"I remember getting a little teary-eyed when Rafe had to leave Alison on Christmas Eve, but when Rafe went back to Heaven at the end of Secrets, I was bawling!! It was also very sad when Rafe lost his memory and watching Alison experience the pain of not having him remember their love. And of course, when they didn't get married at Christmas, I was crying a lot too." -Melody

"The most heart-wrenching scenes for me were when Rafe was shot by Livvie in the barn and he dies in Alison's arms *sniff* and when Alison thinks Rafe is her brother and they have the argument back at the house after what was supposed to be their wedding *sob* we could all feel her pain ripping through our hearts then. Also when she's begging Rafe to remember her during the whole Livvie mess." -Cat

"When they got married." -Kelly Wayne

"When Rafe had to go back to Heaven and leave Alison." -Stephenie

"When she thought she'd killed him during Desire. When she says goodbye to him after Livvie shot him. When after the non-wedding they talk, and he finally leaves the house...and you think he's not coming back and Alison starts to cry--gets me every time." -Katie

"The day she came back from that horrible night with Caleb." -Kathy

"1-When Rafe left at the end of Secrets "I will love you forever Alison Barrington." 2-Rafe dies in the barn after Livvie shoots him. 3-The wedding that wasn't at the end of Naked Eyes. 4-Alison and Caleb do it." -Kelly

"When Rafe died in the barn and Alison was holding him and he said that he came back down to said that he never in his heart called another women his wife. That to me was so moving and touching. Also it was so sad when they said goodbye the first time at the end of Secrets when he yelled out "I love you Alison Barrington! I will love you Forever!" -Alison

"Each time they were torn apart." -Raina

"The discussion after the non-wedding, and when Livvie shot Rafe." -Erin

"When Rafe went back to heaven the second time and when Rafe died a second time." -Ashlee

"When he left the first time and when they broke up. But most of all when she got tricked into having sex with Caleb." -Sheila

"When Rafe left, came back, died again, and came back...AGAIN." -Emily

"The most heartbreaking was the day Livvie shot Rafe in the back and he died in his Angel's arms, that one always get to me. Basically anything Livvie did to keep them apart was heartbreaking. Another one is when his 13 weeks were over and he had to leave, that really got to me. Last but not least is when Caleb let Alison believe that she and Rafe were brother and sister on their wedding day of all days that was heartbreaking not only for me but I think for every Rali fan out there."
-Allison Glaser

"Well the ending of course. When he left and went back to heaven the first time. She was at the party and he disappeared." -Christie

"Lately it's Caleb and Alison in the barn, but before then it was when Rafe was shot in the barn." -Molock

"When Alison asked Rafe to leave when Jamal broke up with her (when Valerie died), and when he didn't remember her. I grabbed the tissues everyday in those two arcs!" -Amber Riley

"When Livvie shot Rafe. The scenes while he was dying and Alison was holding him made the tears start flowing. It made a lump in my throat because I felt so bad for them because they just could never catch a break." -Amanda

"When Ali broke down and though Rafe was her brother, it was heartbreaking to see her even treat or think about Rafe like that. Rafe leaving back to Heaven, many numerous times. Alison being in the hospital when Rafe comes back from Heaven."
-Kim

"When Rafe went back to heaven the first time. Then when he came back & then Livvie killed him right in front of Alison and she fell down next to him and cried for him to live." -Rachael

"Every time that Rafe turned her down when he didn't remember who she was, when they didn't make it all the way down the aisle, and after Alison slept with Caleb and she had to deal with if she should tell Rafe or not. When Rafe was shot in the back and the end." -Ashley

"Rafe realized he was sent to earth to be with Alison and bought Alison pink roses but she rejected him and said she loved Jamal and also when Rafe didn't remember Alison." -Danielle

"I never cried with Rafe and Ali, but I never cry so that doesn't matter. This final wedding really upset me, but maybe that's because I knew it was the final episode." -Thomas

"Rafe leaving in Miracles Happen, Rafe leaving in Secrets, Rafe's death in Torn, the non-wedding in Surrender and every scene of theirs in that 1 hr episode, Alison staying with Joshua and telling Rafe to leave (even if it was all a plan), Rafe going to the barn by himself when Alison was with Joshua." -Amy

"When Rafe and Alison said goodbye at the end of Miracles Happen as well as Secrets." -Teresa

"The worst moments were every time Rafe had to go back to heaven." -Kaitlyn

"OMG! When Rafe married Livvie... ok that was more angry tears. Hehe. The 2nd time Rafe left Alison (at the end of Secrets). That was sooooo heartbreaking." -Nat

"Always when Rafe had to go back to heaven." -Lauren

"All of the goodbyes that they thought would be forever. The ones at the end of Miracles Happen, Secrets, and Torn. When Rafe disappeared after being yanked back up to heaven when Alison talked about wanting a baby." -Karen

"When Rafe told Alison that he needed to be with Livvie to take care of his baby and told Alison to leave him alone." -Carissa

"When Rafe had no memory and he told Alison that Livvie was pregnant with his child. And the one hour Surrender when the wedding was called off." -Precious

"When Rali said goodbye because Rafe had to go back up to heaven, when they were being separated by Livvie because of Rafe's amnesia, when Livvie shot Rafe (Rali reconciled, Rafe got his memory back) and he went back to Heaven, when Alison broke up with my Rafe so Vampie Joshua wouldn't hurt him." -Andrea

"When he went back at the end of Secrets...then the Thanksgiving scene in the chapel at the hospital last year." -Becki

"During Torn, the nonwedding, last day of the show, when Rafe was downstairs, when Ali was w/ Joshua." -Breanna

"Anything that Livvie did to keep Rafe and Alison apart was heartbreaking. Truly the one that brought me to tears is when Livvie shot Rafe in the back just as he got his memory back and died again this time in his Angel's arms." -Karen A.

"Everytime Rafe was called back up to heaven :( Those moments were the worst to have to sit through, even if you KNEW he was coming back, the angst, the longing, the goodbyes that you could only have faith wouldn't be goodbyes but rather see ya laters. Beautifully depicted by Erin and Brian. Nobody likes goodbyes." -Jenna

Back to the survey results
Back to Heaven on Earth