Latham, Aaron. "The Dark Side of the AMERICAN DREAM." Rolling Stone 5 Aug. 1982: 18+.

John Hinckley believed in the American Dream, but in his mind it was twisted into an American Dream Fantasy. His girlfriends were fantasies. And his ambitions were fantasies. And in a sense, his crime, his assassination attempt, was a fantasy too.

His father believed in the Horatio Alger American Dream of working your way to the top. But John believed in the instant-hit Rock Star American Dream. This baby-faced young man - who had breakfast at McDonald's before shooting the president - wanted his fame to be as quick as American fast food. He also believed in another version of the American Dream - the Rich Daddy American Dream - which goes something like this: If I get into trouble, my rich daddy will bail me out. Which, as it turns out, was not so crazy.

Now, we have all dreamed American Dreams similar to Hinckley's, have all indulged at one time or another in the fast-fame fantasy, have all lost ourselves from time to time at the movies. There is a little John Hinckley in all of us. He is the underbelly of our ambitions. He is our bad fantasies. He is the flip side - as they say in the record business he so wanted to break into - of our inventiveness. When you turn over the American Dream, there he is living on the bottom of it, a fat white larva. John Hinckley's complexion is the complexion of a larva. Pasty.

Of course, we are all infected with the fantasy fever, but he developed a much higher temperature than most of us a killing fever. We will never know for sure why he got so sick, but one psychiatrist who studied him in jail has a almost fantastical hypothesis. He did not offer his theory when he testified for the defense at the trial, because it seems to belong more in a fantasy movie than in a courtroom. But we discussed it in his Harvard Medical School office.

"This is almost sci-fi," Dr. David Michael Bear told me. And then he went on to outline a possible scientific scenario, starring John Hinckley, that reminded me of those science-fiction stories about children who are born different. In the movies, they often have glowing eyes, special brains and do terrible deeds. In the real world, which can also be fantastic, John Hinckley could well be one of these children. Except for the glowing eyes. His eyes are quite dull.

What made John Hinckley's brain different--or rather what may have done so--is almost more sci-fi than sci-fi. Some doctors at Harvard now believe, based primarily on theories proposed by Dr. Norman Geshwin, that the human race has a way of increasing or decreasing the number of dreamers it produces. When stress is low humans produce fewer dreamers because the species needs less imagination. But when stress increases, special hormones--testosterone among them--are released in a pregnant woman's body; these help to shape more experimental brains. More deep-dreamers brains. More left-handed brains. More inventive brains with the ability to dream up new solutions. And more defective brains.

"When John Hinckley's mother was in the third month of her pregnancy," explained Dr. Bear, who did not look like a mad scientist in a fantasy movie, "the family home burned down. John turned out to be left-handed and to have a shrunken brain. Maybe he got a pulse of testosterone that might have made him a genius but made him a schizophrenic instead."

Which recalls a poem John wrote called "He Would Have Been a Genius," in which he says he was born insane.

The theories about what happens to the offspring of mothers who were under stress during their pregnancies have centered on children born in England during World War II. This turns out to be an extraordinary generation. And one of the most extraordinary members of this generation was John Hinckley's idol, John Lennon.

The Rock Star Fantasy

John Hinckley wanted to be John Lennon. He used to spend his time alone in his room, teaching himself to play the guitar, practicing to be Lennon. A shy boy, John never got up the nerve to play for his sister or brother or mother or father. He didn't have to worry about playing for his friends, because he didn't have any. But this loner, who was too timid to entertain anyone he knew, dreamed of entertaining the whole world. Becoming a rock star was the original fantasy out of which the assassination fantasy would grow.

"John Hinckley's interest in the Beatles," testified Dr. Park Dietz, a psychiatrist who appeared as a prosection witness, "is the earliest sign that he came exceedingly interested in fame that would not require a great deal of effort." The Easy American Dream Fantasy.

Propelled by his fantasies, the reticent would-be rock star made the first of his many trips in search of stardom in April 1976. The larva was migrating. He wrote to his parents in Evergreen, Colorado, that he was dropping out of Texas Tech University and leaving Lubbock--but he did not say where he planned to go or what he planned to do.

"We didn't hear from John for about six weeks," his mother, Jo Ann Hinckley, recalled on the witness stand. "We had no idea where he was. We were very worried and didn't know whether he was dead or alive. The first communication we had was a Mother's Day card. There was no return address."

John Hinckley followed his fantasies to Hollywood. The man whom he would one day shoot had followed similar dreams to the same town a couple of generations earlier. But Hinckley evidently never got beyond the receptionists who guard the doors to stardom.

"The purpose of this move," William T. Carpenter, a defense psychiatrist, told the jury, "was to move to where the publishers of music were. But he very quickly became discouraged, depressed, feeling like he could not make it in life. And it was at that time that he saw Taxi Driver."

Dr. Bear:

"He first saw Taxi Driver at the Egyptian Theater. He told me he immediately felt; 'I am like Travis. I am a loner. I am unhappy. I have no girlfriend. I look around me. I see how horrible things are.'

The Taxi Driver Fantasy

"What Hinckley identified with was not the violence but the pathology," says Paul Schrader, who wrote Taxi Driver. "We could stop presenting criminals realistically. Then we would still have psychopaths, but we wouldn't have art. We would still have Raskolnikovs, but we wouldn't have Crime and Punishment. The psychopaths would just identify with something else, comic books, swimsuit ads."

I asked Schrader if we weren't all members of a fantasy generation.

"Well, fantasy is a much bigger business than it used to be. It used to be a mom-and-pop business. A family business. Your family told you fairy tales. But now fantasies are pumped to by faceless conglomerates. By TV."

The Fantasy Girlfriend

At last, on June 10th, 1976, John wrote his parents that he was in trouble and needed help. Caught up in a Hollywood nightmare, he was resorting to the Rich Daddy American Dream, counting, as he always would, on his father, the wealthy oilman, to bail him out.

Mother: "Someone had broken into his room and taken everything he owned. He had been living on rooftops and sleeping on park benches. He had no money and no clothing, and he had no place to stay. We were frantic."

Father: "I went to the 7-Eleven store nearby and bought a money order and sent it with twenty dollars in cash to John, along with a letter telling him we were so pleased to hear from him, even though it was not a very happy circumstance. And for him to take the twenty dollars and get something to eat and get cleaned up and see if he could cash the money order. And for him to call so we could get back in touch."

John Hinckley may or may not have been robbed. No such robbery was ever reported to the police, so it is possible that he was dramatized his life to get money from his parents. He certainly dramatized it in later letters when he told of a new girlfriend.

Father: "John tells us about a girl named Lynn. He was going to Malibu with her. He was having a good time for change. And we were very pleased."

Dr. Carpenter: "In order to try to get his parents to continue to provide financial support, he fabricated a girlfriend named Lynn. This woman was very similar to one of the leading characters of Taxi Driver."

Dr. Bear: "After John saw the movie, he began writing to his parents about a woman named Lynn Collins: 'She is a blond woman, a fine woman. She is a writer.' John told me the idea of making up a girlfriend came directly from Travis Bickle. Travis was a washout with girls and yet would write home: 'am doing well with Betsy. Things are just fine.'"

Dr. Carpenter: "He spent time keeping a diary about her, planning activities. And over time, she began to take on something of a life with him."

Having given up on selling his songs, John had little to do besides go to movies and make movies in his mind.

Idle Fantasies

"People fantasize in idle periods," Dr. Bear told me. "Moderate stress stops fantasies. But with extreme stress another kind of fantasizing begins."

When people are not busy, well, idle minds are the devil's--or sometimes the angel's--playthings.

"A lot of drifters live in a fantasy world." Dr. Bear continued. "People who are disengaged, who spend a lot of time with their own thoughts, fantasize more. This is a part of what happened to John Hinckley. This is true of all drifters. They fantasize about what they might be in life. About success. A fair number are going to be schizophrenics, some really sick. Their fantasies will be grandiose fantasies...like writing a hit song."

When a drifter gets a job, the fantasies tend to evaporate. That is what tending to business does. But then this whole picture reverses itself as stress increases from moderate to extreme. For extreme stress opens the wells of fantasy once again. And the new fantasies that flow are essentially attempts to dream up solutions to the problems that are causing the stress in the first place. So fantasies have at least two muses: idleness and stress.

Dr. Bear believers that cultures trend to behave much like individuals. When a culture or a society is simply drifting, the way ours seems to be, it encourages idle fantasies. Science fiction movies. Clothes that sometimes verge on costumes. Comic books. And perhaps occasionally a fantasy assassin.

When a culture really gets down to the business of business, as ours did in, say, the Fifties, then fantasies tend to flee. But when the pressure is increased...

"When cultures are under stress," said Dr. Bear, "there are more fantasies. Fear fantasies. War fantasies. Invention goes up in times of stress. World War II produced lots of inventive fantasies. Look at the Manhattan Project."

I asked Dr. Bear if we were living in a fantasy age.

"Yes. Right now I think we have a lot of dreamers. We are in both a low-stress and a high-stress period culturally. It is low stress compared to World War II. No one is shooting at us. But it is high stress because we could all the blown up tomorrow. It is a super setup for fantasizing."

The danger is that our dreamy drifting culture throws off dangerous drifting dreamers.

Failed Fantasies

Father: "All of a sudden everything had fallen apart. John was having problems with his eyes. A man on the street attempted to rob him. The progress he thought he was making with selling his songs had fallen apart. And worst of all he had broken up with his girlfriend, Lynn."

Mother: "He wished to come back home."

Hinckley's first trip to Hollywood was a paradigm for many other trips to many other places. He followed his fantasies with high hopes, failed to transform his fantasies into reality, became depressed, and retreated. It happened over and over agin. He spent years sallying forth in search of the Fast Fame American Dream and then returning to the Rich Daddy American Dream at home.

He always went home again. Or always tried to . He never wanted to leave home, never wanted to move beyond dependency, never wanted to grow up. He was slow to walk, even to slower to drive, and continued to live at home off and on until he was almost twenty-six (his age when he shot the president on March 30th 1981).

Mother: "He called us from the Denver airport and asked us to pick him up."

He did not stay home for very long, but then he did not go very far away either. He got a job at the Taylor Supper Club in a Denver suburb, and moved into a motel across the street.

Father: "It was a very old, little motel. The room was concrete block walls. I don't think there was any carpet on the floor. It was just a string of rooms one next to the other maybe eight or ten rooms long, one story high."

John Hinckley worked at the Taylor Supper Club for about five months, from September through February 1977, and then grew restless again.

Dr. Carpenter: "He made another trip to Hollywood in an effort to sell music, one that lasted for only about three weeks. And at that time he got very depressed, had suicidal thoughts. He found himself doing many things that the character in Taxi Driver had done, sitting around watching X-rated movies, spending time alone."

Father: "He hated it. Everything went wrong. So he came home and then went back to Texas."

But he was too restless to stay in Texas long. Soon, as the song says, he was on the road again.

Dr. Carpenter: "He made one more attempt at selling his songs. This time he drove to Nashville. Got to the city. Took a look at it. Felt total despair. And turned around and left."

He returned to Lubbock and enrolled for the summer session at Texas Tech, where he changed his major from business to literature and journalism.

Father: "In the early part of 1978, he started having several illnesses. And they moved all over his body. He had problems with his ears, throat, arms, eyes."

Toward the end of the 1978 fall semester, John dropped out of school again and went to Dallas to live in an apartment all alone, alone again, as always. And he unhappily stuffed himself with fast food until he looked more and more like a fat larva on the underside of the American Dream. When he went home for Christmas, his parents were concerned.

Mother: "He had put on an awful lot of weight."

The new year, 1979, began ominously, with the prospect of a visit from John's imaginary girlfriend, Lynn Collins.

Dr. Carpenter: "Having broken with her, she is finally reentering his life now. He becomes obsessed with it so deeply that he had the appropriate emotional experiences that go along with it. It is becoming difficult for him to sort out what is reality and what is a concoction from his own mind."

Mother: "He was getting ready for Lynn's visit, trying to lose weight."

Father: "He got sick from fasting, but as soon as he saw her, he felt better."

But John Hinckley could not even hold an imaginary girlfriend. She had places to go and things to do that were more important than he was. Soon she had returned to California. And John returned to Texas and a state of depression. He consoled himself by reading about hate.

Dr. Carpenter: "He was reading Nazi literature, right-wing, extreme-right ideological literature."

The Fantasy Gap

Ironically, John Hinckley was fantasizing about a Nazi world that would have done all it could to force him to shut down his fantasies.

"One of the worst things about totalitarian states," Dr. Bear told me, "is that they dry up fantasies. And so they dig their own graves. On the other hand, our level of fantasizing is high. And that may turn out to be one of our great survival advantages. The U.S.S.R. puts so many curbs on fantasies. But here our fantasies are right out in the open. And some fantasies lead to new solutions, like Thomas Edison imaging things no one had ever seen before. But by encouraging fantasy, which is good, we may also allow people with defective brains to be hurt--or to hurt others. Fantasies help the strong but hurt the defective."

John Hickey is what is bad about what is good about America.

American-Front Fantasy

Dr. Carpenter:

When he wrote his parents from Lubbock about the American Front, they were upset that their son had made such weird friends who might influence him for the worse.

Dr. Carpenter: "He had also purchased a .38-caliber pistol during 1979, in August. He used that pistol at first in a room alone, kind of aiming at the TV. In Taxi Driver, Travis Bickle used his guns to aim at the television set."

Shoot-the-TV-Fantasy

Paul Schrader, the creator of 'Taxi Driver' hates television enough to shoot a TV set. Which is why he had his script's protagonist point a gun at one.

"There is a kind of fantasy that is productive," he told me, "but there is another fantasy that alienates you from the reality of feelings. Like modelmania fantasies. Sanitized T & A. That's an unhealthy expression of fantasy, removed from any real physicality, unattainable. That's seventy-five percent of TV ads and thirty percent of TV shows. They make you as two-dimensional as they are."

Fantasy Suicide

Mother: " 1979 was the first and only time that John did not come home for Christmas. Our son told us he was going to New York with his girlfriend, Lynn Collins. He had written a novel, and he was going to take the manuscript around to different publishers in New York."

Dr. Carpenter: "He didn't really do that. He didn't feel he could go home and face the effort of trying to be with his family. So he spent that time in Lubbock, alone and in a state of server depression."

Dr. Thomas C. Goldman, another defense psychiatrist: "During this period, John is actually playing Russian roulette. He had a revolver that had five chambers in the cylinder, and he had one round in the cylinder. He would spin it, point it to his head, pull the trigger once. Each time he didn't get the loaded chamber, he said: This is my lucky day."

John Hinckley began the new year, 1980, by buying a rifle. They he posed for pictures with his new friends, his firearms. In one photograph, he holds both his rifle and his handgun; in another he holds the handgun to his head.

Dr. Bear: "He would make playful maneuvers with the gun pointing to his head as Travis Bickle did. In the final scene of that movie. Travis points to his own head like this, click: 'This is the time to shoot myself."

Mother:

The mother took her son from doctor to doctor, but they couldn't find anything wrong.

After spending a few weeks at home, the restless son headed for Dallas to spend some time with his sister, who lived there. Then he returned to Lubbock.

That spring, John Hinckley started turning out poem after sad poem, practicing his meter at the same time he was practicing with his guns. What he had in mind, he later told his doctors, was becoming a "psychopathic poet."

Dr. Goldman: "He decided to be a writer, but the tragic thing about the way he pursued this was that he did it alone. He never showed it to teachers or anybody."

He could-not show his writing to anyone anymore than he could play his guitar for anyone, but he nonetheless intended to be a famous writer.

In the spring of 1980, wh wrote a poem about his lonely, womanless life:

Dr. Carpenter: "I think it was in May when he saw an article about Jodie Foster in People magazine describing her plans to attend Yale. And on reading that, he became much more intensely preoccupied with Jodie Foster."

While Jodie Foster was preparing for her freshman year at Yale, John Hinckley enrolled in summer school at Texas Tech. That summer the "psychopathic poet" began writing poetry about the movie star whom he lived: "Yes, she was another beauty. She's oblivious to my existence." Eventually he intended to change that.

Mother: "He was having new complaints, stress, weakness and a vertigo feeling. His legs wouldn't hold him."

John saw a doctor in Lubbock, a Dr. Rosen.

Mother: "Dr. Rosen prescribed an antidepressant called Serentil and also a tranquilizer called Valium."

Dr. Bear: "Travis Bickle was a compulsive pill-taker. And John Hinckley also was a tremendous taker of pills."

Father: "By the end of that semester, he was just unable to cope. And my wife and I decided again to bring him home and see if we could get some more help for him. I made arrangements with a psychologist by the name of Durrell Benjamin, our company psychologist, to see John."

John's parents also met with Dr. Benjamin.

Father: "He told me that John was immature and that we needed to work out a long-range plan to make John self-sufficient. John had heard of a writer's school at Yale, so when Dr. Benjamin recommended the long-term agreement, we worked it out that John would go to it."

The family drew up a written agreement that set forth the terms under which he was to be allowed the money to go:

"I will receive the sum of $3000 in check, taken from my stock...to last from September 17th to February the 1st... And I do pledge to try to make the coming weeks and months as productive as possible. It is now or never. Thank you for the money and one more chance. John W. Hinckley Jr."

The day after he signed this contract, John left for New Haven. But the only long-term plan he had in mind was a till-death-do-us-part romance with Jodie Foster.

Dr. Carpenter: "The trip to New Haven was not predicated on attending a writing course. He wouldn't have proven eligible. But it was predicated on what had developed in his own mind about Jodie Foster. He saw a number of movies on TV that August with Jodie Foster in them. It was his feeling that the movies had been put on TV to excite him into action, to get him going to make this union with her."

And so John Hinckley set off the find Jodie Foster as if she were some Wizard of Oz who could heal him. In a sense, he was trying to go home again, for she had become something of a mother figure to him. He even began one poem: "Jodie, please watch over me." When he finally reached New Haven, he tried to introduce himself to her by slipping some of his poetry under her door.

Dr. Goldman: "I believe this was the first attempt he made to show his writing to somebody."

Dr. Carpenter: "He did succeed in having two telephone conversations with her during that trip. When he made contact with her, what he was anticipating was an almost magical union. What actually happened on the telephone was kind of the awkwardness of ' Why are you calling?' and not knowing quite what to say, and, kind of pleading almost like a little boy, pleading for her to stay on the telephone. His reaction was that he had been a total failure."

The "psychopathic poet" wrote: "The pain is sharper than a hypodermic penis/Caught in a working meat grinder."

Foster Fantasy

Feeling uncomfortably like John Hinckley, I dialed Jodie Foster's number. After a couple of rings, I heard her familiar, confident voice answer. I told her that I was covering the trial and asked if I could talk to her about Hinckley.

"We talked it over," Jodie Foster said. "And we decided I shouldn't talk about him."

Still hoping for something for my story, I wanted to try to keep her on the phone a little longer, feeling, again, much as Hinckley might have felt. So I told her I was going to write about Hinckley as a member of the fantasy generation.

"That's been the consensus," Jodie Foster said. "I think you should go ahead with it."

Three-Gun Fantasy

Having been gone from home a week--as long as he could sustain the long-term plan-John returned to his real mother.

Mother:

The larva was about to turn.

Dr. Carpenter:

The Fast Fame American Dream had somehow been twisted into the Instant Infamy American Nightmare. But even this bad dream eluded him. Shooting a president was turning out to be just as hard as meeting a movie star.

Dr. Carpenter:

Later that day, John Hinckley flew back to his mecca, New Haven, where he had intended to abduct Jodie Foster, chain her in handcuffs and lead her away. But the police in Nashville had taken not only his guns but his handcuffs. So an unarmed Hickey checked into the Colony Inn in New Haven. The next day, he paid the bill of forty-six dollars and checked out. Then he checked into the Hotel Duncan but checked out only a few hours later. He finally wound up at the Sheraton Park Plaza Hotel were he spent the night at a cost of thirty-nine dollars. The next day...

Dr. Carpenter: "He went back to Dallas to replenish the arsenal. He purchased two .22-caliber handguns."

Rearmed, John returned to New Haven. Naturally. He checked into the Sheraton Park Plaza Hotel were he stayed for two days. The bill was seventy-eight dollars.

Next, he flew to Washington where he registered at the Quality Inn Downtown. Again, he stayed only two days. The bill was $56.80. Then he flew home.

Father:

Mother: "My son was looking just haunted, just in total despair. It frightened me he looked so bad. Hopper told us we had to make him wait forty-eight hours. We talked him down to twenty-four hours. We decided John could come home after one more night out on the streets."

Father: "I learned from my wife that John called several time at the house during the day and was just frantic."

When their son called the next morning, after the prescribed night on the streets of New York City, his parents told him yes, all right, he could come home.

Father:

This time, John's mother did not meet his plane.

Mother: "I could not go. I had been crying all day. And the last few sessions with Dr. Hopper were just crying sessions for me. I was very torn up about this plan of ours to cut him off. I didn't like the plan and was just going along to present a united front with my husband."

Father:

And having said so much, John W. Hinckley Sr. cried.

Barred by his parents from his home--which Robert Frost defined as the place where, when you go there, they have to take you in--John Hinckley checked into the Golden Hours Motel in Lakewood. His time there did not live up to the name on the sign. He spent most of the next week sitting alone in a motel room with the blinds drawn. The few times he ventured out were to convert his movable possessions into cash. He sold his typewriter, his records (even his Beatles albums) and all but one of his guns to raise money for one last trip. When a policeman stopped him for jaywalking one day, he got frightened. He decided it was time to pay his bill ($110) and check out.

John Hinckley moved into the Motel 6 in Lakewood and registered under the name of J.Travis. Mr. Travis stayed only two nights. His bill was $25.34.

Father: "John called and said he was thinking of going to California. And I was very upset to hear this story again. And we talked about his old car, whether it would make it to California. He even proposed that I sell the car and give him the money. I refused to do that. When I quit talking to John, he was still talking with JoAnn. I really did not know whether he was going to California or staying in Denver."

Mother:

Once he got to Hollywood, John Hinckley stayed less than twenty-four hours. Having flown to one coast one day, he turned around and headed for the other coast the next day. But this time he traveled by bus. He bought a ticket for New Haven but decided to go via Washington. He spent the next four days and nights on a Greyhound. Sleeping poorly, the larva from the bottom of the American Dream twisted and turned, dreamed and schemed, from coast to coast.

Arriving in Washington around noon, John Hinckley went to the Park Central Hotel, a block and a half from the White House, registered, and was shown to room 312. He went to bed early, about 8:30 p.m., but slept badly.

Dr. Dietz:

Dr. Bear:

Having written his letter, John picked up a red John Lennon Button and put it in his left coat pocket. Then he put his .22 in his right pocket; for almost the only thing he did with his right hand, which was controlled by the nondreamy, nonfantasy side of his brain, was fire a gun. Armed with his button and his .22--the Rock Star Dream and Assassination Dream united at last--he left his room.

Dr. Bear:

John Hinckley Jr. shot the president of the United States on the day before his parents planned to stop supporting him. In his mind, he shot the national father figure, the president, in order to attain his own private mother figure, Jodie Foster. Now he would be take care of, watched over.

Father:

Mother: "On March 30th I received a telephone call. It was a reporter from the Washington Post who said: 'Do you have your television on?' And I said: 'Yes.' And he said: 'Did you know that your son, John Hinckley, is the man they have identified as shooting the president?'"

At first, it must have seemed like another bad made-for-television fantasy, but this time it was real.

Dr. Bear, psychiatrist for the defense, told me before the verdict: "The law needs to be changed. If John Hinckley is found not guilty, they will have to change the law."

John Hinckley Sr. paid Dr. Bear to testify on behalf of his son. He paid lots of doctors. The Rich Daddy American Dream worked again.

As John Hinckley told one of the psychiatrists: "The movie isn't over yet."

Now the movie's setting has been shifted to St. Elizabeth's mental hospital, where John Hinckley has access to a telephone. He has already started calling his lawyers--whom he seems to regard as the only "friends" he has ever had--all day long. He has called the Washington Post. Soon he may try calling Jodie Foster. Already, he can taste the freedom of wandering through the nation's communications network in search of his dreams. And one of these days he may be free altogether to stalk his dreams though society once more.

So, I find that I cannot help fantasizing about a call he may someday make:

"Hello, Daddy, I just shot Jodie Foster. Can I come home?"

1