| Who | Won From | Date | How |
| Marc "Sellout" Foley | -- | 5/8/99 | Won Battle Royal |
| Pierce 607 | Marc "Sellout" Foley | 5/22/99 | Pinfall |
| Superstar Shawn Storm | Pierce 607 | 6/12/99 | Won 2 Of 3 Falls |
| Marc "Sellout" Foley | -- | 7/31/99 | Defeated Justin "The Snake" Roberts in number 1 contender match after Superstar Shawn Storm forfeited the title. |
| 71 Pac | Marc "Sellout" Foley | 9/11/99 | Won 2 Of 3 Falls |
| Justin "The Snake" Roberts | 71 Pac | 10/4/99 | Pinfall |
| 71 Pac | Justin "The Snake" Roberts | 10/30/99 | Pinfall |
| Marc "Sellout" Foley | -- | 5/20/00 | Won In 4 Corners Match After 71 Pac Retired |
| 71 Pac | Marc "Sellout" Foley | 7/8/00 | Defeated Foley and Psychogay in Triple Threat Ironman Match |
| Psychogay | -- | 8/12/00 | Won Battle Royal |
| 71 Pac | Psychogay | 6/29/02 | Defeated Psychogay and Superstar Shawn Storm in a Triple Threat Match |
