2000
Qantas International Challenge
Olympic Test Event
Sydney, February
25-27, 2000
|
Otherwise
known as the Olympic Test Event, this competition attracted
a number of competitors from around the world (unfortunately
no Russian gymnasts). A rhythmic and a trampoline competition
were held concurrently with the artistic event. This report
concerns the women's all around competition. Twelve Australian
gymnasts competed (in PINK),
not only for the AA title, but the scores achieved here
would be added to the scores they received at the Australian
Championships, Senior International Division, to determine
their national ranking.
Pre
competition favourites were Romania's Andrea Isarescu, China's
Kui Yuan Yuan (making a comeback), Ukraine's Natalia Gorodni,
but Allana Slater, the new Australian champion, could not
be discounted.
|
In
the end, however, there was a surprise winner. Canada's
Emilie Fournier competed consistently all night to
finish with the highest score. A measure of her consistency,
while her rivals made costly errors, is the fact that she
was 7th after the second rotation, and 3rd after the third
(about 30 competitors). Because I didn't expect her to medal,
I made the unfortunate mistake of neglecting the majority
of her routines (and it was hard to keep track with 4 events
going simultaneously). However, on beam, her final piece
of apparatus, she displayed a powerful pike front mount
(floated and high) to immediate tuck jump; as well as a
punch pike front mid routine.
Andrea
Isarescu finished second, and was the last competitor
on the floor. She needed a 9.7 odd to win, and being the
1998 Junior European champion on that piece of apparatus,
theoretically it wasn't out of the question. However, a
questionable landing on a jump connection meant no gold
medal for her. Tumbling quite consistent - nice 2 1/2 twist
punch front. Her Phelps vaults are reasonably well laid
out, but it is frustrating to see the Romanian girls pike
their post flights and score highly, while many other gymnasts
can reach a layout position and get a lower score. But I
digress. Isarescu has some interesting qualities, but she
is still very Romanian.
Both
Chinese gymnasts were very good. It was great to finally
see the exciting Kui Yuan Yuan live - she is a head
taller than she was in Atlanta, and even Lausanne (well,
she is 18 years old now). Her beam was packed, even though
it was slightly watered down - switch leap, Yang jump combo;
FF, layout, layout; FF, FF, whip (no full twist, although
I suspect she will put it back in); wolf jump, Rulfova;
double tuck off. Her release on bars was a Tkatchev, and
I enjoyed the relatively mature choreography in her floor
(cheeky start pose).
Yang
Yun is a new name from China with some exciting gymnastics.
On bars, she displayed a HUGE Ono turn (pirouette around
one arm) to a HUGE piked Jaeger; and an amazing high and
floated Pak salto. Beam was typical Chinese style, and she
included an interesting wolf jump 3/4 to a Yurchenko loop
(without the back hip circle). Vault was her undoing, falling
backwards on one attempt. Yang did her best to outdo the
Aussie's pink leos with her own glad wrap neon pink version.
Both
"Spainish" competitors, Sara Moro and Esther
Moya, had the routines and talent to win, but once again,
errors held them back. Sara Moro is an exciting gymnast
with a crisp, clean style, and difficult routines. Her beam
routine was excellent and packed with difficulty - layout
on; aerial walkover to a cute little pose; side somi; pike
jump to 3/4 turn to Shushunova; FF, layout FF; Rulfova;
double tuck off. Bars includes a Stalder 1/2 turn to inverted
giant; and a front giant full turn to Jaeger.
Esther
Moya is an excellent vaulter (she actually won this in the
EF), using a RO, 1/2 on, piked barani off (great height).
Her bar routine, while excellent, was also notable for being
one of the few in the field to mount straight onto the high
bar. The routine included a front giant full turn to Jaeger;
Tkatchev; and a double front 1/2 dismount.
I
was excited by the gymnasts sent out to represent Italy
- Adriana Crisci and Martina Bremini, but
it was evident that they weren't in peak condition. Bremini
is a personal favourite of mine, but unfortunately she started
with falls on beam (no Popa jump, but a nice Silivas mount),
which continued through onto floor. Her jumps on floor were
extended and high, one of her characteristics. Vault was
better where she displayed a full and double twisting Yurchenko.
|
A
feature of Adriana Crisci's work is her crisp and light
style, which I find is particularly evident on beam. Her
main series on beam (FF, layout, FF) is magic, but she came
unstuck on a tour jete, which she landed on two feet. She
also had problems landing her double tuck off. Crisci includes
a gorgeous, split leg dive roll in her floor, which almost
hangs in mid air at one point, such is the skill with which
she performs this simple move. She came to grief at the
end of her floor, falling heavily on the last tumble, and
she appeared momentarily to be injured, but still finished
the competition.
The
Belarussian girls, Natalia Naramovich and Marina
Zarzhitskaya, were also plagued by major errors. Naramovich
was first up on beam, and had the misfortune of falling
at least three times, scoring 6.9 odd. Zarzhitskaya had
problems on all apparatus, but displayed some mature choreography
on beam and floor.
Natalia
Gorodni was in the lead for most of the night, but her
final apparatus, vault, did her in (this seems to be a real
problem for the "Jukraine" team as a whole). She
displayed gymnastics which can be described as "typical
Ukrainian" - good technique, form and style, with no
big risks. A highlight of her bars was a 1 1/2 pirouette
into a piked Jaeger, while on beam she showed a hesitant
Yang Bo type jump; but her side somersault, and her dismount
series (FF, FF, double tuck) were excellent.
Galina
Tyryk, her elegant team mate, made errors to finish
down the standings, such as falls on floor and vault. I
really enjoyed her beautiful beam routine, which had similar
elements to Gorodni's, eg side somi, and she performed two
consecutive Yang Bo type jumps. I call them this because
they didn't really jump into them, they sort of stepped
into them, put their heads back momentarily, but their feet
barely left the beam. (Right:
Galina Tyryk performs a beautiful Yang Bo jump on beam).
The
sunburnt British girls (yes, the sun is much stronger in
Australia!) went through the motions. Holly Murdock
withdrew from the competition after beam, although it wasn't
clear why. She is an excellent beam worker, with an interesting
aerial walkover mount to sit sideways, to a reverse straddle
balance. Natalie Lucitt displayed some nice choreography
on floor and beam, but overall, I didn't see much of her
gymnastics. Similarly, I didn't take note of the routines
peformed by Fournier's team mate Amelie Plante, although
she was noticeably more elegant.
I
was so excited to see Ludivine Furnon and Elvire
Teza, the veteran performers from France. After seeing
them on TV for years, it was an experience to see them in
person. I couldn't believe how tiny the 19 year old Furnon
was, and the personality she displays on TV is very much
evident live. Her new floor routine, to techno music, was
very well received. Starting with a double layout punch
front, she displayed a well choreographed routine - she
moves so beautifully on floor, that it's not hard to see
why she makes finals at Worlds. Her beam was also a treat.
Starting with a jump 1/4 turn to side split mount, she showed
a nice side somi; FF, layout, FF series; change leg side
leap to immediate Shushunova (even quicker than Trudy's),
but she nearly came to grief on her punch front (those new
beams are slippery).
|
Elvire
Teza was equally as exciting, especially on beam on bars.
A treat for everyone was her trademark move on beam, the
"Teza", which is a full twisting backflip to support
across the beam. Her leg form on this isn't great, but it's
such a wild move (oohs from the crowd), you can't really
blame her. She also includes a wolf jump, Rulfova combo,
and a 2 1/2 twist off. Bars includes a German giant (kind
of a stoop through to an L-grip giant), to piked Jaeger,
immediate overshoot 1/2 turn to handstand on low bar. From
memory, she had problems on floor and vault to keep her
down the standings.
Jana
Komrskova from the Czech Republic is a gymnast I have
become familiar with over the past year or so, due to Foxtel's
coverage of the Grand Prix events, so I was pleased that
this tall, somewhat elegant gymnast made the trip out here.
Unfortunately she didn't have the best competition, with
falls on floor (bad take off for her 2 1/2 twist punch front),
and maybe another on beam. She made vault finals, performing
a difficult "Pod" vault (RO, 1/2 on, pike barani
off).
Jeanette
Antolin from the United States wore a sleeveless leotard
for this competition - to each their own, but I hope this
trend doesn't catch on. The muscly Antolin has some interesting
routines and some difficult skills, but she made a number
of errors to finish below her potential. Her bars is accentuated
with amazing swing, and an L-grip giant to die for - she
really powers her way over the top of the bar, straight
into a dazzling layout Jaeger. Her dismount has been described
as a double front half, but she does it differently, swinging
out of the preceding giant with an inverted grip. Vault
was a layout Khorkina. Her floor routine is performed to
the theme from Gone with the wind, and
was quite well presented, with nice use of her hands. Her
tumbling was watered down from what I've seen in the past
(whip double pike; double pike). (Left:
Jeanette Antolin shows an interesting
variation on an arabesque).
Twelve
Australian gymnasts competed in the AA, and unlike Wednesday
night's excellent competition, many of the girls made uncharacteristic
errors. Tired? Nervous? Self conscious in the pink leos?
One can only guess.
The
highest placed Australian was Melinda Cleland, who
was 6th, despite a fall on one of her tumbles on floor.
However, she went on the stick her vaults (handspring layout;
same with 1/2 turn), her bars (trademark sky high dismount)
and a beautiful beam.
Allana
Slater looked set to win the event until she fell on
her punch front mount on beam, and a further fall on floor
didn't help her at all. However, her bars and vaults (layout
and piked Cuervo) were very good. Her bars was one of the
highlights of the night, as she competed a double twisting
double back dismount - first Australian girl to do so, and
only one of a handful of girls who have EVER competed it.
Trudy
McIntosh started on bars, her weakest event, and once
again, she experienced some problems, scoring just 8.05.
But being the fighting competitor she is, she erased memories
of the fall by storming back on beam (beautiful FF, FF,
whip series) and floor. On vault she performed an easy handspring
layout, but slipped backwards on her McIntosh. Despite this,
she still scored high enough to make EF on vault, as well
as floor and beam.
|
Brooke
O'Brien was one of the few Australians to go through
the night with no major errors. She arguably owns the best
triple twist in the country - such a tight and fast twist,
and all the way round - no cheating 2 3/4 quarter twists
for her.
Jacqui
Dunn was great on bars, scoring 9.6+, but her AA was
spoilt by a fall on her FF, Onodi series on beam. Her floor
routine, to one of the songs from the movie The mask,
shows improved expression, and all tumbles were pretty much
stuck. It was interesting to note the reaction of Ludivine
Furnon, who once used this music - she was dancing to it
on the side (using the moves from her floor) while Jacqui
was performing!
Zeena
McLaughlin had trouble with her tumbling on floor, and
may have fallen from bars. Her Yurchenko 1 1/2 was good,
and she was back to the Zeena of 1998 on beam, with an excellent
routine, scoring 9.537. Unfortunately she didn't get to
compete in the EF as her score tied Melinda Cleland, and
Peggy Liddick gave Melinda the nod due to her higher AA
score.
Tam
Le went through with no major errors, and as usual her
beam routine was a highlight, despite a wonky mount. She
has a really nice style on this apparatus, and the jump
half turn to split handstand across the beam, lowering to
a planche, got all the cameras clicking away. Another highlight
of Tam's work is her Endos on bars - she achieves a deep
straddle position as she swings under the bar. I noticed
that Tam was finding increased consistency on her beam and
bars, and possibly floor, but it is her floor and vault
work that is noticeably weaker and holds her back in AA
competitions.
Brooke
Walker had a reasonable competition, and once again
elected to perform a handspring pike front half on vault
(she's capable of a layout). Her floor routine was very
good, and she made finals on this piece of apparatus. Beam
was another good event - she has really found her consistency
on this apparatus -the last thing you expect is for her
to fall.(Right:
The elegant Brooke Walker shows her style on beam).
|
Jenny
Smith had problems on beam and bars, but once again,
we were treated to some excellent vaulting from this gymnast.
Her Yurchenko 1 1/2 was excellent - comparable to Shushunova's
version - height, form, distance, and a stuck landing.
Lisa
Skinner performed much better tonight than she did in
the Nationals AA, but a few errors still crept in, eg she
missed her sissone jump after her punch front mount, foot
out on two tumbles. Lisa has introduced a difficult combination
into her floor routine - a triple pivot to immediate Shushunova!
If there was one gymnast that the pink leo looked really
good on, it was Lisa (see photo left).
Liz
Wong also made errors on beam and floor, but she performed
one of the best bar routines of the night for a score of
9.50. Her form on this apparatus is excellent, and her releases
are a Shaposhnikova, and a straddled Jaeger.
Alexandra
Croak went through the motions - it really wasn't her
night at all. She missed her difficult Kim released on the
bars, and there may have been an extra swing elsewhere in
the routine. She also put her hands down on her opening
tumble on floor, which was an Arabian double front. More
competitive experience can only help this gymnast find her
consistency.
Katarina
Frketic missed her Shaposhnikova on bars (just like
Nationals), and may have fallen from beam, but her floor
routine was excellent. After several months off through
injury, Frketic can only improve from this point.
Reading
back, it seems that the Australian girls performed really
badly - they certainly made errors, but so did many of the
international gymnasts. In the end, consistency won out,
and Emilie Fournier was a deserving winner of the title.
Gorodny, Isarescu and Slater all had their chances, but
failed to go 4 for 4.
I
didn't see both sessions of the Event Finals, but the winner's
were as follows : vault - Esther Moya (ESP); bars - Allana
Slater (AUS, best bars I've ever seen from her); beam -
Kui Yuan Yuan (CHN, fantastic) and floor - Trudy McIntosh
(AUS).
©
Dudnik, 2000
|
|
|