Vitamin E
Vitamin E was discovered in the 1920s when rats fed a vitamin E- deficient diet became unable to reproduce; but it was not officially considered essential for humans until 1966. It is the name given to a group of fat soluble compounds which are also called tocopherols and tocotrienols. The term "tocopherol" comes from the Greek words meaning "to bear offspring". The most abundant and active form of vitamin E is alpha tocopherol.
Function of vitamin E in the body
Antioxidant properties
Unlike the
other vitamins which take part in metabolic reactions or function as hormones,
the main role of vitamin E appears to be to act as an antioxidant. Vitamin
E is incorporated into the lipid portion of cell membranes and carrier
molecules and protects these structures from toxic compounds, heavy metals,
drugs, radiation and free radicals. Vitamin E also protects cholesterol
from oxidative damage. Because of its antioxidant effects, a diet high
in vitamin E appears to be protective against common health conditions
such as heart disease, cancer and strokes (See page 417 for more information.)
Immune system
Vitamin E
is essential for the maintenance of a healthy immune system as it protects
the thymus gland and circulating white blood cells from damage. Vitamin
E is particularly important in protecting the immune system from damage
during times of oxidative stress and chronic viral illness.
Eyes
Vitamin E
is vital for healthy eyes. It is essential for the development of the retina
and protects the eyes against free radical damage associated with cataract
formation and macular degeneration. It also protects vitamin A in the eyes
from damage.
Aging
As an antioxidant,
vitamin E may protect against the effects of aging by destroying free radicals
which cause degeneration in tissues such as the skin and blood vessels.
Studies in mice have shown that high doses of vitamin E may help prevent
aging-related damage to proteins involved in immune and central nervous
system function. Vitamin E may also protect against the mental effects
of aging, such as memory loss.
Absorption and metabolism
Vitamin E
requires the presence of fats and bile in the gut to be absorbed. Approximately
20 to 60 per cent of dietary vitamin E is absorbed and it is stored in
the liver, heart, fatty tissues, heart, muscles, testes, uterus, blood,
adrenal and pituitary glands. Absorption and transport are likely to be
reduced in elderly people.
Deficiency
The symptoms
of vitamin E deficiency in infants are irritability, fluid retention, hemolytic
anemia (the breaking down of red blood cells) and eye disorders. In adults,
vitamin E deficiency can lead to nerve damage and symptoms of lethargy,
apathy, inability to concentrate, staggering gait, low thyroid hormone
levels, decreased immune response, loss of balance and anemia.
Severe vitamin E deficiency is very rare. Those at risk include people with chronic liver disease and fat malabsorption syndromes, such as celiac disease and cystic fibrosis. Hemodialysis patients, those with inherited red blood cell disorders, premature and low birthweight infants, and elderly people may also be at risk of vitamin E deficiency and are often given supplements.
As vitamin E is stored in the body, it can take some time before deficiency symptoms become apparent in someone consuming a diet low in vitamin E. Marginal vitamin E deficiency may be relatively common and several studies have shown an increased risk of heart disease, cancer and other disorders in those with low vitamin E levels.
Cardiovascular disease
Low dietary
intake of vitamin E seems to increase the risk of heart disease. This is
illustrated by results from the Iowa Women's Health Study published in
1996 in the New England Journal of Medicine. Researchers studied
34 486 postmenopausal women with no cardiovascular disease who in early
1986 completed a questionnaire that assessed, among other factors, their
intake of vitamins A, E, and C from food sources and supplements. During
seven years of follow-up, 242 women died of coronary heart disease. The
results showed that high vitamin E consumption reduced the risk of death
from coronary heart disease. This association was particularly striking
in the subgroup of 21 809 women who did not consume vitamin supplements.
Similar results have been seen in men. Harvard School of Public Health researchers have assessed the links between diet and heart disease in 39 910 US male health professionals aged between 40 to 75 years of age. Participants responded to a questionnaire in 1986 and were then followed up for four years, during which time there were 667 cases of coronary disease. The results showed a lower risk of disease among men with higher intakes of vitamin E. Men consuming more than 40 mg (60 IU) per day had a 36 per cent lower risk than those consuming less than 5 mg (7.5 IU) per day. Men who took at least 67 mg (100 IU) per day for at least two years had a 37 per cent lower risk than those who did not take supplements.
The results of a 1996 study done in Japan suggest that low vitamin E levels increase the risk of a type of angina caused by coronary artery spasm. Animal studies suggest that brain damage after stroke may be greater in those who are vitamin E-deficient
Cancer
There is some
evidence that vitamin E can protect against cancer, although studies have
shown conflicting results. Some population studies suggest that low vitamin
E levels increase the risk of certain cancers, particularly those of the
gastrointestinal tract, cervix and lungs.
Cancers of the gastrointestinal
tract
Results from
the Iowa Women's Health Study suggest that high intakes of vitamin E reduce
the risk of colon cancer. Researchers analyzed the links between vitamin
E and colon cancer in 35 215 Iowa women aged 55 to 69 years without a history
of cancer. During the follow-up period, there were 212 cases of colon cancer.
The results showed that low vitamin E intake increased the risk of colon
cancer and those in the high intake group had 30 per cent of the risk of
those in the low intake group. The protective factor was stronger in the
younger women.
Other results from the Iowa Women's Health Study show that higher intakes of antioxidants, including vitamin E, are linked to lower risks of both oral, pharyngeal, esophageal and gastric cancers.
Breast cancer
Researchers
at the University of Southern California investigated the relationship
between blood levels of various nutrients, including vitamin E, and the
risks of breast cancer and proliferative benign breast disease (BBD) in
postmenopausal women in the Boston area. Women whose intake of vitamin
E from food sources only was high had around 60 per cent less risk of breast
cancer compared to those in the low intake group. However, not all studies
have shown protective effects.
Cervical cancer
Utah University
researchers investigating the relationship between cervical cancer and
dietary intake of antioxidant vitamins and selenium in 266 women with cervical
cancer and 408 women without the disorder found that women with high vitamin
E intakes had a 40 per cent lower risk of cervical cancer. Blood levels
of vitamin E have also been found to be low in women with cervical cancer.
Lung cancer
Several epidemiological
studies suggest that low vitamin E intakes increase the risk of lung cancer.
In 1974 and 1975, researchers at Johns Hopkins School of Hygiene and Public
Health, Baltimore, collected blood samples from 25 802 volunteers. They
assessed vitamin E levels in samples from 436 cancer cases and 765 matched
control subjects. The results showed that high vitamin E levels protected
against lung cancer.
Cataracts
Low vitamin
E levels may increase the risk of cataract formation. A 1996 Finnish study
of over 400 men found an increased risk of cataracts in those with low
vitamin E levels. The researchers evaluated the link between vitamin E
levels and progression of eye lens opacities in 410 men with high cholesterol.
The results showed that those with low vitamin E levels had almost four
times the risk of lens opacities when compared with those in the highest
intake group.
Parkinson's disease
The results
of several studies suggest that high levels of vitamin E can protect against
Parkinson's disease. In a 1997 study, researchers at Erasmus University
Medical School in Holland examined the relationship between dietary intake
of antioxidants and Parkinson's Disease and found a reduction in risk associated
with high vitamin E intake. The study involved over 5300 men and women
living independently and without dementia. It included 31 people with Parkinson's
Disease.
Sources
The best natural
sources of vitamin E are wheatgerm oil, hazelnut oil, sunflower oil, almond
oil, wheatgerm, whole grain cereals and eggs. Peaches, avocados, broccoli
and leafy greens are also good sources. Different foods have varying amounts
of the different forms of vitamin E. For example, soybean oil is composed
of about 10 per cent alpha tocopherol with the rest made up of other tocopherols.
The specific benefits of the different forms of vitamin E remain to be
discovered.
The results of a 1997 study suggest that the mixed forms of vitamin E found in food may be more beneficial than the alpha tocopherol form which is the main ingredient in supplements. Scientists at the University of California compared the abilities of alpha tocopherol and gamma tocopherol to protect against lipid peroxidation by compounds known as peroxynitrites which are formed in response to cigarette smoke, pollution and inflammation. Results showed that the gamma tocopherol form may be better at inhibiting these damaging reactions. About 75 per cent of the vitamin E found in food is the gamma tocopherol form while supplements may not contain any gamma tocopherol and it is possible that taking very high doses of alpha tocopherol may displace gamma tocopherol.
Cooking and processing reduces the vitamin E content of foods such as flours and oils. Cold-pressed oils therefore have a higher vitamin E content than refined vegetable oils. Exposure to light and oxygen also destroys vitamin E.
Recommended dietary allowances
The amount
of vitamin E required depends on the amount of polyunsaturated fats in
the diet. The greater the amount of these fats in the diet, the greater
the risk that they will be damaged by free radicals and exert harmful effects.
As vitamin E prevents this damage, recommended intake is roughly proportional
to the amount of polyunsaturated fats in the diet. The US RDA is based
on an intake of 0.4 mg per g of polyunsaturated fats. Vitamin E is measured
in International Units (IU) and more commonly nowadays, mg alpha TE. 1
IU equals 0.67 mg alpha TE.
USA
Men 10 mg alpha TE (15 IU)
Women 8 mg alpha TE (12 IU)
Pregnancy 10 mg alpha TE (15 IU)
Lactation 12 mg alpha TE (18 IU)
No RNI has been given in the UK. A 1991 Department of Health report concluded that a fixed amount is impossible to recommend as required vitamin E needs depend on the intake of polyunsaturated fats, which varies considerably from person to person.
Supplements
Vitamin E
supplements are available in natural and synthetic forms. Natural forms
of vitamin E are derived from soybean or wheatgerm oil and are indicated
by a 'd' prefix. These include d-alpha-tocopherol, d-alpha-tocopheryl acetate
and d-alpha-tocopheryl succinate. The synthetic forms are manufactured
from purified petroleum oil and are indicated by a 'dl' prefix. These include
dl-alpha-tocopherol, dl-alpha-tocopheryl acetate and dl-alpha-tocopheryl
succinate. Natural vitamin E supplements containing mixed tocopherols appear
to offer the most beneficial effects. Water soluble vitamin E supplements
are also available and, although more expensive, may not necessarily be
more beneficial. As they require fat for absorption, vitamin E supplements
should be taken with food.
In studies where benefits of vitamin E supplementation have been shown, the doses used have usually well exceeded the RDAs. In many studies, daily doses of up to 536 mg (800 IU) or even 804 mg (1200 IU) have been used. It is not possible to get such large amounts of vitamin E from food without consuming a high fat diet. Therefore many experts believe that supplements are necessary.
Toxic effects of excess
intake
Vitamin E
is considered safe even in large doses. Doses over 536 mg (800 IU) may
lead to an increased risk of bleeding, diarrhea, abdominal pain, fatigue,
reduced resistance to bacterial infection and transiently raised blood
pressure.
Some research suggests that vitamin E may actually be pro-oxidant at high doses; that is, may actually increase free radical damage. The results of a 1997 study done in Scotland showed that red cells of nonsmokers receiving 1050 mg of vitamin E had an increased susceptibility to peroxidation. Also, prolonged supplementation with vitamin E led to a decline in vitamin C concentrations in the blood.
Therapeutic uses of supplements
Vitamin E
supplements are used to treat deficiency and to prevent it in those at
risk. Supplements are also used in a wide range of disorders where there
is an increased need for immune support and protection against free radical
damage.
A study published in 1996 by researchers from the National Institute on Aging examined the effects of vitamin E and vitamin C supplement on mortality risk in 11 178 persons aged from 67 to 105 who were taking part in the Established Populations for Epidemiologic Studies of the Elderly Study. From 1984 through 1993 there were 3490 deaths. The results showed that those using the vitamin E supplements had a 34 per cent lower risk of death when compared to those not using vitamin E supplements, and around half the risk of death from coronary disease.
Cardiovascular disease
Several studies
have shown that high vitamin E intake can reduce the risk of developing
heart disease and improve the symptoms in those who do have the disease.
Results from the Nurses Health Study provide evidence for the protective
effects of vitamin E. Results published in 1993 assessed the links between
vitamin E and heart disease in 87 245 female nurses aged from 34 to 59
who were free of diagnosed cardiovascular disease and cancer in 1980. During
the follow-up period of eight years, there were 552 cases of major coronary
disease (437 nonfatal heart attacks and 115 deaths due to coronary disease).
The results showed that women with the highest vitamin E intakes had 34
per cent less risk of major coronary disease compared to those with the
lowest intakes. Most of the reduction in risk was attributable to vitamin
E consumed as supplements, a finding which conflicts with some other studies
which only show benefit from high dietary intakes. Women who took vitamin
E supplements for short periods had little apparent benefit, but those
who took them for more than two years had an even lower risk of disease.
Results from a British study known as the Cambridge Heart Antioxidant Study (CHAOS) which were published in The Lancet in 1996 provide further evidence of a link between vitamin E supplements and reduction in heart disease risk. In this double-blind, placebo-controlled study, 2002 patients with coronary atherosclerosis were enrolled and followed up for 510 days. 546 patients were given 536 mg (800 IU) daily; 589 were given 268 mg (400 IU) per day and 967 received identical placebo capsules. The results showed that those who received vitamin E supplements had a 75 per cent reduction in the risk of fatal heart attacks. However, when nonfatal events were included there did not appear to be any benefit from the vitamin E supplements.
As part of the Finnish Alpha-Tocopherol, Beta carotene Cancer (ATBC) Prevention Study, researchers studied the preventive effect of vitamin E and beta carotene supplements on major coronary events. A total of 27 271 Finnish male smokers aged 50 to 69 years with no history of heart attack were randomly assigned to receive 50 mg (75 IU) and a 20 mg dose of beta carotene, both supplements, or placebo daily for five to eight years. During this period there were 1204 nonfatal heart attacks and 907 fatal ones. The results showed that major coronary events decreased 4 per cent among those taking vitamin E. Supplementation with vitamin E also decreased the incidence of fatal coronary heart disease by 8 per cent although did not appear to affect the incidence of nonfatal heart attacks. The dose of vitamin E used in this study is smaller than that commonly used.
Vitamin E may help prevent heart disease in a number of ways. It lowers total blood cholesterol levels, and as it is easily incorporated into the harmful LDL cholesterol molecule, it can protect it from oxidation by free radicals. Oxidized LDL cholesterol is more likely to block arteries and contribute to the atherosclerotic process than unoxidised LDL cholesterol. Vitamin E may be able to prevent the free radical damage that occurs when blood is cut off then re-supplied, for example during surgery or in the case of a blood vessel spasm. Vitamin E also has important direct effects on vascular endothelial and smooth muscle cells and also inhibits the clumping together of platelets which helps to reduce atherosclerotic plaque formation. It also seems to inhibit the attachment of white blood cells to artery linings which is caused by LDL cholesterol.
A study published in 1996 suggests that the minimum dose of supplementary vitamin E which will significantly reduce the susceptibility of LDL to oxidation is 335 mg (500 IU) per day.
Angina
Vitamin E
appears to play a part in decreasing the risk of angina. Results of the
Finnish ATBC Prevention Study found a slightly reduced risk in those taking
vitamin E supplements.
Cancer
Vitamin E
supplements, especially when combined with selenium, have shown beneficial
effects in the prevention of certain types of cancer, including breast
cancer. Results from the US National Institute on Aging study mentioned
above showed a 22 per cent decrease in the risk of death from cancer in
those taking vitamin E supplements.
Vitamin E may protect against cell membrane and chromosome damage that would otherwise lead to cancerous changes in cells. Vitamin E also inhibits the growth of abnormal cells and plays a role in their conversion back to normal cells. Vitamin E can also prevent the formation of certain carcinogens by combining with substances in the intestine. For example, the formation of cancer-causing nitrosamines from dietary nitrites in the stomach may be inhibited by vitamin E.
Prostate cancer
According
to more results from the ATBC study published in 1998 in the Journal
of the National Cancer Institute, vitamin E reduces the risk of prostate
cancer among smokers. Researchers studied the effects of 50 mg (75 IU)
in Finnish men and the results showed a 32 per cent decrease in the incidence
of prostate cancer and a 41 per cent decrease in prostate cancer deaths
among the men taking vitamin E, compared with those who took no vitamin
E.
Immunity
High doses
of vitamin E boost the immune system in elderly people. In a 1997 study
of 88 healthy people, aged 65 or older, those who took 200 mg (300 IU)
each day for about four months showed an improvement in immune response.
Researchers assessed the effects of either 60 mg (90 IU), 200 mg (300 IU)
or 800 mg (1333) on a measure of immune system strength known as delayed
hypersensitivity skin response. The results showed that those who took
200 mg a day had a 65 per cent increase in immune function. Those taking
60 mg or 800 mg of vitamin E also showed some improvements in immune function
but the ideal response was seen in those taking 200 mg. In other tests,
those who took the supplements produced six times more antibodies to hepatitis
B after being given the vaccine than those who took placebo. They also
produced more antibodies against tetanus infection. The study, which was
reported in the Journal of the American Medical Association provides
more support for vitamin E supplementation in older people.
HIV/AIDS
Vitamin E
may also help to slow disease progression in HIV-positive people. The results
of a nine year study involving 311 HIV-positive men showed that those patients
with the highest vitamin E intakes had a 35 per cent decrease in risk of
progression to AIDS when compared to those in the lowest intake group.
Diabetes
Vitamin E
may improve insulin action in some diabetics. Those with the disorder are
particularly susceptible to oxidative damage and vitamin E may play a role
in preventing the long-term complications of diabetes. Studies show that
vitamin E can protect diabetics against LDL cholesterol oxidation and other
adverse effects of the disease.
In a study published in 1996, Louisiana researchers examined whether 67 mg (100 IU) per day had any effect on blood lipid oxidation products and blood lipid profiles of 35 diabetic patients over a three month period. The results showed that vitamin E supplementation significantly lowered lipid peroxidation products and lipid levels in diabetic patients.
Type I diabetes
The results
of a 1997 study done in Italy show that vitamin E can protect against damage
to beta cells which produce insulin in Type I diabetes patients. The one
year study involved 84 patients between 5 and 35 years of age. One group
was treated with vitamin E supplements and the other group received nicotinic
acid which has been shown to protect pancreatic beta cell function (See
page 80 for more information.) All patients were under intensive insulin
therapy with three to four injections a day. The results showed that vitamin
E was as effective as nicotinic acid in protecting the beta cells.
Cataract
Vitamin E
supplements may help to prevent cataract progression, according to a 1998
study published in the journal Ophthalmology. Researchers found
that among a group of around 750 elderly people, those who took vitamin
E supplements had half the risk that their cataracts would progress over
a four-and-a-half-year period. Taking a multivitamin pill lowered the risk
by one-third.
Fertility
Animal studies
suggest that moderate doses of vitamin E may enhance the ability of sperm
to fertilize eggs. Recent studies suggest that vitamin E supplements may
be useful in treating male infertility by improving sperm function.
Arthritis
Vitamin E
has anti-inflammatory and analgesic activity which may be useful in rheumatoid
arthritis patients. In a study published in 1997, UK researchers treated
42 patients with 600 mg (895 IU) twice a day or with placebo for 12 weeks.
The patients were already receiving anti-rheumatic drug treatment. Laboratory
and clinical measures of inflammation were not influenced by the treatment.
However, the pain measures; including pain in the morning, pain in the
evening, and pain after chosen activity; were significantly decreased after
vitamin E treatment when compared with placebo.
Asthma
Antioxidants
may help asthmatics. According to researchers at the University of Washington,
antioxidant vitamin supplements may help relieve the symptoms of asthma.
The researchers measured the amount of breath expelled by the lungs in
17 asthma sufferers. The subjects took peak flow lung function tests while
running on a treadmill and breathing in high levels of polluted air. In
those asthmatics whose diets were supplemented with daily doses of 268
mg (400 IU) and 500 mg of vitamin C, an 18 per cent increase in peak flow
capacity was seen.
Alzheimer's disease
Vitamin E
may slow the progression of Alzheimer's disease. Researchers at Columbia
University have found that treatment with vitamin E slows the progression
of Alzheimer's disease symptoms. In a study reported in 1997 in the New
England Journal of Medicine, patients were treated with 1340 mg (2000
IU) daily, 10 mg of selegiline daily, a combination of the two, or a placebo
for two years. The patients were monitored every three months by the researchers
who looked for signs such as the loss of ability to perform basic activities,
institutionalization or severe dementia. Researchers found that all the
treatment groups had delayed rate of loss of function when compared with
the placebo group.
Liver disorders
Vitamin E
levels have been found to be low in patients with liver damage and supplements
have been shown to protect against liver damage induced by oxidative stress
in animal experiments. In a 1997 German study, researchers treated 23 hepatitis
C patients with two 268 mg (400 IU) doses per day for 12 weeks. In 11 of
23 patients, the measurements in clinical tests to assess liver damage
showed improvement during vitamin E treatment.
Hot flashes
In a study
published in 1998, researchers at the Mayo Clinic in Minnesota looked at
the effect of vitamin E on hot flashes in 104 women who had survived breast
cancer. The women were experiencing at least two hot flashes per day. The
study took nine weeks. In weeks two to five, the women took either vitamin
E or a placebo and in weeks six to nine, they took the alternative pill.
The results showed that in general, women taking vitamin E experienced
approximately one less hot flash per day than women taking the placebo.
Skin protection
Vitamins E
may help to protect against sunburn. In a study reported in 1998, dermatologists
at Ludwig Maximilians University in Germany found that people who take
the antioxidant vitamins C and E have a higher threshold for sunburn reaction.
The researchers tested ultraviolet sensitivity in two groups of ten Caucasian
people by exposing a section of skin to UV light. Subjects in one of the
groups then took 2 g of vitamin C and 670 mg (1000 IU) for 8 days. The
UV test was then re-done. Those taking the vitamins showed increased tolerance,
particularly at higher UV doses. The researchers speculate that combined
intake of both vitamins is necessary for protection. However, the researchers
stress that in comparison with the protection afforded by topical sunscreens,
this level of protection is small.
Exercise
A growing
amount of evidence indicates that free radicals play an important role
in causing skeletal muscle damage and inflammation after strenuous exercise.
The generation of oxygen-free radicals may be increased during exercise
as a result of increases in oxygen metabolism in the energy producing organelles
of the cell - the mitochondria. These changes may lead to damage to cholesterol
and DNA. Increased antioxidant activity can help to prevent this damage
and some research suggests that antioxidant vitamin supplementation can
be protective in people who regularly exercise heavily.
In a study published in 1998, Pennsylvania State University researchers investigated the effects of high intensity resistance exercise on free radical production and also whether vitamin E supplementation could affect free radical formation or muscle membrane disruption. They divided 12 weight-trained males into two groups. The supplement group received 804 mg (1200 IU) once a day for a period of two weeks and the other group received a placebo. The results showed that high intensity resistance exercise increased free radical production and that vitamin E supplementation decreased muscle membrane disruption.
Interactions with other
nutrients
Vitamin E
exerts antioxidant effects in combination with other antioxidants including
beta carotene, vitamin C and selenium. Vitamin C can restore oxidized vitamin
E to its natural antioxidant form. Megadoses of vitamin C may increase
vitamin E requirements. Vitamin E can also protect against some of the
effects of excessive vitamin A and regulates levels of that vitamin. Vitamin
E is necessary for the action of vitamin A and high intake of vitamin A
may decrease vitamin E absorption
Vitamin E may be necessary for the conversion of vitamin B12 to its active form and may reduce some of the symptoms of zinc deficiency. Large doses of vitamin E may interfere with the anticoagulant action of vitamin K and may reduce intestinal absorption of vitamin K. Inorganic iron destroys vitamin E, so the two supplements should not be taken together.
Interactions with drugs
Cholestyramine,
mineral oil and alcohol may reduce the absorption of vitamin E from the
intestine. Vitamin E can enhance the action of anticoagulant drugs on blood
clotting and should not be taken in large doses. However, the results of
a 1996 study in which 21 people taking chronic warfarin therapy received
either vitamin E or placebo suggest that vitamin E can safely be given
to patients who require chronic warfarin therapy.
Anticonvulsants such as phenobarbital, phenytoin and carbamazepine may lower plasma vitamin E levels by altering absorption, distribution and metabolism. Isoniazid also decreases vitamin E absorption. Neomycin impairs utilization of vitamin E.
Cautions
Vitamin E
should be used cautiously by anyone with an overactive thyroid or rheumatic
heart disease. Vitamin E in large doses may aggravate iron deficiency anemia.
Vitamin E supplements can cause a transient rise in blood pressure and
should be used with caution by anyone suffering from hypertension.