Groups are expected to provide a detailed explanation of the readings
for the day. This does not mean that you will merely summarize what
the class has read.
The group is expected to be familiar with all discussion questions assigned
for the reading, though you do not necessarily need to discuss all of them
as part of your presentation, especially if doing so will preclude you
from adequately explaining the meanings of the texts and addressing the
specific issues listed below.
Not all group members are required to speak during the actual presentation,
provided group members agree the work for the presentation has been distributed
evenly among the members.
There should be two parts to the group discussions:
Critical Perspectives
Reader-Response
The New Historicism
Psychoanalytic
Feminist
Gender
Marxist
Cultural
Critical Essays
Ferguson
Modiano
Collings
Smith
Michel
Montag
Zakharieva
Group members discussing Critical Perspectives are required not only
to explain the essential meaning of the essay, but also to be able to explain
and identify all significant terms and figures (culture, materialism, libido,
Freud, Marx, Lacan, etc.) associated with the subject, especially those
mentioned in the essay itself.
Group members discussing Critical Essays, in addition to providing a
brief explanation of the author's main argument, will explore the theoretical
framework that undergirds the argument of the essay and explain how it
demonstrates the discipline with which it is associated (New Historicism:
Modiano, Psychoanalytic: Collings, Feminist: Smith, etc.).
An outline / summary of the group's discussion MUST be submitted in
written form to the instructor at the BEGINNING of the class period. If
you are using power-point (which is not required), please print out all
slides to submit at the beginning of the class as well.
ALL information taken from secondary sources MUST be clearly and accurately
documented !! (See Plagiarism Policy
)
In addition, you will submit a full-length paper following proper MLA
guidelines for a documented critical paper.
What this means is that you will bring in quotes from the essay to support
the claims you make about it. If you refer to (or simply include
information from) outside sources, perhaps in your discussion of terms
or figures, you must provide parenthetical citation and a reference in
the Works Cited page.
For example, for sections discussing Critical Perspectives, your thesis
will be that the essential points of this perspective are "a," "b," and
"c." These points are demonstrated "here," "here," and "here," etc.
For sections discussing Critical Essays, your thesis will be that "x"
essay exemplifies "y" critical perspective for reasons "a," "b," and "c."
You will then bring in supporting quotes from "x" essay demonstrating reasons
"a," "b," and "c" that it exemplifies "y" perspective.
Please ask Dr. Mekler any questions about these requirements before
the day of your presentation.
In terms of grades, each member of the group will evaluate her/himself
and the others, based on a percentage of effort put in. This is a
team effort, so it will require everyone to participate, not only in performing
his or her individual tasks, but also in combining all the individuals
parts into a coherent unit. The presentation will be graded by the
instructor as a whole, not according to each presenter. At the beginning
of your presentation, each member will hand in his or her grading sheet.
You may get the sheets here .
I will make every effort to maintain a "secret ballot" environment.
I will average the different grades together and return each member's sheet,
listing the group grade and the individual grade for that student.
Please let me know as early as possible what if any electronic/technological
accomodations you will require so that I can make the proper arrangements.