton
BLIND
MOUNTAIN
****
China
Wholesome university graduate Huang Lu is cheerily toiling her way through
rural China, working for a distributor of medical instruments in order to
pay off her family's debts. One morning she wakes up to discover she
has been sold into marriage to an uncouth, uneducated peasant and is to
feed the pigs, bear children and have no further say in the matter.
In his gracefully gut-wrenching verité suspense drama, Li
Yang tracks Huang's harrowing escape attempts in a low-key, unfussy style
traditionally suited to dusty odes to faintly exotic country life. In
pretending he isn't doing it on purpose, he draws out your disgust and
outrage with beguiling mastery (which is why a certain cathartic third-act
incident has been repeatedly greeted with rabid applause at festival
screenings around the world). He's essentially playing dumb, taking the
perspective of an ambivalent observer allowing ugly things to take place
against pretty scenery and seeing nothing unusual in the matter - which,
he implies, is a common enough attitude in rural China where bride
trafficking remains widespread.
wr/dir: Li Yang
ed: Li Yang, Mary Stephen
cast: Huang Lu
BREATH
**˝
South Korea
Ever since he turned meditative, Kim Ki-duk has been teetering down a fine
line between poignant and cutesy. In this love story between a lonely
housewife and a killer on death row, you are to determine at your own
discretion whether Kim's characters are quirky-melancholic people, or
quirky-melancholic caricatures of morbidly maladjusted people. They're
endearing - to a point - but they don't resonate.
wr/dir: Kim Ki-duk
cast: Chang Chen, Ha Jung-woo, Kim Ki-duk, Park Ji-a
CARGO 200
***
Russia
A moody Soviet slasher flick with a strange notion of social conscience.
Set in 1984, it's woven around an impotent police chief with party membership
who kidnaps a teenager
and devises increasingly sadistic ways to humiliate and torture her.
Whatever points director Alexei Balabanov wants to make about the
corruption and zombie-like depersonalisation of USSR on the cusp of the
perestroika are
undermined by his ambivalent attitude towards the victim. He treats her
and her horrific degradation as just a plot point.
The story is reportedly
'based on real events' - which is part of what makes it such compulsive
viewing - though Balabanov appears to have taken considerable poetic
licence.
wr/dir: Alexei Balabanov
ph: Alexander Simonov
cast: Alexey Serebryakov, Leonid Gromov, Yuri Stepanov, Agniya
Kuznetsova, Alexei Poluyan, Natalya Akimova, Valentina Andryukova, Leonid
Bicevin
CLUBLAND
**˝
Australia
An Aussie variation (with a seasoned Brit in the lead) on those
dysfunctional family quirkfests that bag multimillion-dollar distribution
deals at Sundance. Brenda Blethyn plays a failed stand-up comedian, who
grows uncomfortably overprotective of her son when he starts getting laid.
It's cloying and derivative, but fortunately watchable thanks entirely to
an ensemble's worth of intelligent, natural performers (aside from one
conspicuous exception).
Out of consideration for fat Americans in the mid-West,
they're referring to the movie as "Introducing the Dwights" in
certain territories.
dir: Cherie Nowlan
cast: Brenda Blethyn, Khan Chittenden, Emma Booth, Katie Wall,
Frankie J. Holden, Emma Booth, Rebecca Gibney, Richard Wilson
CONTROL
**˝
UK/USA
As far as biopics of troubled musicians go, this one, detailing the
personal more than the creative life of Joy Division's Ian Curtis, is a
watchable one, though it's deeply flawed. Director Anton Corbijn and
writer Matt Greenhalgh - predictably - want to present Curtis (played by
Sam Riley) as a misunderstood genius, yet they give him the dialogue of an
angsty teenager. And, with his emotional range limited between skinny
brooding hipster and skinny misty-eyed hipster, Riley doesn't contribute
any further layers. Within this context, even his lyrics sound whiny.
You're bound to feel sympathy for a man driven to suicide at the age of 23
by epilepsy and mistakes he made as a teen, but you can do that from
reading a newspaper article. The Ian Curtis who mopes and hazes his way
through Corbijn's film doesn't warrant feature length nor Samantha Morton
as his wife (doing her best with a dog of a role).
It has to be noted though that while Corbijn fails to grasp
the complexity of Curtis' character, he does capture the beauty and impact
of his music.
dir: Anton Corbijn
cast: Sam Riley, Samantha Morton, Alexandra Maria Lara, Joe
Anderson, Toby Kebbell, Craig Parkinson, James Anthony Pearson, Harry
Treadaway, Andrew Sheridan, Robert Shelly
THE
DARJEELING LIMITED
**˝
USA
Various quirky misadventures befall Owen Wilson, Jason Schwartzman and
Adrien Brody playing depressed brothers on a quirky spiritual quest aboard
a quirky, lumbering locomotive traversing the cleanest parts of India.
It's ironic that moving out of an oppressively art directed studio has
resulted in Wes Anderson's first thoroughly airless picture. The trouble
isn't in the rigid visual composition, cutesy humour or self-consciously
hipster soundtrack so much as it is in the hollowness of the protagonists.
Their crises feel cursory. They only serve to accentuate the artifice of
the whole venture. Anjelica Huston pops up towards the end to breathe
some life into the story, but it's too little too late.
dir: Wes Anderson
wr: Jason Schwartzman, Roman Coppola, Wes Anderson
cast: Owen Wilson, Adrien Brody, Jason Schwartzman, Amara Karan,
Waris Ahluwalia, Anjelica Huston, Irfan Khan, Wallace Wolodarsky, Bill
Murray, Natalie Portman
DEATH
PROOF
***
USA
Tarantino's Cannes-endorsed half of the quickly buried Grindhouse
double-bill is technically set in the present day, while he works hard to
convince you it was filmed in the early 1970s. He puts in plenty of blips
and scratches, colour drop-outs, 'missing reels' and brazen, extended
close-ups of comely women's asses wiggling in hot pants.
Tarantino piled on roughly 20 minutes worth of footage from
the cutting room floor to transform his half-movie into a stand-alone
feature. It's essentially two hardcore action sequences pitting a
homicidal stunt driver against said comely women, padded out with about an
hour's worth of a high-school-girl's conception of sassy Sex-and-the-City
talk. Since there's no plot or character to speak of, it would appear that
the talky segments were put in for purposes of tawdry atmosphere and
iconic posturing - except that the dialogue is inane in a very flavourless
way, and there is nothing iconic about the ladies dishing it out. Few of
them muster up much screen presence and several of them - particularly
stunt-woman-turned-bad-actress Zoe Bell - are plain grating. So once the
long-awaited reel comes about where they fall into mortal danger, the
movie's tension is compromised by the realisation that their death would
mean their forever shutting up.
That said, none of them get to do much acting or speaking
during the chases, joy rides, dismemberments and head-on collisions. These
are thrilling in the best empty-visceral Tarantino fashion.
wr/dir/ph: Quentin Tarantino
cast: Kurt Russell, Zoe Bell, Rosario Dawson, Vanessa Ferlito,
Sydney Poitier, Tracie Thoms, Rose McGowan, Jordan Ladd, Mary Elizabeth
Winstead, Quentin Tarantino, Eli Roth
EASTERN
PROMISES
***
USA
On the level of campy fun, David Cronenberg's blood-and-entrail-
laden foray into murky Russian mafia transactions in London's underworld
works perfectly well. Except then you're asked to accept for human-like
characters the sadistic brutes who, for commercial purposes, spik to each
odder in hevily akcented Inglish and kan even temporarily survive being
stabbed through the heart. Not to mention the dead teenage mother, who
reads out [again, in Slavic-inflected English] voiceover pages and pages
of seemple-Rrrussian-girl dreams and expositori backstory from her diary
(all to the accompaniment of the world's whiniest violin). On this level
of projected human drama, the whole thing amounts to one dumb joke.
(And is a single one of the actors genuinely Russian?)
dir: David Cronenberg
cast: Viggo Mortensen, Naomi Watts, Vincent Cassel, Armin
Mueller-Stahl, Sinead Cusack, Jerzy Skolimowski, Donald Sumpter
ENCHANTED
***˝
USA
Yet another animated Disney princess' courtship by Prince Charming is
interrupted - only this time she's magically transported to a New York
City sewer in the shape of Amy Adams. The script is only half-there, but
on its own G-rated terms, the finished product is shockingly enjoyable in
large part because of Adams' immobilising charm and conviction.
dir: Kevin Lima
cast: Amy Adams, Patrick Dempsey, James Marsden, Susan
Sarandon, Timothy Spall, Idina Menzel, Rachel Covey
FORBIDDEN LIES
***˝
Australia
Comfortably the most compelling Australian picture of the season, Anna
Broinowski’s documentary inspects the case of author Norma Khouri, who
sold her Jordanian-honour-killing exposé ‘Forbidden Love’ as an
autobiographical piece until a pair of diligent Aussie reporters
discovered she was in fact an American con-artist wanted by the FBI. In
the beguiling, confounding, continually shape-shifting Khouri, Broinowski
stumbled upon a goldmine – the woman is compulsive viewing on her own,
so all the cutesy flash montages and chapter sub-headings that Broinowski
piles on tend to distract from the story more than they jazz it up. And
though it’s a polished and expensive-looking piece of work, there is
nothing inherently cinematic about the way it's been put together. But
with such a dazzling, twist-ladden, larger-than-life tale, it’s enough
that you’re able to follow the multiple lies-within-lies-within-lies
(not to mention that you’re given the opportunity to watch Khouri in
interview) and Broinowski ought to be praised for that.
dir: Anna Broinowski
4 MONTHS, 3 WEEKS AND 2 DAYS
*****
Romania
Unfolding across a few hours not long before the decline of Causescu's
Romania, Cristian Mungiu's wrenching tale of two university students going
about an illegal abortion may be the two most vividly horrific hours
you'll ever spend in a cinema. It's as much an urban tragedy as it is a
snapshot of a tattered, festering society, written, directed and performed
with miraculous insight and subtlety. It's not only one of the great films
of the decade, but one of the great films, period. It's also the first
instalment in a series of Romanian films, ironically titled Tales of the
Golden Age. (And it gives me a very warm feeling to watch an obscure
Eastern European country experience a New Wave of its own.)
wr/dir: Cristian Mungiu
ph: Oleg Mutu
ed: Dana Bunescu
cast: Anamaria Marinca, Laura Vasiliu, Vlad Ivanov, Alexandru
Protocean, Luminita Gheorgiou, Adi Carauleanu, Liliana Mocanu,
Tania Popa, Teo Corban, Cerasela Iosifescu, Doru Ana, Eugenia Bosanceanu,
Ioan Sabdaru, Cristina Buburuz, Marioara Sterian
LA FRANCE
**
France
In Serge Bozon's aggressively eccentric WWI fairytale, Sylvie Testud
dresses up as a boy and while searching for her husband's regiment latches
onto a band of deserters who wax poetic about Atlantis and break into kitschy pop tunes, retrieving makeshift instruments from
thin air. Bozon's chief goal seems to be to expose the fragility behind
the valour and machismo of the warfront soldier and he goes about it in
admirably unconventional ways. But for such a brash experiment, it's an
oddly limp film. Since no screen time is wasted on character development,
it's a shame how little the key ideas are allowed to advance. And much of
the dialogue sounds as though it's meant to be infinitely richer and more
poetic than is the case.
dir: Serge Bozon
cast: Sylvie Testud, Pascal Greggory, François Negret, Laurent
Talon, Pierre Leon, Benjamin Esdraffo, Guillaume Verdier, Guillaume
Depardieu
GONE BABY
GONE
****
USA
The old joke that Ben Affleck won an Oscar for typing Matt Damon's
screenplay ought to be laid to rest now that he has not only directed but
coaxed terrific tension and moral quandary out of this story of an
abducted toddler and the baby-faced ghetto private eye hired to help track
her down. The latter is played by Affleck's little brother, similarly
displaying unsuspected depth in his second-most startling lead performance
of 2007. The sordid, coke-rimmed squalor he inhabits borders on the
grotesque and the deeper we delve into it, the more gnawingly our notions
of Right and Wrong (particularly if we happen to be raised on American TV)
are questioned.
After a wrenching first two acts, the third takes a rushed
and melodramatic detour and comes on as somewhat implausible. However, it
brings forth the core dilemma of the piece, which is hefty and
provocative, yet so tactfully presented and with such complexity that it
sparks off an urgent meditation on prickly but vitally important issues
without patronising you with any kind of bias.
dir: Ben Affleck
wr: Aaron Stockard, Ben Affleck
cast: Casey Affleck, Michelle Monaghan, Ed Harris,
Morgan Freeman, Amy Ryan, John Ashton, Amy Madigan, Titus Welliver,
Michael K. Williams, Edi Gathegi, Jill Quigg
HAIRSPRAY
***
USA
What makes Adam Shankman's screen-to-stage-to-screen-musical transfer more likable than most others is that it embraces the corn with an
unfashionably open spirit and that it aspires to the bounce and sparkle of
the musicals from Hollywood's golden age. John Travolta has never been more
charming and human-like than he is as Edna Turnblad, James Marsden nails
Corny Collins with terrific (and unexpected) showmanship and Amanda Bynes,
over-tanned though she is, isn't remotely grating (while, as Tracy
Turnblad, much-hyped debutante Nikky Blonsky often is). It's a shame then
that Michelle Pfeiffer is forced to scowl and gyrate her way around an
immobile forehead and that Christopher Walken isn't quite accepted for the
gift that he is to any musical.
dir: Adam Shankman
cast: John Travolta, Michelle Pfeiffer, Nikky Blonsky,
Christopher Walken, Queen Latifah, Amanda Bynes, James Marsden, Brittany
Snow, Zac Efron, Elijah Kelley, Allison Janney, Taylor Parks, Paul Dooley,
Jerry Stiller
HOT FUZZ
***˝
UK
What Edgar Wright, Simon Pegg and their note-perfect cast did to suburban
London with "Shaun of the Dead", they do to the sleepy country
town with their second feature - only instead of zombie attacks, here you
get sadistic serial killings. It's a thoroughly straight-faced (though
thoroughly nutty) send-up of both the buddy cop action genre and the
English countryside murder mystery. At least one of the several climactic
showdowns is in itself a little masterpiece of surreal comedy.
dir: Edgar Wright
wr: Simon Pegg, Edgar Wright
cast: Simon Pegg, Nick Frost, Jim Broadbent, Timothy
Dalton, Paddy Considine, Olivia Colman, Bill Bailey, Steve Coogan, Bill
Nighy, Kevin Eldon, Martin Freeman, Edward Woodward, Anne Reid, Cate
Blanchett
I'M NOT THERE
***˝
USA
In gravely simplistic terms: Marcus Carl Franklin is plucky pre-teen
Dylan; Ben Whishaw is early 20s art-wank Dylan; Heath Ledger is womanising
matinee idol Dylan; Cate Blanchett is
mid-life-crisis-filtered-through-Fellini's-8˝ Dylan; Christian Bale is
solemn, tortured, born-again Dylan; and Richard Gere may or may not be
aging, increasingly benign outlaw Dylan.
It's a tricky conceit - too murky and underdeveloped to be branded a success but too much of a
blast to be dismissed as a failure. Even the sections that don't
really work - which is most of them - are absorbing.
dir: Todd Haynes
wr: Todd Haynes, Oren Moverman
ph: Edward Lachman
ed: Jay Rabinowitz
cast: Christian Bale, Cate Blanchett, Marcus Carl Franklin, Richard
Gere, Heath Ledger, Ben Whishaw, Charlotte Gainsbourg, Bruce Greenwood,
David Cross, Julianne Moore, Michelle Williams, Kris Kristofferson
IN MEMORY OF
MYSELF
**˝
Italy
A sombre, magisterially crafted mood piece about a Jesuit novice
experiencing doubts just as he's about to be ordained. The actors'
brooding - and there is a hefty amount of it - appears to be motivated
roughly as often by self-importance as it is by something more
substantial.
dir: Saverio Costanzo
cast: Christo Jivkov, Filippo Timi, Marco Baliani, André Hennicke,
Fausto Russo Alesi
INTO THE
WILD
****
USA
The story of straight-A law school graduate Christopher McCandless, who
donated his $20,000+ scholarship to charity and disappeared without
warning into the harsh American landscape to pursue the fantasy of every
undergrad who ever read Walden, treads the spiritual-pathological territory
that Werner Herzog has long laid claim to. Sean Penn is no Herzog. He puts
in too many helicopter shots, too many redundant transcripts from
McCandless' diary, too much slow motion - key scenes that are meant to
resonate spiritually come off instead looking like credit card ads. More
annoyingly, Penn glorifies the mystic-romantic appeal of McCandless'
adventure where it would have been much more honest and productive to
focus on the dangerous naďveté, the misguided arrogance and emotional
instability.
It's a morbidly flawed film. But it has a hypnotic power. It's built on a constant
stream of thought-provoking, transcendentally beautiful passages and
performances that obliterate all the minor and major shortcomings of
Penn's writing and direction. The images, lensed by the great Eric
Gautier, avoid the always-tempting postcard aesthetic and carry a
forceful, primal beauty. Several deeply intelligent actors invest their
crudely stitched-up cameos with a disarming, burnt but tortuously
subsisting humanity. They render the mystic posturing insignificant and
shape the canvas for the searing tragedy of the real McCandless to come
through with tremendous force. You carry it with you.
wr/dir: Sean Penn
ph: Eric Gautier
cast: Emile Hirsch, Marcia Gay Harden, William Hurt, Jena
Malone, Catherine Keener, Brian Dierker, Hal Holbrook, Vince
Vaughn, Kristen Stewart
JELLYFISH
**˝
Israel
Yet another hipster, quirky-sad dramedy about a disparate bunch of
quirky-sad non-characters going through quirky-sad crises to arrive at
trite, quirky-sad epiphanies. Basically a bunch of cloying, spiritless
student films strung together and stretched out to just-barely feature
length.
dir: Shira Geffen, Etgar Keret
cast: Sarah Adler, Tsipor Aizen, Bruria Albek, Ilanit Ben-Yaakov,
Assi Dayan, Ma-nenita De Latorre, Miri Fabian, Shosha Goren, Tzahi Grad,
Johnathan Gurfinkel
A JIHAD FOR
LOVE
***
USA/UK/France/Germany/Australia
First-time director Parvez Sharma tries to cram in as many testimonials
from persecuted Muslim gays from as many countries as an 80-minute running
time permits. So his documentary very quickly becomes reductive and
repetitive. Though, of course, with such a gripping subject, it isn't
uninteresting.
dir: Parvez Sharma
JOSHUA
***
USA
A hesitantly arty variation on the devil-child formula, with the two leads
investing their roles with more complexity than the script does.
dir: George Ratliff
cast: Sam Rockwell, Vera Farmiga, Jacob Kogan, Celia Weston, Dallas
Roberts
JUNO
***˝
USA
A cutesy-quirky, aggressively self-satisfied then aggressively
heartwarming indie elevated to the realm of the bearable and even
genuinely affecting, mostly by an ensemble of exceedingly clever,
committed actors. Ellen Page plays the caustic but inwardly fragile teen
impregnated by a dork and deciding to donate her bundle to a yuppie couple
with half-hidden issues.
There are blips - more, distorting oversights and
misjudgments - both in the writing and direction: no one - and certainly
not a 16-year-old - says things like "You're acting shockingly
cavalier!"; no one's been put off abortion by 20 seconds' worth of
clicking pens etc. The soundtrack is stuffed with lite-indie chick-rock,
and several costuming and set design choices feel transported from a Wes
Anderson movie onto a habitat that is unnatural to them.
But the quirks which are jarring to begin with are pushed to the background in the second act and
fade entirely by
the third. Most of what's implausible about the plotting is gotten out of
the way early, so that the situations and conversations start feeling more
and more organic.
Even in the earlier, sketchier sections however, Page
demonstrates an uncanny gift for selling unspeakable dialogue as her own
words and building from mostly snarky scraps a sensitive, human-like
portrait of a scarred, guarded premature adult. And the supporting actors
are wonderfully subdued.
dir: Jason Reitman
wr: Diablo Cody
cast: Ellen Page, Michael Cera, Jennifer Garner, Jason Bateman,
J.K. Simmons, Allison Janney, Olivia Thirlby, Rainn Wilson, Lucas
MacFadden
|
KNOCKED UP
****
USA
There is a pink elephant at the centre of this frathouse-friendly
contemporary screwball of sorts: why is the intelligent, radiant Katherine
Heigl prepared to potentially sacrifice a blossoming career and a bright
future for an unwanted child with bonghead Seth Rogen? Writer-director
Judd Apatow dodges the issue with some awkwardness, but otherwise he
doesn't strike a false note both in terms of nutty sex comedy and in terms
of grounding the picture in the realm of palatable human relationships.
The actors - from the deceptively clever leads right down to the
incidental, perfectly pitched cameos - are roundly excellent, and the
dialogue is tight, natural and frequently very very funny.
wr/dir: Judd Apatow
cast: Seth Rogen, Katherine Heigl, Leslie Mann, Paul Rudd, Jay
Baruchel, Jonah Hill, Jason Segel, Martin Starr, Allan Tudyk, Kristen Wiig,
Harold Ramis
LARS AND THE
REAL GIRL
**˝
USA
Small-town introvert Ryan Gosling falls in love with a sex doll,
introduces her to the community as Bianca his partner and the community
plays along to the point that Bianca gets her hair styled, is invited to
do charity work and even has the ambulance at ready disposal. The premise
isn't played for cutesy quirk so much as soppy romance. A bunch of
talented actors scramble to pitch their performance at some level
of honesty, but to little avail. The film's inner reality is so sketchy,
it's unlikely that the writer or director ever had a handle on it either.
dir: Craig Gillespie
wr: Nancy Oliver
cast: Ryan Gosling, Emily Mortimer, Paul Schneider, Kelli Garner,
Patricia Clarkson, Nancy Beatty
MADONNAS
***
Germany/Switzerland/Belgium
A raw, relentless verité account of an unstable Sandra Hüller's handling
of many many movie children. Writer-director Maria Speth doesn't seem to
understand that some of the faux-doco conventions and mannerisms she
adopts here are becoming as transparent as things like a crack addict with
a heart of gold or a tinkly piano on the soundtrack. But Hüller has a
gift for obliterating any surrounding hint of artifice in the kind of role
that would go to Maggie Gyllenhaal in an American remake. The children too
are uncannily, uncomfortably convincing.
wr/dir: Maria Speth
cast: Sandra Hüller, Luisa Sappelt, Susanne Lothar, Coleman
Swinton, Peter Moltzen, Jérémie Segard, Olivier Gourmet
THE MAN
FROM LONDON
**
France/Germany/Hungary
Béla Tarr's adaptation of a Georges Simenon novella has something to do
with a switchman at a ghostly French port, a killing he witnesses and some
money he may or may not have scored from it. It's shot on location in
noirish high-contrast black-and-white and Tilda Swinton pops up
occasionally, dubbed (poorly) in Hungarian. You may very well go in
expecting atmosphere and intrigue - of which there's plenty. But brace
yourself for a crushing realisation all the same, when around the
20-minute mark it becomes all too apparent that nothing as of yet has
really happened and nothing as of now is ever going to happen. And it's
difficult beyond this point to look at the picture as anything other than
a self-parody.
But then (!) - as if the funereal score in combination with
the glacial pace wasn't suffocating enough - finally the actors start
speaking. And speaking really. Really. Slo-owl-ly. And this is when the
picture morphs from self-parody into one very nasty joke.
dir: Béla Tarr
cast: Miroslav Krobot, Tilda Swinton, Ági Szirtes, János Derzsi,
Erika Bók, Gyula Pauer, István Lénárt
MICHAEL
CLAYTON
***
USA
In a style unfashionable in Hollywood since the 1970s but experiencing a
resurgence of late, this thriller mixes strands of character study,
political intrigue and questioning of corporate ethics with equal - and
commendable - tenacity. It's flawed on a couple of levels - George
Clooney's lead performance, although solid and photogenic, doesn't hint at
layers that warrant the many pensive, protracted silent close-ups; and the
flashback as a framing device is not only redundant but takes away from
the tension build-up in the third act. But the majority duels and
conversations are absorbing, and writer-director Tony Gilroy finds the
perfect note to wrap things up on.
wr/dir: Tony Gilroy
cast: George Clooney, Tom Wilkinson, Tilda Swinton, Sydney Pollack,
Sean Cullen, Michael O'Keefe
THE MOURNING
FOREST
**
Japan/France
Naomi Kawase blends two film festival staples: the glacial pace that
symbolises the unwieldy vastness of life; and the unlikely
inter-generational connection formed between two grieving, alienated (and
wooden) strangers. She also hopes that you'll mistake alternately serene
and eerie vegetation for alternately serene and eerie filmmaking.
wr/dir: Naomi Kawase
cast: Machiko Ono, Kanako Masuda
MY FRIEND
AND HIS WIFE
**
South Korea
What begins as a gentle romantic comedy with a curious focus on the
corporeal (i.e. an exemplary relaxed attitude to the depiction of sex,
nudity, birth and various viscous substances) is derailed by a grave
tragedy round the 40-minute mark, after which much of the screen-time is
devoted to characters staring grimly/vacantly just past the edge of the
frame and blurting out pregnant, vaguely contemplative-sounding musings on
matters of life and death. From a silly but likable rom-com it devolves
into a silly, malnourished melodrama.
wr/dir: Shin Dong-il
cast: Hong So-hee, Park Hee-soon, Jang Hyeong-seong
MY KID COULD
PAINT THAT
****
USA
You may have heard of 4-year-old Marla Olmstead and her strikingly
sophisticated abstract paintings; and you may have heard the general
consensus that their sophistication owes a lot to her cowardly father's
secret input and/or tyranny. Accordingly,
in your mind you may have formed your own ghastly portrait of a maniacal
parent, and then here comes Amir Bar-Lev to present the lovely, twinkling
Mark and Laura Olmstead, who, by all accounts, are determined to ensure a
happy and wholesome state of mind for their two adorable children. And
then you get a nasty feeling.
As Bar-Lev's layered, piercing documentary unfolds, and
damning evidence builds up against the Olmsteads, you find yourself
suppressing your better judgment, and scouring for unlikely clues to
vindicate them lovely Olmsteads. As Bar-Lev catches himself doing the
same, torn as he is between his common humanity and his pursuit of truth
(not to mention, 'documentary gold') he brings up some pesky points
regarding the editorial slants and agendas that shape the reportage that
so often poses as objective fact.
Working off the implication that reportage (including documentaries and
news reports), like art, is subjective, he examines in great detail the
role of the artist in relation to his/her work, both in terms of his/her
self-aggrandising perspective as well as his/her status in the eyes of the
public.
Furthermore (and in line with his sole original motive), in
terms of pure artistry and virtuosity, he ponders what it is exactly about
Marla's technically irrational paintings that makes them beautiful and
moving and worth thousands of dollars. And as he watches the same
paintings' gushing devotees decamp and start denouncing once their
child-prodigy tag is undermined, he comes across some uncomfortable
revelations about the corrupting human dependence on neat, (more often
than not) projected narratives.
dir: Amir Bar-Lev
NO COUNTRY
FOR OLD MEN
*****
USA
The Coen Brothers adapt a Cormac McCarthy novel ostensibly concerning a
bunch of disparate men directly and indirectly involved in a drug deal
gone bad in the cavernous plains near the Texan border. The Coens are as
invested in constructing their immaculately nerve-wracking suspense
setpieces as they are in capturing in cinematic terms the parched,
unsettling poetry of McCarthy's prose and worldview. From coolly tracking
the protagonists' cat-and-mouse game, the picture - at first imperceptibly
- moves on to exhuming the roots of their morbid resignation, and not a
false note is struck along the way by either the Coens or their
extraordinary cast.
wr/dir/ed: Joel and Ethan Coen
ph: Roger Deakins
sound: Craig Berkey
cast: Josh Brolin, Javier Bardem, Tommy Lee Jones, Woody
Harrelson, Kelly Macdonald, Garret Dillahunt, Tess Harper, Barry
Corbin, Stephen Root, Rodger Boyce, Beth Grant, Gene Jones,
Kathy Lamkin
AN OLD
MISTRESS
****
France/Italy
When you consider Catherine Breillat's preferred mode of archness and
formalism, the period melodrama seems like not only a natural arena but
almost an extension of her personality. Though it's less confrontational
and explicit than in her previous films, her fascination with
transgression and sexuality is no less trenchant when framed against a
society built on outwardly strict and rigorous codes and conventions. Her
observations lose none of their relevance or pointed precision for being
fluffed up in starched collars and ballgowns. They do in the meantime gain a depth and
resonance for being defined against a field of absorbing, volatile and
complex emotions.
Fu'ad Ait Aattou plays a notorious libertine reflecting on
his ten-year affair affair with tempestuous kept-woman Asia Argento on the
eve of his commitment to a pretty, accommodating young lady with a title.
Argento lacks the maturity the role demands but has the brazenness to
compensate. Aattou is equipped with enormous, highly photogenic lips to
distract from his vacant, vacant eyes. Claude Sarraute and Yolande Moreau
are both delightful as veteran socialites.
wr/dir: Catherine Breillat
cast: Asia Argento, Fu'ad Ait Aattou, Roxane Mesquida, Claude
Sarraute, Yolande Moreau, Michael Lonsdale, Anne Parillaud
PLANET
TERROR
***
USA
After Grindhouse bombed at the US box office, several international
distributors sliced it in two, released Tarantino's half in theatres and
sent Rodriguez's straight to DVD. Unlike Tarantino, Rodriguez recognises
his limitations. While nothing here matches the charge and dexterity of Death
Proof's climactic car chase, it's overall the happier experience.
dir: Robert Rodriguez
cast: Rose McGowan, Freddy Rodriguez, Josh Brolin, Marley Shelton,
Jeff Fahey, Michael Biehn, Rebel Rodriguez, Bruce Willis, Naveen Andrews,
Nicky Katt
RATATOUILLE
***˝
USA
A warm, vibrant Pixar concoction concerning a gourmet rat who refashions
a Parisian kitchen. It works best in the bits where there's no dialogue.
In its weaker patches it suffers from the contemporary compulsion to make
every cartoon hero sound like a snarky teenage girl.
wr/dir: Brad Bird
cast: Patton Oswalt, Ian Holm, Lou Romano, Brian Dennehy, Peter
Sohn, Peter O'Toole, Brad Garrett, Janeane Garofalo, Will Arnett
SAVAGE
GRACE
***
USA
A confounding account of the sensational real-life murder of unstable
socialite Barbara Baekeland by her that-much-more-unstable son. With
elegance and absolute - as well as, to an extent, blinding - commitment,
Tom Kalin (whose first film since the staggering Swoon [1992] this is)
directs Howard A. Rodman's haphazard, incomplete draft of a promising
script. The characters, although rendered vivid by a uniformly solid cast,
are left underdeveloped, and much of their unorthodox behaviour in the
third act is shocking for all the wrong reasons. The picture is always
absorbing and often dazzling (as pictures tend to be every time they
provide the malleably fierce and destitute Julianne Moore with a juicy
role), so much so that - despite the unpleasant subject matter and the
trying 15-year wait for a second Tom Kalin picture - it leaves you wishing
that Kalin and Rodman took some extra time in pre-production to prod
into the motives and causes behind their characters' dodgy neuroses,
rather than focus on the kinky effects.
dir: Tom Kalin
wr: Howard A. Rodman
cast: Julianne Moore, Stephen Dillane, Eddie Redmayne,
Simón Andreu, Elena Anaya, Barney Clark, Hugh Dancy, Abel Folk, Anne
Reid, Brendan Price
SHOTGUN
STORIES
**˝
USA
A leisurely, mournful, mannered meditation on a small-town Arkansas family
feud with a rapidly escalating body count. For eschewing the obvious
punchy approach and attempting instead something more personal and
contemplative, writer-director Jeff Nichols is to be commended. But there
are too many false, derivative notes both in his script and his handling
of the actors. Perhaps his second movie might turn out more sincere and
authentic if he manages to step out of the shadow of co-producer - and
evident mentor - David Gordon Green.
wr/dir: Jeff Nichols
cast: Michael Shannon, Douglas Ligon, Barlow Jacobs, Natalie
Canerday, Glenda Pannell, Lynnsee Provence, Michael Abbott Jr.
SICKO
***
USA
As is sometimes the case with Michael Moore joints, in this litany on the
[patently paltry] American health care system, it's difficult to swallow
the syrup in his voiceover, his rehearsed disbelief, his fetish for maudlin and/or cartoonish
scoring and his compulsion to hammer home a point long after you get it,
you really truly get it.
But each point he raises and then underlines repeatedly is so
thoroughly urgent and sobering that you're forced to cut him some slack.
Plus, he's trying so hard to give off the impression that he's trying hard
to take in the issue from the maximum of viable perspectives.
dir: Michael Moore
THE SIMPSONS
MOVIE
*****
USA
[Comparatively] cheaply, cleverly and beautifully animated for the big
screen, the quirks, manics and insecurities of Homer, Marge and their 2.5
children are blown up against an epic plot, wherein Homer
half-inadvertently brings on the destruction of the town of Springfield
and his family, and must then put concentrated thought and effort into
their recovery. From the point that Ralph Wiggum pops into the
20th-Century-Fox logo to sings along, to the Squeaky-Voiced Teen's
closing-credits homily on the value of four years of film school, the
barrage of genuinely witty gags - be they visual, verbal, nasal,
political, observational, self-referential: all hits, no misses - doesn't
relent, though it allows for feature-length character arcs for each of the
principals and a representation of family (American, nuclear, or otherwise) as
alert, considerate and absorbing as any contemporary one.
dir: David Silverman
wr: Matt Groening, Sam Simon, James L. Brooks, Al Jean, Ian
Maxtone-Graham, George Meyer, David Mirkin, Mike Reiss, Mike Scully, Matt
Selman, John Swartzwelder, Jon Vitti
voices of: Dan Castellaneta, Julie Kavner, Nancy Cartwright,
Yeardley Smith, Hank Azaria, Harry Shearer, Pamela Hayden
STRANGE
CULTURE
***
USA
And a suitably strange, thought-provoking picture. In an occasionally
muddled but nevertheless absorbing mix of documentary and fiction, Lynn
Hershman-Leeson investigates the Kafkaesque case of Steve Kurt, who was
arrested for bio-terrorism under the most peculiar circumstances.
dir: Lynn Hershman-Leeson
SUNSHINE
****
UK
The Sun is dying. The last team of astronauts sent to resuscitate it
disappeared without a trace seven years earlier. So it's now up to Cillian
Murphy and a cast that brings memories of a Benetton-ad to save humanity.
On paper it sounds like a daunting thing to sit through, but
the plot exposition, along with the less intriguing performers, is
disposed of early on and what follows is uncommonly enthralling sci-fi.
It's both mildly philosophical in accordance with current zen-sci-fi
trends as well as unnervingly tense in that more enduring slasher-sci-fi
tradition. On top of this it boasts a high-strung, fatalistic emotionalism
that is difficult - and probably pretty pointless - to resist. The soaring
anguish of the strings on the soundtrack is an easy enough weapon in
itself, but it's that much more stirring matched as it is to awe-inspiring
imagery.
dir: Danny Boyle
wr: Alex Garland
ph: Alwin H. Kuchler
m: John Murphy, Karl Hyde, Rick Smith
pd: Mark Tildesley
cast: Cillian Murphy, Rose Byrne, Chris Evans, Michelle
Yeoh, Cliff Curtis, Hiroyuki Sanada, Benedict Wong, Troy Garity, Mark
Strong
SUPERBAD
***˝
USA
Maybe because Seth Rogen and Evan Goldberg wrote the script while still in
high school, this teen comedy - yet another one about a bunch of scruffy
hornbags seeking to lose their virginity before prom night - feels
authentic. The drinking, the vomiting, the awkward sexuality, the fixation
on genitalia, the burden of virginity - everything seems lifted from lived
experience, not market research. And the three leads - two of whom are
genuinely high-school-aged - are switched-on and note-perfect.
dir: Greg Mottola
wr: Seth Rogen, Evan Goldberg
cast: Michael Cera, Jonah Hill, Christopher Mintz-Plasse, Seth
Rogen, Bill Hader, Martha MacIsaac, Emma Stone, Aviva
SWEENEY TODD:
THE DEMON BARBER OF FLEET STREET
***˝
USA
The wit, tension and soaring tragedy of Stephen Sondheim's musical can
withstand even Tim Burton's rigid efforts to turn it into a cartoon. The
irritating technical quirks, like a silly whirlwind tour of 19th-century
CGI-London, are easy to overlook, but it takes concentrated goodwill to
get past the miscasting.
When Johnny Depp - looking Botoxed throughout - drones
"I will have venn-geance", you want to punch him and his ego
that insisted singing lessons would reduce the performance (of a
character defined by operatic bloodlust). Helena Bonham Carter fares a
little better if only because she pitches her performance according to her
(thin) vocals and reinvents Mrs. Lovett as a desiccated, fragile ghoul
with a stunted passion (in contrast to Depp's stunting passionlessness).
All the same, enough of Sondheim's melancholy and savagery
survives the transition to make even this muted adaptation intensely
compelling. Although in butchered form, the morbid yearning and warped
genius of the songs comes through.
dir: Tim Burton
cast: Johnny Depp, Helena Bonham Carter, Alan Rickman, Timothy
Spall, Edward Sanders, Jamie Campbell Bower, Jayne Wisener, Sacha Baron
Cohen, Laura Michelle Kelly
2 DAYS IN PARIS
***
France/Germany
Julie Delpy seems to be apologising for French mentality and customs in
this meet-my-quirky-foreign-parents comedy, which gets grating -
particularly in the opening sections, riddled as they are with clammy
voiceover, unwieldy banter and forced jokes. But she builds up an easy,
absorbing rhythm with her actors, so that by the end even the homilies and
stereotypes are easy to swallow.
wr/dir/ed: Julie Delpy
cast: Julie Delpy, Adam Goldberg, Marie Pillet, Albert Delpy,
Aleksia Landeau, Daniel Brühl, Adan Jodorowsky, Alexandre Nahon
THE WITNESSES
****
France
The earnest-complacent AIDS drama hit its peak (in terms of circulation
more than quality) during the early-to-mid 90s and gradually began losing
exposure thereafter, so much so that it has been nearing extinction as of
late (bad news to people with a social conscience, though good news to
lovers of complex drama). In a sense André Téchiné is being
unfashionable in daring to tackle the issue at this point in time -
particularly in opting for an approach of historical documenting rather
than hysterical pseudo-topicality. But a more graceful and articulate
insight into the shock and panic of the abrupt outbreak of the disease in
the 1980s doesn't exist on celluloid. With customary wisdom he peoples his
picture with tangible, vibrant characters rather than shrill demographics.
Through them you experience the paralysing terror of AIDS rather than just
hear about it.
The fretting orchestral score by Fred Chichin and Philippe
Sarde is quite openly derivative of Philip Glass' work and it works
wonderfully well. Setting up a brisk pace in tandem with the shrewd,
sensible cutting, it keeps you that much more involved in the proceedings,
and builds on the story's urgent, forceful impact while maintaining its
intimacy.
dir: André Téchiné
wr: André Téchiné, Laurent Guyot, Viviane Zingg
ph: Julien Hirsch
ed: Martine Giordano
m: Fred Chichin,
Philippe Sarde
cast: Michel Blanc, Emmanuelle Béart, Sami Bouajila, Julie
Depardieu, Johan Libéreau, Constance Dollé, Lorenzo Balducci, Alain
Cauchi
YEAR OF THE
DOG
***
USA
An off-centre, admirably committed portrayal of a near-middle-aged woman,
whose most poignant relationship in life is with her dog - and the dog
dies prematurely. Though he's constantly treading on the edge of hollow
quirk and cutesiness, writer-director Mike White very rarely crosses it,
and he's served with uniformly note-perfect performances from his fine
cast.
wr/dir: Mike White
cast: Molly Shannon, Peter Sarsgaard, Laura Dern, Josh Pais, Regina
King, Thomas McCarthy, John C. Reilly
YELLA
**˝
Germany
An obtuse metaphysical thriller that puts an attractive young accountant
played by Nina Hoss in increasingly dubious circumstances that fail to
compromise her icy veneer. The few outbursts of plot are imaginatively
handled and carefully placed within the greater focus on faintly
off-kilter mundaneness. And Hoss' conviction helps to make the picture
intriguing for the most part. But in the end it's too clinical and
arbitrary - or maybe just too much smarter than its audience - to
pack any kind of a punch.
dir: Christian Petzold
cast: Nina Hoss, David Striesow, Hinnerk Schönemann, Burghart
Klaussner, Barbara Auer, Christian Redl
YOU, THE
LIVING
***˝
Sweden
Roy Andersson delivers another bunch of nutty, surrealist vignettes - less
cohesive in tone than in his moody, terrific previous
film, though hardly less delightful - wherein he infuses with absurdist
humour and a joyous, irrepressible spirit the lives of an otherwise bleak
bunch of people.
wr/dir: Roy Andersson
cast: Hĺkan Angser, Eric Bäckman, Patrik Anders Edgren, Björn
Englund, Lennart Eriksson, Pär Fredriksson, Elisabeth Helander, Gunnar
Ivarsson, Leif Larsson, Jessika Lundberg, Jessica Nilsson, Jörgen Nohall,
Waldemar Nowak, Olle Olson, Kemal Sener, Jan Wikbladh
YOUR
MOMMY KILLS ANIMALS
***
USA
A distressing look into the Animal Liberation Movement, whose actions have
placed them at the top of the FBI's list of national terrorist threats
(that's right, above Al-Qaeda), mirroring as they often do the very
behaviour of the animal-abusers they're fighting against. Director Curt
Johnson takes on too much when he brings in the SHAC7 trials and the
issues they raise regarding free speech (a topic worth feature length on
its own), though his refusal to plonk people into neat hero/villain boxes
is commendable.
dir: Curt Johnson
ZODIAC
***˝
USA
David Fincher returns to the serial killer genre with this look into the
as-yet unsolved Zodiac murders in California in the late 60s. He drops the
moody, upstart showiness that had heretofore marked his films and delivers
instead the kind of sombre, reserved, detail-driven suspenser that Sidney
Lumet is committed to.
It's very much a movie-movie: Jake Gyllenhaal plays the
handsomest and most clean-cut of dishevelled, bookish true-crime nerds;
the killings and near-killings wouldn't look out of place in any sadistic
slasher flick; none of the victims and near-victims are permitted a
personality; women exist only for purposes of exposition; and every
location is glazed in a Technicolor sheen (though, astonishingly,
celluloid never came into it).
And within the realm of its movie-movie-ness, it's tense,
compelling and thoroughly satisfying in the way that every efficient
studio picture ought to be. The actors help, certainly, as does the script
by James Vanderbilt, who throws hooks at you at a finely judged rhythm and
avoids the traditionally clunky dialogue that haunts the genre. And though
neither Vanderbilt nor Fincher adequately pursue the fascinating strand
they open up about mankind's compulsive need for closure above factually
supportable justice, they do at least touch on it, and within the realm of
movie-movieness, that's enough to be commended.
dir: David Fincher
wr: James Vanderbilt
ph: Harris Savides
cast: Jake Gyllenhaal, Mark Ruffalo, Anthony Edwards, Robert Downey
Jr., Brian Cox, Chloë Sevigny, Elias Koteas, Dermot Mulroney, Donal
Logue, Clea DuVall, Philip Baker Hall, John Carroll Lynch
ZOO
**
USA
An admirably compassionate but awkward look into zoophilia, sparked by the
notiorious case of Kenneth Pynan (though he's only ever referred to as Mr.
Hands in the movie), who bled to death after being anally penetrated by a
horse. Director Robinson Devor understands the sadness, the eerieness and
the tragedy of a 'zoosexual's state of mind, but he refuses to acknowledge
its bizarreness and its morbid fascination. He has accordingly chosen to
photograph the film with artsy, grief-stricken, heavily pregnant lyricism
that very quickly becomes exhausting.
dir: Robinson Devor
|