| First Team |
 QB Steve Young - 318 3615 Pass, 434 rush, 37 TD Ragin Geckos |
 RB Terrell Davis - 256 1801 Rush, 195 Rec, 22 TD Scorpions |
 RB Fred Taylor - 144 846 Rush, 240 Rec, 13 TD Ragin Geckos |
 WR Randy Moss - 165 1186 Rec, 14 TD Scorpions |
 WR Antonio Freeman-137 1173 Rec, 10 TD Ragin Geckos |
 WR Terrell Owens - 130 866 Rec, 39 Rush, 12 TD Hosers |
 K Morton Andersen - 115 46 XP, 22 FG Scorpions |
 DT New England Patriots - 192 Cakeboys |
| Second Team |
 QB Brett Favre - 275 4059 Pass, 133 Rush, 31 TD Cakeboys |
 RB Robert Smith - 123 1013 Rush, 241 Rec, 8 TD Cakeboys |
 RB Barry Sanders - 122 1356 Rush, 275 Rec, 4 TD The Crush |
 WR Joey Galloway - 125 1014 Rec, 29 Rush, 12 TD Cakeboys |
 WR Jerry Rice - 105 959 Rec, 7 TD Pimp Daddies |
 WR Cris Carter - 103 821 Rec, 9 TD Pimp Daddies |
 K Gary Anderson - 100 37 XP, 19 FG Hot Peppers |
 DT Denver Broncos - 174 Ragin Geckos |
