Barney and Instant Gratification
There are many problems with Barney , but I am going to focus on a single,
important one: the use of instant gratification. This problem has not been covered as
much as some others, but I believe it is as important as any.
The synopsis of instant gratification is simple; one of the childrenasks for or
wants something, and Barney gives it to them. For example, in the episode on
neighborhoods, a boy wants a telescope so he can explore the neighborhood. Presto!
Barney gets him a telescope (and a very nice one at that) using his "Barney magic".
Instant gratification fosters the following confusing or disturbing ideas in young
children:
- "If I want something, I should be able to get it right now." Although the
phenomenon is written off as "Barney magic" or imagination" in the show, little kids
often don't know the difference between fantasy and reality.They could easily expect
their parents to be able to do what Barney does, and when their parents don't grant
their every wish, they could become confused and decide that there is something
wrong with Mommy and Daddy.
Also, Barney makes no distinction between stealing and sharing. He has even
specifically said that "stealing is okay if the person you steal from doesn't mind". Kids
can learn that if you really want something, stealing is a perfectly acceptable way to
get it. This is not something that preschoolers need authority figures to tell them.
- "If I just have the right thing, I can solve all my problems." Whenever the kids have
a problem, Barney gives them whatever they need to solve it. The message being sent
here is "Don't try to think to solve this! It's too much work, and the solution probably
wouldn't work anyway. Just use this." Because of this, children could stop thinking
through things (Barney said it was too much work) and become dependent on the
"right" object. (The right shoes, the right food, the right computer, the right exercise
machine...) This is obviously a good message for the Barney marketers, but it's not
good for preschoolers.
Most other kids' television shows teach creative problem solving well, without
having to resort to "magic". Barney could also have done that but instead decided to
use the method that was A) best for the marketers and B) took the least time and
money for scripts. It's a blatant sellout that shows just how little the Lyons Group
actually cares about children.
Back