Archaeologists and Development logo

Archaeologists campaigning for the environment

World archaeology under threat - sorted by date

Threat

Country

Date

Description

Tourism

Italy

15 Feb 2000

Valle dei Nuraghi, Italia-Sardegna

This is an ethnographic and archeological museum.The archaeological section, dedicated to the Logudoro and Meilogu regions(Sardinia),focuses mostly on the prestigious nuragic complex of Santu Antine in Torralba.

http://www.geocities.com/Baja/Canyon/1952

Disputed ownership

Greece

01 Dec 1999

British Museum admits 'scandal' of Elgin marbles

The British Museum has admitted that the controversial Elgin Marbles were damaged by "heavy handed" cleaning 60 years ago. And it has said an attempt to cover up the damage to the marbles in the 1930s was "a scandal".

BBC News Online (UK): (follow this link for numerous related stories)

http://news.bbc.co.uk/hi/english/uk/newsid_543000/543077.stm

Campaign for return of Parthenon marbles:

http://www.uk.digiserve.com/mentor/marbles/

Disputed ownership

France

18 Nov 1999

British MP demands return of Glyndwr letter

A member of the British parliament is calling for the return to Wales of artefacts belonging to Welsh hero Owain Glyndwr from the French National Library in Paris.

BBC News Online (UK):

http://news.bbc.co.uk/hi/english/uk/wales/newsid_526000/526247.stm

Disputed ownership

Greece

06 Nov 1999

Greece and UK row over who has cleanest marbles

"The Greek cultural attaché to Britain has accused a British art expert of arrogance and "spouting pseudo-scientific froth" for claiming that the Elgin marbles in the British Museum are in a better condition than the remaining marbles in Athens."

The Independent (UK), 6 November 1999:

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/UK/This_Britain/marblesrow061199.shtml

Development

Germany

16 Oct 1999

Berlin builders unearth Hitler's suicide bunker

Builders working on a new street in Berlin have uncovered what may be the remains of the bunker where Hitler committed suicide on April 30, 1945. Opinions are divided over whether to preserve the site. Former city archaeologist Alfred Kernd'l favours preservation, but Andreas Nachama, head of Berlin's Jewish Community, said he doesn't believe preserving every remnant from the Nazi era would serve any purpose.

The Guardian (UK): 16th October 1999.

http://www.newsunlimited.co.uk/AC/setguestcookie.cgi?section=News&host=www%2Enewsunlimited%2Eco%2Euk&uri=%2Finternational%2Fstory%2F0%2C3604%2C92556%2C00%2Ehtml&userid=4G9Dbb01

Pollution

India

03 Oct 1999

Smog threatens to destroy Taj Mahal

"THE Indian government has been forced to take emergency measures to save the Taj Mahal, the world's most famous and enduring monument to love, which is in danger of collapse from pollution."

Sunday Telegraph, 3 Oct 1999:

http://www.telegraph.co.uk:80/et?ac=001696131314601&rtmo=qsRs9uX9&atmo=FFFFFFtX&pg=/et/99/10/3/wtaj03.html

Tourism

 

28 Sep 1999

War and growth of tourism are biggest threats to historic sites

WAR, the pressures of tourism and Russian corruption are the most serious problems facing the world's greatest buildings and historic sites, according to a report published today.

The World Monuments Fund's list of the 100 most endangered sites ranges from prehistoric rock carvings in Niger to a visionary arts school in Cuba built in the Sixties. Although the report was completed too early to include buildings damaged in the latest conflict in Kosovo and Serbia, the scale of devastation caused by earlier wars in Croatia, Bosnia and elsewhere in the world is clear.

UK Daily Telegraph, Electronic Telegraph, 28 Sep 1999:

http://www.telegraph.co.uk:80/et?ac=001696131314601&rtmo=VwkwgM6K&atmo=rrrrrrbq&pg=/et/99/9/28/wmon28.html

War

 

28 Sep 1999

War and growth of tourism are biggest threats to historic sites

WAR, the pressures of tourism and Russian corruption are the most serious problems facing the world's greatest buildings and historic sites, according to a report published today.

The World Monuments Fund's list of the 100 most endangered sites ranges from prehistoric rock carvings in Niger to a visionary arts school in Cuba built in the Sixties. Although the report was completed too early to include buildings damaged in the latest conflict in Kosovo and Serbia, the scale of devastation caused by earlier wars in Croatia, Bosnia and elsewhere in the world is clear.

UK Daily Telegraph, Electronic Telegraph, 28 Sep 1999:

http://www.telegraph.co.uk:80/et?ac=001696131314601&rtmo=VwkwgM6K&atmo=rrrrrrbq&pg=/et/99/9/28/wmon28.html

 

USA New York

01 Sep 1999

City Hall dig – skeletons and secrecy?

A dig at City Hall Park, Lower Manhattan, has turned up human remains that may relate to a politically contentious African Burial Ground. Field archaeologists, contractually bound to secrecy over the project, have been threatened with a $1000 fine if they reveal details of the site.

Archaeology Magazine, Sept/Oct 1999:

http://www.archaeology.org/curiss/newsbriefs/cityhall.html

 

Development

USA Wisconsin

28 Aug 1999

Preservation of Wisconsin's archaeological sites

"It is estimated that nearly 80% of the archaeological sites that once existed in the state have been destroyed or severely damaged, primarily by modern land practices such as development and farming. Many sites have also been damaged by looting." But the State Historical Society of Wisconsin is fighting hard to preserve what remains.

The State Historical Society of Wisconsin:

http://www.shsw.wisc.edu/arch/preserve/index.html

Tourism

Peru

28 Aug 1999

Machu Picchu wrecked by tourists… or poverty?

The remarkable Peruvian site of Machu Picchu (a World Heritage Site) is threatened by cable cars and a massive hotel complex. But tourist dollars are needed to relieve grinding poverty and foreign debts.

About.com's (typically perceptive) analysis:

http://archaeology.about.com/library/weekly/mcurrent.htm?pid=2826&cob=home

Machu Picchu in Danger: http://www.mpicchu.org/

Save Machu Picchu another way: stay home and take the virtual trail. "In Search of Cultures Past: Cuzco, the Sacred Valley, and the Inka Trail":

http://www.archaeology.org/online/features/peru/index.html

War

Yugoslavia

10 Aug 1999

NATO bombing threatens Yugoslavian heritage

The Institute for the Protection of Cultural Monuments of Serbia has compiled a long list of monuments which they say have been endangered, damaged or destroyed by NATO's £4.5 billion, 78-day bombing campaign. They argue that the war was contrary to the UN Convention on the Protection of Cultural Property, which states: "damage to cultural property belonging to any people whatsoever means damage to the cultural heritage of all mankind, since each people makes its contribution to the culture of the world". The Institute asks: "Does our past have a future?"

Yugoslav heritage: http://www.yuheritage.com

UN convention: http://www.unesco.org/general/eng/legal/cltheritage/hague/index.html

Development

USA Florida

01 May 1999

Time running out for Miami stone circle?

The Brickell stone circle site in Miami, Florida, is threatened by a $126 million development project.

Miamicircle.org: http://www.miamicircle.org/

Site web cam: http://www.enterprisemission.com/miamicam.html

Sign the online petition: http://www.peaceday.org/miamicircle.shtml

Archaeology

USA

26 Feb 1999

Native Americans and archaeologists

"The relationship between archaeologists and Native Americans…has not always been smooth, and until recently it has been characterized by a lack of effective communication. Here we present articles from past issues of ARCHAEOLOGY, news items, and links to sites concerned with the ongoing dialogue between Native Americans and archaeologists"

Archaeology magazine Feb 1999:

http://www.archaeology.org/online/features/native/index.html

Mines and quarries

South Africa

10 Jan 1999

Digging for diamonds or heritage in South Africa?

What happened when archaeologists took on miners at Barkly West in the Northern Cape Province, near the National Monument of Canteen Koppie, in 1997.

Heritage conservation, small-scale mining and the role of public archaeology by David Morris, World Archaeology Congress newsletter, South African Focus: http://www.le.ac.uk/archaeology/adm3/wac/wac73.htm - Heritage conservation

Dam

China

01 Jan 1999

Three Gorges Dam threatens 1.3 m people and archaeology

The notorious Yangtze (Three Gorges) dam in China threatens archaeology and ecology. More than 1.3 million people will be forced from their homes by the 410 mile long, £17 billion hydroelectric reservoir/dam project, and driven into arid desert in Xinjiang province or the equally arid steppes of Inner Mongolia. More than 10,000 people in Yuyang county have signed a petition, and organized protests are expected to follow as construction work proceeds. One petition reads: "Once conflict breaks out it will be too late for the central government to send down officials to handle the matter."

News report: http://www.archaeology.org/9611/abstracts/3gorges.html

International Rivers Network: http://www.irn.org/programs/threeg/index.html

Mines and quarries

Canada

01 Jan 1999

Quarry Threatens Delicate Cave In Southwestern British Columbia

Caves in southwestern mainland British Columbia are rare, and examples with speleothems of the quality of those found in Iron Curtain Cave are exceptional in Canada. They are now threatened by quarrying.

http://www.cancaver.ca/conserv/quarry/

Disputed ownership

Mexico

01 Jan 1999

Help Emperor Moctezuma's crown return to Mexico

Did you know that Moctezuma's quetzal feather crown is being held at the Volkskendemuseum in Vienna, Austria? This incredible work of sacred art, known to the Aztecs as the Kopilliketzalli, or "The Precious Crown," has

been in Austria since 1524, when it was given to them by the government of Spain after being plundered in the conquest and holocaust of Mexico. The Austrians have been asked to return the crown many times. They claim that it is not Moctezuma's, but that of an important chief other than Moctezuma. They also say that since it was a gift, it needn't be returned.

Letter-writing campaign: http://dayofdestiny.com/MoctezumasCrown.html

 

USA

01 Jan 1998

Who's to blame for the destruction of ancient sites?

The American Institute of Archaeology offers some suggestions.

http://fragments.gosite.com/blame.htm

Battlefields

USA Virginia

01 Jan 1998

Civil war battlefields under pressure in Virginia

It's not just the UK that's turning its civil war battlefields into housing estates and roads.

http://www.cvbt.org/threatened.shtml

 

Dam

Turkey

01 Jan 1998

British Government funds destructive Ilisu dam

The British government is underwriting a one billion pound dam at Ilisu in Turkey, which will wipe out many Kurdish towns and villages and destroy a site of international archaeological interest. It will flood the town of Anatolia, which dates from the Middles Ages, and was given archaeological protection in 1978.

The Guardian 1 Marrch 1999, page 1. http://www.guardian.co.uk

European Rivers Network: http://www.rivernet.org/

Logging

Canada

01 Jan 1998

Rainforest logging threatens First Nations' cultural heritage

Over half the world's temperate rainforest has been destroyed; a quarter of what is left is here in British Columbia. BC now has the largest remaining expanse of coastal temperate rainforest left in the world, but clearcutting continues in the spectacular Great Bear Rainforest to make earth-shatteringly vital items, such as newspapers, toilet paper, and diapers (which cannot, of course, be made from recycled materials). Fortunately, the Forest Action Network continues its spectacular fight.

The impacts of clearcutting are not just ecological and economic. According to Greenpeace: "Archaeological studies and oral traditions show that coastal First Nations have lived in the Pacific rainforest region for at least 9,000 years, creating rich and diverse societies and using the bounty of both the rainforest and the connecting waters for sustenance. European contact, however, has resulted in the erosion of both First Nations' culture and land.

According to Ecotrust International, 44 of 68 language groups believed to have been spoken on North America's west coast at the time of contact are today extinct or spoken by fewer than ten individuals. The pattern of this cultural erosion mirrors the south to north pattern of the Europeans' movements, and reflects where old-growth rainforests have been cleared all along the Pacific coast.

Today, clearcutting continues on First Nations lands often without the consent of the First Nations who have resided in these forests for millennia and on land which has never been ceded or signed away in treaty. On the central coast in the Great Bear Rainforest, few First Nations communities receive direct economic benefit from the logging. At times, as much as 90 % of the logging "benefits" have completely bypassed the region. "

There's still hope of saving the forests. We can all make a difference by refusing to buy wood that comes from ancient forests in BC. How do you know where wood comes from? Look for the Forestry Stewardship Council (FSC) label/logo as a mark of forestry from secondary, managed plantations of known origin. Going for recycled paper products makes a difference; so too does writing to newspapers and magazines asking them not to get their pulp from the companies Interfor, Macmillan Bloedel, and WFP who have been clearcutting the old forests of British Columbia.

Forest Action Network: http://www.fanweb.org/index.shtml

Greenpeace: http://www.greenpeace.org/~forests/f_index1.html

NRDC: http://www.nrdc.org/nrdc/nrdc/status/foclay.html

FSC scheme: http://www.fscoax.org/index.html

Road

Japan

01 Jan 1998

Government palace preserved in Nara

The government palace from the ancient Japanese city of Nara stands as an example of how a national treasure has been preserved despite intense pressure for development (a bypass project).

About.com archaeology site: http://archaeology.miningco.com/library/weekly/aa071199.htm?pid=2826&cob=home

Tourism

Egypt

01 Jan 1998

Tourism threatens Egypt's monuments and artefacts

Tourism has become one of the most dynamic sectors of the Egyptian economy. As a consequence, the decay of some of the world's most fabulous ancient relics has been proceeding at an alarming rate. Some say that if current rates continue unabated, within another one to two centuries the paintings and architecture of many of these monuments will be completely destroyed. Although there are no legal proceedings currently taking place, the potential exists mainly in international organizations that could exert pressure on Egypt to preserve its ancient treasures.

http://gurukul.ucc.american.edu/ted/egypt.htm

Road

Greece

Nov 1997

Development juggernaut threatens Greek cemetery

Archaeologists fear that construction of a subway tunnel under the Kerameikos cemetery (center) will destabilize marble funerary

sculptures erected by ancient Athenians. "Ancient sites, which reflect the ambitions of people of the past, are now threatened by ambitious people of the present. "

http://www.archaeology.org/9711/abstracts/greece.html

Tourism

Greece

13 Sep 1997

Tourism threatens to damage Cretan ruins

CRETE'S most important ancient site, the Minoan palace of Knossos, is suffering from severe neglect and mismanagement, officials have admitted.

Graffiti, queues, confusing signposts and bands of unlicensed guides who describe themselves as "curators", are just some of the problems affecting the monument, which was built in 1400 BC and is renowned for its frescoes.

Daily Telegraph/Electronic Telegraph, 13 Sep 1997:

http://www.telegraph.co.uk:80/et?ac=001696131314601&rtmo=fMoMraNs&atmo=6666666J&pg=/et/97/9/13/etncre13.html

Archaeology

Egypt

01 May 1997

Are archaeologists killing off classical African civilizations?

"For years our scholars have informed us that the world has long sought to suppress, distort or ignore Black history. In antiquity, foreign invaders destroyed African monuments, defaced them or adopted them as their own. Centuries later, after Europe conquered and colonized Africa, Western historians erased the record of African greatness. They removed Black people from Egypt, Egypt from Africa and Africa from world history. According to Professor Manu Ampim, the desecration of Africa, her people, her monuments and her culture persists even today. European and Arab 'conservation' teams arecurrently defacing and destroying Egyptian temple and tomb images and inscriptions."

The MAAT Newsletter, Volume I, Edition V, May 1997: http://www.melanet.com/clegg_series/maat0597.html

Development

Palestine

01 Jan 1997

Israeli bulldozers destroyed Christian Holy Sites

An old story about an inspiring bit of direct action against the 'dozers at mount Abu Ghniem.

http://www.bailasan.com/pinc/english/news3.htm

Development

France

01 Jan 1997

French archaeologists strike at Rodez

French archaeologists strike over controversial Rodez scheme. Yes, archaeologists have been known to protest too.

http://pages.pratique.fr/~archdata/actualites/ga97a/gainfoangl.html

Development

Canada

01 Oct 1996

Iroquoi sites under threat

A Finite Iroquoian Legacy: A number of fragile Iroquoian sites near Toronto, the fastest growing city in Canada, are threatened by developers' bulldozers.

An article by Brian Fagan from Archaeology, (Archaeological Institute of America ): http://www.archaeology.org/9609/abstracts/depts.html#ontario

Tourism

Kenya

26 Jan 1996

Tourism cuts swathe through Kenya's spiritual enclaves

Sheltered fortified forests on the South coast of Mombasa are used as spiritual enclaves, burial grounds, and a source for medicinal herbs. But they are coming under increasing threat from developers motivated by tourist profits.

UK Telegraph/Electronic Telegraph, Friday 26 Jan 1996:

http://www.telegraph.co.uk:80/et?ac=001696131314601&rtmo=fMoMraNs&atmo=6666666J&pg=/et/96/1/26/wkenya26.html

Archaeology and development

USA California

01 Jan 1995

Victory for Native Americans at Pavunga

A nice story from 1995. Note how the Native Americans saw both the "backhoes of archaeologists and bulldozers of developers" as an unwelcome intrusion into their sacred lands; a clear conspiracy between archaeologists and developers?

http://www.csulb.edu/~eruyle/puvufly_9508_howlong.html

First Americans Journal

http://www.turtle-island.com/first.html

 

 

Road

USA Indiana

01 Jan 1992

The NAFTA 1800 mile superhighway

This began in 1990 as a proposal for 100 miles of new highway between

Indianapolis and Evansville, Ind., and has steadily grown. By the end of 1992 Congress had expanded the project tenfold, transforming it into a NAFTA Superhighway proposal. There has been no proper investigation of archaeological impacts.

http://www.bikeroute.com/autofree/fighters.html

Pillage

Lebanon

01 Jan 1991

Lebanon's treasures plundered after 15-year war

"After 15 years of war, Lebanon has fallen victim to the greatest pillage of Graeco-Roman, Iron and Bronze Age treasures in the Middle East since European explorers sacked the area more than a century ago. Priceless statues, Byzantine mosaics, Roman glass and Phoenician gold are being illegally exported to London, Paris, New York and Bonn by Lebanese dealers and international middlemen while some of the most important archaeological sites in what was ancient Phoenicia have been destroyed by treasure-hunters."

Robert Fisk, BERITUS Vol XXXIX, 1991:

http://almashriq.hiof.no/ddc/projects/archaeology/berytus-back/berytus39/fisk/index.html

Development

USA Arizona

01 Jan 1990

Ruination of prehistoric site still grieves anthropologist

PHOENIX: Mesa anthropologist Jerry Howard's heart aches when he recalls the time a prehistoric Hohokam Indian site near here was bulldozed into oblivion. The outlook is improving, however. Many developers are becoming more sensitive and interested in helping to preserve Arizona's past, if they can afford to. "It's a matter of education rather than creating new laws," said Tom Simplot, assistant director of the industry group Home Builders of Central Arizona. "As good citizens, we recognize efforts to preserve our past while building our future."

http://deseretnews.com/dn/view/0,1249,30001228,00.html


This page hosted by
Get your own Free Home Page
1