La Traviata
Home Up Aida La Traviata

 

La Traviata - SFO - June 6th, 2001

ViolettaPatricia Racette
Alfredo GermontStephen Mark Brown
Giorgio GermontChristopher Robertson
Conducted ByMarco Armiliato

La Traviata
The production by John Copley was very interesting. All the acts had standard sets and the costumes (designed by David Walker) were ravishing. The singers were very well directed and the production had some nice touches: when Violetta asks Annina to take a letter to Flora accepting the invitation to the party, Annina leaves in a haste and when Violetta turns to call her back she is already gone, Violetta sings "Sempre libera" from the balcony where it is more believable to hear Alfredo's voice and so on.

Patricia Racette sang well specially in Act IV where she was excellent, displaying true legato and ravishing pianissimos. Her acting was also good and she looks the part. But Act I was her Achilles' heel, the tessitura is too high for her and her "Sempre libera" was weak. She is not a coloratura also but rather a lyric soprano.

Stephen Mark Brown was a good Alfredo, as I said before (see my Luisa Miller review) his voice is beautiful in the middle and distinctive, but he has a problem with passagio and his high notes sound strained. But Alfredo is not difficult and he sang well and even sang the cabaletta in Act 2 with high note and all.

Christopher Robertson was a good Germont, the voice projected well and he showed felling and attentiveness to both the scene and the words, but his voice is not very powerful nor a true Verdian voice lacking more resonance in the lower notes.

The other parts were well sung, with a special mention to Catherine Keen's Flora.

Alas, Marco Armiliato conducted a routine performance, the orchestra sounded thin and it lacked sparkle something essential in La Traviata. Some speeds were very slow. He did follow the singers well though.

 
1