Terror's Martyr's Comments:
Soldier by TGM
F (4/4)
(2/2)
(2/2)
A (3.7/4)
(1/1)
(.7/1) (Why are the soldier's eyes so bright?)
(1/1)
(1/1)
N (.5/2)
(0/1)
(.5/1)
B +0
T 8.2/10
Wizard by TGM
F (4/4)
(2/2)
(2/2)
A (2.8/4)
(1/1)
(.4/1) (Two color shading is lazy.)
(.4/1) (Two color detail is lazy.)
(1/1)
N (0/2)
(0/1)
(0/1)
B +0
T 6.8/10
Brigand by Wild Karrde
F (3/4)
(1/2) (The eyes...!)
(2/2)
A (3.1/4)
(1/1)
(.7/1) (A little dark- a problem I also had with the original)
(.4/1) (This graphic came to me messed-up like a JPG.)
(1/1)
N (0/2)
(0/1)
(0/1) (The original is better)
B +0
T 6.1/10
Female Brigand by Wild Karrde
F (1.5/4)
(1/2) (A bit chubby to be a brigand, why are the clothes so invisible?)
(.5/2) (I wouldn't use it at all, ever.)
A (2/4)
(1/1)
(0/1) (+75% Black = Bad)
(0/1) (+75% Black = Bad)
(1/1)
N (0/2)
(0/1)
(0/1)
B -1 (This graphic is complete ass.)
T 2.5/10
Mage by Milu
F (4/4)
(2/2)
(2/2)
A (3.8/4)
(1/1)
(1/1)
(.8/1) (The background is a bit undone)
(1/1)
N (1/2)
(.5/1)
(.5/1)
B +0
T 8.8/10
Slith by Milu
F (1.5/4)
(.5/2) (Sliths wear lipstick and have hair?)
(1/2) (A slith beauty salon, maybe...)
A (4/4)
(1/1)
(1/1)
(1/1)
(1/1)
N (1.3/2)
(.8/1)
(.5/1)
B +0
T 6.8/10
Slith (2) by Milu
F (3.5/4)
(1.5/2) (The lipstick is still a bit odd.)
(2/2)
A (4/4)
(1/1)
(1/1)
(1/1)
(1/1)
N (1.7/2)
(.8/1)
(.9/1)
B +0
T 9.2/10
Rogue by Luz
F (3/4)
(1/2) (Why is he kissing a glass plate?)
(2/2)
A (3/4)
(1/1)
(.5/1) (See above)
(.5/1) (See above)
(1/1)
N (1/2)
(.5/1)
(.5/1)
B +0
T 7/10
Warlock by Luz
F (4/4)
(2/2)
(2/2)
A (3/4)
(1/1)
(.5/1) (Looked like something out of Heroes of Might and Magic II)
(.5/1) (See above)
(1/1)
N (.5/2)
(0/1)
(.5/1)
B +0
T 7.5/10
Alcritas' Comments:
Athanos
3/4 Function
3/4 Aesthetics
0.5/2 Necessity
-0.5 Bonus=6.0
Ermarian
2/4 Function
2/4 Aesthetic
0/2 Necessity
+0.5 Bonus = 4.5
Echoes: Thesis
3/4 Function
3/4 Aesthetic
0.5/2 Necessity
0 Bonus = 6.5
Thyron IV - 4.5, Identical scores to Ermarian
(Both) Ultimate Weapons
2/4 Functions
2/4 Aesthetic
0.5/2 Necessity
0 Bonus = 4.5
Soldier
3/4 Functions
2/4 Aesthetic
1/2 Necessity
0 Bonus = 6
Wizards
3/4 Function
3/4 Aesthetic
1/2 Necessity
+0.5 Bonus = 7.5
Brigand
2/4 Function
0.5/4 Aesthetic
0.5/2 Necessity
-1 Bonus = 2
Female Brigand
2/4 Function
2.5/4 Aesthetic
1/2 Necessity
+.5 Bonus = 6
Mage
3/4 Function
3.5/Aesthetic
1/2 Necessity
+1 Bonus = 8.5
Very Nice Background!
Slith(1)
3/4 Function
3/4 Aesthetic
2/2 Necessity
0 Bonus = 8
Slith (2)
3/4 Function
2.5/4 Aesthetic
2/2 Necessity
0 Bonus = 7.5
Rogue
3/4 Function
3/4 Aesthetic
1/2 Necessity
+.5 Bonus = 7.5
Warlock
4/4 Function
3/4 Aesthetic
1/2 Necessity
0 Bonus = 8
Stareye's Comments
Athanos - 6.0 (not enough editing to make it significantly different from the original)
Ermarian - 6.5 (all right, not extremely useful)
Echoes: Thesis - 5.0 (okay graphic, I do not see any place to use it outside of TMs scenarios though)
Thyron IV - 7.0 (I like this planet better)
Ultimate Weapon Dialog - 7.0 (nice background)
Ultimate Weapon Talking - 7.0 (same graphic twice)
Soldier - 7.5 (nice armor detail, quite useful, eyes may be a little too bright and supernatual though)
Wizard - 6.0 (meh, a hooded man in boring robes. Ok detail, but very bland, useful at least)
Brigand - 5.0 (those eyes seem abnormal, maybe a possessed brigand?)
Female Brigand - 3.0 (the background is waaay too dark)
Mage - 8.0 (good overall, nice graphic and shading.)
Slith 1 - 6.5 (nice, a little grainy. The part where the helmet sits on the head needs more shadow)
Slith 2 - 9.5 (very nice, great background)
Rogue - 8.0 (good)
Warlock - 8.5 (good, creative headdress)
Ira Mertes' Comments
Athanos Dialogue 2+2+1+1+1+1+0+1 = 9 / 6.5 = 7.75 (Usable and good but generic.)
Ermarian 2+2+1+1+1+1+1+1 = 10 / 10 = 10 (Useful for just about any generic dialog box.)
Echoes : Thesis 1+0+1+1+1+1+0+1 = 6 / 8 = 7 (Looks cool, but doesn't really represent much.)
Thyron IV 2+1+1+1+1+1+0+1 = 8 / 10 = 9 (Like Ermarian, only doesn't look as good.)
Ultimate Weapon Dialog 1+0+1+0+1+0+0+1 = 4 / 6 = 5 (Why was this submitted to the competition?)
Ultimate Weapon Talking 1+0+1+0+1+0+0+1 = 4 / 6 = 5 (See above)
Soldier Dialogue 2+2+1+1+1+1+0+1 = 9 / 7 = 8 (I suppose it can be useful.)
Wizard Dialogue 2+2+1+1+1+1+0+1 = 9 / 4 = 6.5 (I don't like this one, for some reason.)
Brigand Dialogue 1+1+0+1+1+1+0+0 = 5 / 2 = 3.5 (He looks strange and creepy. No thanks.)
Female Brigand Dialogue 1+2+0+1+1+0+1+0 = 6 / 1 = 3.5 (AHH WTF)
Mage 2+2+1+1+1+1+0+1 = 9 / 8.5 = 8.75 (Looks very good.)
Slith 1+1+1+1+1+1+1+1 = 8 / 6 = 7 (Sliths... with white hair? Err...)
Slith2 2+2+1+1+1+1+1+1 = 10 / 7 = 8.5 (A much more passable Slith.)
Rogue 2+2+.5+.5+1+1+1+1 = 9 / 5 = 7 (His stubble is purplish, and that's not right.)
Warlock 2+2+1+1+1+1+0+1 = 9 / 7 = 8 (Looks cool.)