I guess I should explain this list. All these players played for United in the 60s. A lot played much of their football in the 50s, but due to lack of information I didn't do a 50s list, so included them here. There is a lot of overlap between the list for the 60s and the list for the 70s. I apologise. These things aren't easy to do. Finally the stats are for all competitions, excluding the Charity shield, World Club Cup and the European Super Cup.
Player
(Career at United)
apps/sub
goals
Willie Anderson (63/66)
10/2
Johnny Aston jnr
(64/71)
164/21
27
George Best (63/73)
466
178
Warren Bradley (58/61)
66
21
Shay Brennan (57/69)
355/1
6
Ronnie Briggs (60/61)
11
Francis Burns (67/71)
142/13
7
Noel Cantwell (60/66)
144
8
Joe Carolan (58/60)
71
Bobby Charlton (56/72)
752/2
247
Phil Chisnall (61/63)
47
10
John Connelly (64/66)
112/1
35
Ronnie Cope (56/60)
106
2
Pat Crerand (62/70)
392
15
Alex Dawson (56/71)
93
54
Tony Dunne (60/72)
529/1
2
Pat Dunne (64/65)
66
Paul Edwards (69/72)
66/2
1
John Fitzpatrick
(64/72)
141/6
10
Bill Foulkes (52/69)
679/3
9
David Gaskell (57/66)
118
Johnny Giles (59/62)
114
13
Don Givens (69)
5/4
1
Alan Gowling (67/71)
77/10
21
Harry Gregg (57/66)
247
Frank Haydock (60/62)
6
David Herd (61/67)
262/1
144
Tommy Heron (57/60)
3