Hokkian and Chinese Language Family
There are some arguments whether there is one Chinese language that consists of many dialects or there is Chinese language family that consists of many languages within the family. The first argument refers Mandarin, Cantonese, Wu, Hakka, Minnan, etc as dialects of one language i.e. Han Chinese language. The second argument refers Mandarin, Cantonese, Wu, Hakka, Minnan, etc as languages of one family i.e. Han Chinese language family.
Personally I tend toward the second argument since those languages have their own characteristics and are usually unintelligible to each other, unless in written form. Yet it's very obvious that they are closely related to each other since they share the same writing system and have great similarity in grammar, also their pronunciation on words usually reflect their closeness. They share similarity in written vocabulary, yet slightly differ in diction.
Hokkian is the name used by its native speakers to identify their language. They also refer themselves as Hokkian people. Hokkian language is also referred as Hokkien, Minnan, Amoy, Fujianese, Fukkien, Taiwanese, Taigi, Taigu, Hoklo, etc. In general sense, Hokkian and Minnan are interchangable terms. Linguistically Hokkian is considered as part of Minnan language. Minnan is considered as a language group that consists of many dialects that some are easily intelligible to each other and some are harder. In its broadest sense, Minnan includes Teochew/Tiociu dialects and Hainan dialects beside Hokkian dialects.
Hokkian / Minnan is a member of Chinese language family. In fact, Chinese language isn't only Mandarin or Putonghua. It's a family of languages (or dialects) which used by Chinese people. In this unique family, there are language groups of:
Mandarin Pronunciation |
漢字 |
Hokkian Pronunciation |
English Transliteration |
||||
Language Name | Origin Place | 語言名稱 | 原鄉 | Language Name | Origin Place | Language Name | Origin Place |
Pu3 Tong1 Hua4 |
Bei3 Ping2 ; Bei3 Jing1 |
普通話 |
北平 ; 北京 |
P'o= T'oq- Ue-. |
Pak^ Piqv. ; Pak^ Kia*/. |
Mandarin ; Putonghua |
Beijing ; Peking |
Wu2 |
Shang4 Hai3 | 吳 | 上海 |
QoV. ; NgoV. |
Sioq~ Hai\. |
Wu |
Shanghai |
Gan4 |
Jiang1 Xi1 | 贛 | 江西 |
Kan-. |
Kaq- Se/. |
Gan |
Jiangxi |
Xiang1 |
Hu2 Nan2 | 湘 | 湖南 |
Sioq/. |
O~ LamV. |
Xiang |
Hunan |
Min3 Bei3 | Fu2 Jian4 Bei3 Bu4 ; Fu2 Zhou1 | 閩北 | 福建北部 ; 福州 | Ban~ Pak\. | Hok^Kian~. Pak^ Po-.; Hok^ Ciu/. | Minbei | Northern Fujian ; Fuzhou |
Min3 Nan2 | Fu2 Jian4 Nan2 Bu4 ; Xia4 Men2 | 閩南 | 福建南部 ; 廈門 |
Hok^ Kian~.; Ban~ LamV. |
Hok^ Kian~. Lam~ Po-. ; E~ MqV. |
Hokkian; Hokkien; Minnan; Amoy; Taiwanese | Southern Fujian; Amoy; Xiamen |
Ke4 Jia1 | Guang3 Dong1 Mei2 Xian4 | 客家 | 廣東梅縣 | K'e\. | Kq= Taq/. Mui*~ Kuai*-. | Hakka | Mei County - Guangdong |
Yue4 |
Guang3 Dong1 ; Guang3 Zhou1 | 粵 | 廣東 ; 廣州 |
Uat^. |
Kq= Taq/. ; Kq= Ciu/. |
Yue / Cantonese |
Guangdong / Canton |
etc. (note: the list above is sorted by area, from Northern China to Southern China) |
Minnan language consists of many dialects. Those dialects are usually named after their speakers' hometown. Here are some of them:
Hokkian Pronunciation |
漢字 |
Mandarin Pronunciation |
English Transliteration |
||||
Dialect Name | Affiliation of | 方言名稱 | 屬於 | Dialect Name | Affiliation of | Dialect Name | Affiliation of |
Cuan~ Ciu/. |
Hok^ Kian~. | 泉州 | 福建閩南 |
Quan2 Zhou1 |
Fu2 Jian4 Min3 Nan2 |
Cuanciu / Quanzhou |
Hokkian |
Taq~ Ua*/. |
Hok^ Kian~. | 同安 | 福建閩南 |
Tong2 An1 |
Fu2 Jian4 Min3 Nan2 |
Tang-ua / Tong-an |
Hokkian |
E~ Mqv. |
Hok^ Kian~. | 廈門 | 福建閩南 |
Xia4 Men2 |
Fu2 Jian4 Min3 Nan2 |
Amoy / Emng / Xiamen |
Hokkian |
Kim- Mqv. |
Hok^ Kian~. | 金門 | 福建閩南 |
Jin1 Men2 |
Fu2 Jian4 Min3 Nan2 |
Quemoy / Kinmen / Kimmng / Jinmen |
Hokkian |
Ciaq- Ciu/. | Hok^ Kian~. | 漳州 | 福建閩南 | Zhang1 Zhou1 | Fu2 Jian4 Min3 Nan2 | Ciangciu / Zhangzhou | Hokkian |
Tio~ Ciu/. | Tio~ Ciu/. | 潮州 | 潮州 | Chao2 Zhou1 | Chao2 Zhou1 | Teochew / Tiociu | Teochew |
Sua*- T'auv. |
Tio~ Ciu/. | 汕頭 | 潮州 |
Shan1 Tou2 |
Chao2 Zhou1 | Swatou | Teochew |
Hai= Lamv. | Hai= Lamv. | 海南 | 海南 | Hai3 Nan2 | Hai3 Nan2 | Hainan | Hainan |
and many more...
(note: the list above is sorted by area from North to South) |