Genetic and pathogenicity variation among isolates of Bipolaris maydis
(Nisik. and Miyake) in Thailand
Siwilai Lapbanjob1, Patchara Po-ngam2, Narong Singhbura U-dom,2
and Teerasak Manupeerapan1
1 Field Crop Research Institute, Department of Agriculture Bangkok, Thailand.
..
ABSTRACT
One hundred and seventeen isolates of Bipolaris maydis (Nisik. And Miyake) were collected from different maize planting areas throughout Thailand. The aim was to assess the genetic and pathogenic variability using culture characteristics, mating type, pathogenicity and AFLP analysis. The results show differences in the colony morphological characters, such as the colony, zonation of colour. From the mating type tested, it was found that 51 isolates are classified as mating type M1-1 and 66 isolates as M1-2, accounting for 43.6% and 56.4%, respectively.
Nineteen representative isolates were evaluated for pathogenic variability on 22 inbred lines of maize. Significant differences occurred between the isolates and the maize genotypes. The same virulent patterns were not found. Analysis of the AFLP data revealed a close relationship in B. maydis and this could be divided into two groups. Most of the isolates were clustered into one group, except for three that showed differences in their DNA patterns to others.
INTRODUCTION
Southern Corn Leaf Blight that is caused by the fungus Bipolaris maydis (Nisik. and Miyake) is one of the most important maize diseases in Thailand. It is prevalent throughout the growing area in Thailand and causes yield and quality reductions. (Anchareesangas, 1998). Up until the present there has been no investigation into the biology and variability of this fungus. The planting environment, varieties used, together with type of fungicide used can lead to significant variation in the pathogen populations. In addition, the mode of reproduction of the fungus is also another important factor that shapes the pathogens genetic structure. The B. maydis is heterothallic meaning that mating type is controlled by a single gene with two alleles resulting in the recombination of hypha to produce the sexual reproductive organ.
Studies of population genetics and mode of reproduction of this pathogen are used to describe and quantify the genetic variations within and among the different populations. Such studies will yield information useful for more effective disease management. For example, if this pathogen shows high variation, then the use of a resistant variety derived either from a cultivar mixture or near-isogenic lines having many types of vertical resistance would be the most appropriate management strategy. Having knowledge of the mode of fungus reproduction within the population can be used to predict the possible changes in the genetics of the pathogen enabling more efficient control measures to be developed.
In recent years, plant pathologists have adopted the use of the molecular marker as a population genetic tool. Amplified fragment length polymorphisms (AFLP) have proved to be highly polymorphic and robust for use as markers. In contrast to virulence markers, molecular markers are assumed to be selectively neutral. The objective of this study was to evaluate the genetic variation of B. maydis in Thailand using morphological characters, mating type, and the ability to cause disease (pathogenicity).
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Isolate and mating type test : Samples of B. maydis were collected from maize fields between year 1999-2000 and these were cultured and maintained on potato dextrose agar (PDA). A pair of unknown and known mating type were crossed on Sachs medium. Pseudothecium was determined 3 week after crossing.
Pathogenicity test : Nineteen isolates were evaluated for pathogenicity on 22 maize inbred lines. Isolates of B. maydis were cultured as describe above. Conidial suspensions were prepared by washing the surfaces of 14-day-old cultures with sterile water and adjusting the final concentrations to approximately 2500 conidia per ml with the aid of hematocytometer. Inoculum was applied to the leaves of 3-week-old plants and after 5 days the length of the lesions were measured. All statistical analyses were done using ANOVA.
Cultural characteristics : The cultural feature of B. maydis isolates were evaluated on PDA medium. Mycelial plugs were placed in the centre of the petri-dishes and incubated at room temperature followed by exposure to a 12 hour-photoperiod, under near UV light. Colony colour and pattern of zonation were recorded after 7 days.
DNA extraction : Total DNA was extracted from freeze-dried mycelium according to the procedure of Vandemark et al. (2000). The DNA was resolved in deionised water and stored at 4 oC until required.
AFLP analysis : The protocol employed for AFLP analysis was a version of that proposed by Vos et al. (1995). In brief, a primary DNA template is prepared by digesting 500 ng of DNA with Eco RI and Tru 9I at 37 oC for 1 h. The digested DNA is then ligated to Eco RI and Mse I adapter for 3 h at 37 oC. The primers used for the pre-amplification step were Eco RI+A and Mse I+C, the pre-amplification reaction was diluted 1:10 in dH2O prior to the second selective amplification. Selective amplification were done using the primer combinations of Eco RI+A and Mse I+CAT, Eco RI+A and Mse I+CAC, Eco RI+A and Mse I+CAG, Eco RI+AC and Mse I+C. The products were electrophoresed on 4.5% denaturing acrylamide gel, followed by a silver staining. Electrophoresis data were recorded as a binary, presence (1) or absence (0) matrix. Cluster analysis was performed using UPGMA in the SAHN procedure. (NTSYS-pc, version 1.7)
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Mating type
Fifty one out of 117 isolates are classified as mating type M1-1 and 66 isolates are mating type M1-2, accounted for 43.6 and 56.4%, respectively.
Cultural characteristics
A total of 117 isolates of B. maydis were collected from 26 regions in 19 provinces. Colonies grown on PDA medium varies in colour. In general, B. maydis were deep green colour with smooth colony, but in this study, colony colour are range from deep green, brownish-green, grayish-green and yellowish-green. Some isolates have difference colony morphology to others. Moreover, the zonation of colour and hyphae in each colony are also different, some colony has uniform colour and hyphae, but some are not uniform.
Pathogenicity test
After 5 days of inoculation, two types of disease symptom were observed as follows: 1) necrotic lesion, and ; 2) chlorotic lesion. Other researcher has shown these to be certain levels of resistance in maize (Smith, 1975). Size and shape of symptoms are different among the different maize varieties, such as oval or rectangular shapes found along the leaf veins or eyespot-like-lesions. Some varieties also show a halo or purple ring that surround the lesions. The pathogenicity of the 19 isolates over 22 maize inbred lines were statistically different (P<0.01). Maize leaf lesions varied in length from averages of 3.12 to 5.17 mm. Some inbred lines, such as nei 402015, and nei 9204 (R ) are classified as resistant with average lesion length of 2.45 and 2.83 mm, respectively. Susceptible lines are, nei 402012, nei 4012013, nei 402014, nei 402019, and nei 402020 with average lesion lengths of between 5.00 to 5.84 mm. Based on the virulence pattern, no pair of isolates were found to have identical pattern (Table 1). The most virulent isolate, TF7 was found to cause disease on 15 lines of maize. From this study, we found that there was a wide variation between the fungus that we studied, therefore, the effective development of a maize variety that is resistance to southern corn leaf blight should be developed using the virulent isolates, together with a mix of isolates in order to test the disease interaction.
Genetic relation among isolates
The dendrogram from cluster analysis using 155 loci can divided B. maydis into 4 groups with a similarity coefficient of 0.75. The biggest group consisted of 16 isolates. From this experiment found that TF7, The most virulent, shows only slightly different from this group. These 16 isolates are separate from MA1, TF1, and S4 with similarity coefficient of 0.5, 0.47 and 0.33 respectively. (Figure 2) The result shows that B. maydis, when analysis by AFLP data, they are shown to be genetically close or may be came from the same clone, this being slightly different from analysis by using pathogenicity. (Table 1 and Figure 3). This show that changing of this fungus is response to the host plant variety and these change tend to happen quicker than other means. The dendrogram, based on pathogenicity, is related to virulent pattern (Table 1 and Figure 3). Isolate MA1, TF1 and S4 are classified in the same cluster that is in the avirulent or moderately virulent, whereas Isolate TF7 are different from others. Cluster analysis using pathogenicity result to dendrogram that is slightly difference from using AFLP data in some isolates required further studies.
CONCLUSION
In the survey of B. maydis in Thailand, we found slight differences in colony colour uniformity characteristics. In some area, both mating types in the same place were found. Although, there is no evident on sexual reproduction found in nature. Both mating type in the same place may, however be caused by others genetic variation apart from sexual reproduction, such as para-sexual cycle. In this experiment, it was found that B. maydis show differences in disease severity on inbred lines tested. Cluster analysis generated using AFLP data found that most of pathogens showed closer genetic relationship than by using pathogenicity.
REFERENCES
D. Anchareesangas. 1998. Waxy Corn Disease in Utai-Thani Province. Plant Pathology and Biology Information. 8(1):15-17.
Lev, S., A. Sharon, R. Hadar, M. Hong and B.A. Horwitz. 1999. A nitrogen-activated protein kinase of the corn leaf pathogen Cochliobolus hetrostrophus is involved in conidiation, appressorium formation, and pathogenicity:Diverse roles for nitogen-activated protein kinase homologs in foliar pathogens. PNAS. 96 : 13542-13547.
Rohlf, J.F. 1993. NTSYS-pc : Numerical taxonomy and multivariate analysis system. Version 1.7.
Smith, D.R. 1975: Expression of monogenic chlorotic-lesion resistance to Helminthosporium maydis in corn. Phytopathol. 65 : 1160-1165.
Vos, P., R. Hogers, M. Bleeker, M. Reijans, T. van der Lee, M. Hornes, A. Frijter, J. Pot, J. Peleman, M. Kuiper and M. Zabeau. 1995. AFLP : a new technique for DNA fingerprinting. Nucleic Acids Res. 23 : 4407-4414.
Vandemark, G., O. Martinez, V. Penica, and M. de J. Alvarado. 2000. Assessment of genetic relationships among isolates of Macrophomina phaseolina using a simplified AFLP technique and two different methods of analysis. Mycologia. 92 : 656-664.
Table 1 Virulence phenotype of Bipolaris maydis on maize inbred line
Corn lines |
Bipolaris maydis |
|||||||||||
TF7a |
PC5 |
PL4 |
BS1 |
PN3 |
UD1-3 |
D2 |
TF1 |
PC1 |
CN3 |
VA2 |
S4 |
|
Nei 9202 T Nei 9204( R ) Nei 402008 Nei 402014 Nei 402015 Nei 402023 |
Sb M S S M S |
M M M M R R |
M R M S M M |
M R M S M M |
S M M S M M |
M M M S R M |
M M R S R M |
S M M S M M |
M M M S M M |
M M R S R M |
M M M S M M |
M S M S R M |
a
Abbreviation of locations where pathogen were collected.b
Disease reactions were categorized according to lesion length, in which 0-2 mm was classified as resistant ( R ) or avirulent, 3-4 mm as moderately susceptible or moderately virulent (M) and more than 5 mm as susceptible or virulent (S).
FCRI-paper2-2