| Who | Won From | Date | How |
| 71 Pac | -- | 5/8/99 | Pinned The Rage In #1 Contender Match |
| Pierce 607 | 71 Pac | 5/15/99 | Pinfall |
| 71 Pac | -- | 5/22/99 | Defeated Cactus Sack After Pierce 607 Forfeited The Title |
| The Rage | 71 Pac | 6/12/99 | Won Ladder Match |
| Cactus Sack | -- | 7/24/99 | Defeated Diablo in Hardcore Match after The Rage wussed out and quit. |
| 71 Pac | Cactus Sack | 8/14/99 | Pinfall |
| Psycho Gay | -- | 9/11/99 | Defeated Cactus Sack in #1 Contender Match after 71 Pac forfeited the title. |
| Cactus Sack | Psycho Gay | 9/18/99 | Pinfall |
| El Nino | Cactus Sack | 9/25/99 | Pinfall |
| Cactus Sack | El Nino | 10/4/99 | Pinfall |
| Special Ed | -- | 5/13/00 | Awarded Title By Jess Stutzman |
| Shannon Bates & Amy Thompson | Special Ed | 5/13/00 | Pinfall |
| Special Ed | -- | 5/13/00 | Given the title after Shannon & Amy refused to take it |
| Funk | Special Ed | 5/13/00 | Pinfall |
| Special Ed | -- | 5/13/00 | Given the title after Funk refused to take it |
| JMX | Special Ed | 5/13/00 | Pinfall |
| Special Ed | -- | 5/13/00 | Given the title after JMX refused to take it |
| The Rage | Special Ed | 5/20/00 | Pinfall |
| Special Ed | The Rage | 5/20/00 | Pinfall |
