Terror's Martyr's Comments
Energy Barrier by Exile Master
F (3.4/4)
(1.4/2)
(2/2)
A (3/4)
(1/1)
(1/1)
(0/1) (Not much detail here.)
(1/1)
N (0/2)
(0/1)
(0/1)
B +0
T 6.4/10
Chest by TGM
F (4/4)
(2/2)
(2/2)
A (3.7/4)
(1/1)
(.8/1)
(.9/1)
(1/1)
N (.5/2)
(0/1)
(.5/1)
B +0
T 8.2/10
Fire Vortex
F (2/4)
(1/2)
(1/2) (Frame animations, maybe.)
A (2/4)
(1/1)
(.5/1)
(.5/1) (Could probably benefit from being animated.)
(0/1) (It doesn't really look good on ANY background.)
N (.5/2)
(0/1)
(.5/1)
B +0
T 4.5/10
Beam by Wild Karrde Smuggler
F (2/4)
(1/2)
(1/2) (Again, would be okay in Frame Animations)
A (2.4/4)
(1/1)
(.5/1)
(.4/1)
(.5/1)
N (1/2)
(.5/1)
(.5/1)
B +.2 (Because it can be extended, making it somewhat more useful)
T 5.6/10
Arctic Hills by Milu
F (1.3/4)
(.5/2) (I personally wouldn't have pieced it together, if Milu's email didn't have a title given to it.)
(.8/2) (Where's the rest of the terrain set?)
A (1.8/4)
(1/1)
(.4/1) (See below.)
(.4/1) (The ground is nothing but white.)
(0/1) (It has no background designated.)
N (0/2)
(0/1)
(0/1)
B +1 (The rubric is a bit hard on this one. It's not THAT bad, it's just that I can't ever see this being used.)
T 4.1/10
Curtains by Milu
F (4/4)
(2/2)
(2/2)
A (3/4)
(1/1)
(.5/1) (It looked like the result of a mishmash done with the paint tool in Photoshop, but assuming that's what made it, it's not awful.)
(.5/1) (See above.)
(1/1)
N (1.3/2)
(.8/1)
(.5/1) (I prefer Holt's more.)
B +0
T 8.3/10
Crystal Floor by Luz
F (4/4)
(2/2)
(2/2)
A (4/4)
(1/1)
(1/1)
(1/1)
(1/1) (It IS a background.)
N (1.5/2)
(.7/1) (Seeing this made me think of my adapted version of Rabbitlord's tiled floors. You know, the Sylvian ones. Good, but not entirely unique.)
(1/1)
B +0 (This one is missing its objects, save for a pretty-looking pillar. I can't very well give this a bonus, now can I?)
T 9.7/10
Paved Floor by Luz
F (4/4)
(2/2)
(2/2)
A (4/4)
(1/1)
(1/1)
(1/1)
(1/1)
N (2/2)
(1/1)
(1/1)
B +1 (Almost all new terrain objects, and all of them are beautiful.)
T 11/10
Drakefyre's Comments
Sun Symbol by Terror's Martyr
6.5 - Decent, but it doesn't quite seem to blend with the floor well.
Energy Barrier by Exile Master
5 - Looks far too solid and blocky to be a real barrier.
Chest (Openable and Closable) by The Great Mister
6 - It's good, but it's no BoE-style graphic.
Fire Vortex by Wild Karrde Smuggler
5 - Can't see the usefulness of this, especially as it's not really a BoE graphic.
Beam by Wild Karrde Smuggler
4.5 - Just looks like some orange lines - not very clear as to a meaning.
Arctic Hills by Milu
7 - Finally, a real BoE graphic. It doesn't try to do too much, and it look pretty good.
Curtains by Milu
5.5 - Not really as good as the other curtain set out there, and it has no opening graphic.
Crystal Floor by Luz Piazuelo
7.5 - Very nice, and I wish that there were more of them
Paved Floor by Luz Piazuelo
9 - Very, very nice. Completely original and it looks wonderful. Again, not a complete floorset.
Wild Karrde's Comments
Sun Symbol by TM
Functionality: 4/4
- Does the graphic make sense? (2/2)
- Can the graphic be used easily in multiple circumstances? (2/2)
Aestheticism: 3.5/4
- Are the dimensions of the graphic suitable for use in Blades of Exile? (1/1)
- Is the graphic shaded properly? (1/1)No shading is necessary
- Does the graphic have sufficient detail? (.5/1)
- FREE SPACE(1/1)
Necessity: .5/2
- Is the graphic really necessary? (0/1)
- Is the graphic an improvement or on the same level as other graphics of similar design? (.5/1) Not as good as the pentagon things
Bonus: - 1 Because it's an edit, not an original
7/10
Energy Barrier by Exile Master
Functionality: 1.5/4
- Does the graphic make sense? (.5/2) It doesn't look like what it is.
- Can the graphic be used easily in multiple circumstances? (1/2)Probably, but not for the use it was priginally intended.
Aestheticism: 3/4
- Are the dimensions of the graphic suitable for use in Blades of Exile? (1/1)
- Is the graphic shaded properly? (1/1)
- Does the graphic have sufficient detail? (0/1)
- FREE SPACE! (1/1)
Necessity: 0/2
- Is the graphic really necessary? (0/1)
- Is the graphic an improvement or on the same level as other graphics of similar design? (0/1)
4.5/10 Nothing Spectacular here.
Chest Openable by The Great Mister
Functionality: 2/4
- Does the graphic make sense? (2/2) Yes.
- Can the graphic be used easily in multiple circumstances? (0/2)Not really
Aestheticism: 2.5/4
- Are the dimensions of the graphic suitable for use in Blades of Exile? (1/1)
- Is the graphic shaded properly? (.5/1) Too sharply defined shadow.
- Does the graphic have sufficient detail? (0/1)
- FREE SPACE! (1/1)
Necessity: 0/2
- Is the graphic really necessary? (0/1)
- Is the graphic an improvement or on the same level as other graphics of similar design? (0/1)I've seen better.
Bonus: + .5 It would make a nice avernum graphic.
5/10
Artic Hills by Milu
Functionality: 2.5/4
- Does the graphic make sense? (1.5/2)somewhat.
- Can the graphic be used easily in multiple circumstances? (1/2)Maybe
Aestheticism: 4/4
- Are the dimensions of the graphic suitable for use in Blades of Exile? (1/1)
- Is the graphic shaded properly? (1/1)
- Does the graphic have sufficient detail? (1/1)
- FREE SPACE! (1/1)
Necessity: 1.5/2
- Is the graphic really necessary? (.5/1)Questionable
- Is the graphic an improvement or on the same level as other graphics of similar design? (1/1)
8/10
Curtains by Milu
Functionality: 4/4
- Does the graphic make sense? (2/2)
- Can the graphic be used easily in multiple circumstances? (2/2) I think so.
Aestheticism: 4/4
- Are the dimensions of the graphic suitable for use in Blades of Exile? (1/1)
- Is the graphic shaded properly? (1/1)
- Does the graphic have sufficient detail? (1/1)
- FREE SPACE! (1/1)
Necessity: 1.5/2
- Is the graphic really necessary? (.5/1)
- Is the graphic an improvement or on the same level as other graphics of similar design? (1/1)Above average
9.5/10
Crystal Floor by Luz
Functionality: 3.5/4
- Does the graphic make sense? (1.5/2)It's not crystal, but it's damned good.
- Can the graphic be used easily in multiple circumstances? (1/2)
Aestheticism: 4/4
- Are the dimensions of the graphic suitable for use in Blades of Exile? (1/1)
- Is the graphic shaded properly? (1/1)
- Does the graphic have sufficient detail? (1/1)
- FREE SPACE! (1/1)
Necessity: 1/2
- Is the graphic really necessary? (.5/1)
- Is the graphic an improvement or on the same level as other graphics of similar design? (1/1)
9/ 10
Paved Floor by Luz
Functionality: 4/4
- Does the graphic make sense? (2/2)
- Can the graphic be used easily in multiple circumstances? (2/2)
Aestheticism: 3.5/4
- Are the dimensions of the graphic suitable for use in Blades of Exile? (1/1)
- Is the graphic shaded properly? (.5/1)sometimes
- Does the graphic have sufficient detail? (1/1)
- FREE SPACE! (1/1)
Necessity: .5/2
- Is the graphic really necessary? (0/1)
- Is the graphic an improvement or on the same level as other graphics of similar design? (.5/1) Average
8/10
Alcritas' Comments
Beam - 4, Would have been much higher if animated
Artic Hills - 4, Hard to tell what this is
Stareye's Comments
Sun Symbol - 6.0 (okay detail and shading, not all that useful)
Energy Barrier - 5.5 (I just do not like it, not a credible energy barrier IMHO)
Chest - 7.5 (okay detail, the top seems a little out of touch with shading)
Fire Vortex - 4.0 (wow, you can use Photoshop; how long did it take you to find that feature?)
Beam - 5.0 (maybe a little bire more work)
Arctic Hills - 8.0 (nice, but not sure where to use them)
Curtains - 8.0 (quite nice, a little too purple)
Crystal Floor - 7.5 (excellent, but so incomplete I could never use it, sorry)
Paved Floor - 9.0 (very nice, like the firepit animation)