Rose of Versailles for Smart People

The Title
Prositution
Oscar and André
Why Oscar is so Great




The Title


Why is it called "Berusaiyu no Bara"? Well, there are many hypothesises. Below is a list of possible right and wrong answers. Some of them I read them some where else but forgot where so I can't credit the person now with the brillant ideas. Other more original and bizzare ones, I am proud to say, I came up with them on my own in this little distorted mind of mine!

1) It is the fate of a rose to wither and die.

This can be seen true in Oscar's fate as she suffers from Tuborculosis and coughing up blood as she reaches what should have been the peak of her beauty and career. The problem with this interpertation is that Marie Antoinette and Fersen do not actually "wither" and thus lack parallelism.


2) The rose is a metaphor for the life style at Versailles. It seems beautiful but is something we must not try to pick with our unprotected hands.

Marie Antoinette has to learn this lesson the hard way. She has to deal with gossips about her inability to produce heirs as well as enter petty silent wars with the king's mistress. In addition, the author wants us to feel vycariously her loneliness and misery while she longs for someone to emphatize with her. When she finally finds someone she loves, she realizes that she can never be with him because she is married. However, from the outside, it appears as though she is completely happy because of all the luxuries around her and her ability to whip her husband.

To Oscar, this was the harsh reality of her life. Although she gets promoted endlessly and is always in the queen's grace, she has many reasons to be miserable. To an onlooker, it seems that she escapes the fate of normal women at that time, which is to get married and get into affairs. She is not bound to a house or children. However, because nobody trusts women, she has to work extra hard to act strong and controlled. The decision that mark the major courses of her life is never for herself. Her service to the royal family is to mainly please her father; her revolt against the royal family is mainly for the commoners.


3) It is simply a metaphor for the main character.

We have names like "King of Fighters" and "Goddess of the Sun" and "The Golden Arch" standing for the real names of the signified. So "Rose of Versailles" could just be a name for somebody in the series. However, there is no pural in Japanese. So, the title could also be "Roses of Versailles". In other words, it could refer to only Oscar or it could refer to Oscar, Marie Antoinette and Fersen as the Roses of Versailles. The problem with the latter is that Fersen is not linked directly to Versailles.



Back to Top of Page

Prostitution

Now, I am quite sure that everybody recall the famous scenes where Antoinette got into a no-speak-fight with Mme. DuBarrie. Antoinette's position is that Mme. DuBarrie sold her body to climb the ladder of society and corrupts the French Court. DuBarrie was just insulted that a mere child would not speak with her. Well, you have to admit, those scenes, more like volumes, were pretty silly. But since I am silly too, we will look into this matter deeper. Ooohhh!

Ok, maybe sleeping your way up the royal ladder is not the most noble thing to do but one has to consider that DuBarrie probably came from a pretty poor family. Pre-revolution commoners were basically going through hell everyday. Now, she has the choice of living through hell or sleeping her way up there and getting, not only herself but her children also, out of hell. Just because she was not born with wealth does not mean that she can't strive for it.

Antoinette's treatment towards DuBarrie is not only unfair, but hypocritical. Antoinette herself is a prositude; her marriage ensures the safety of Germany and all the French riches she can get. She did not marry Louis XIV because she loves him; so, she sleeps with him like a prositude does except, in her case, it is legalized and honoured.

Also, in Berusaiyu no Bara, we never see Dubarrie commit adultery, but we do see Marie Antoinette doing that. The only reason the audience is supposed to hate Dubarrie is because she has an evil look on her face an Marie Antoinette hates her.


Back to Top of Page



Oscar and André

This has got to be the most heart wrenching love story in the world. However, I was wondering, who does Oscar love more? I thought it was Fersen. She was willing to change for him but not for André. However, I like to believe that she was moved by André's consistant loyalty for her and thus changed her mind and love him more. There is one question for us to ponder. Another one is did she get shot on purpose because she wants to join André?
Back to Top of Page



Why Oscar is so Great

Unlike most contemprary female characters, misfortune does not occur to her because she did something stupid. She is always calm and rational in order to do what she has to. From the beginning, she is not given much choice of her own life, but she never whines about her fate. When problems do arise, she does not cry or whine or wait for her boyfriend to come get her out of it. Instead, she solves her problems as well as others' as they are her duties. She also handles situations so that she does not burden other people. If that ain't great, tell me what is.

Back to Top of Page
Back to Titles.
Back Home.




This page is written by Athena.
Mail Athena


last updated: June 28th, 1998
1