PHYSICS
EXPERIMENTAL INVESTIGATION
INFORMATION BOOKLET
CONTENTS
Overview |
Page 3 |
Introduction |
Page 4 |
Selecting a Topic |
Page 4 |
Designing a Practical Investigation |
Page 5 |
Carrying Out the investigation |
Page 7 |
Writing a Research Report |
Page 7 |
Sample Topics |
Appendix 1 Page 12 |
Planning Sheets |
Appendix 2 Page 15 |
Equipment Request Sheets |
Appendix 3 Page 18 |
Report Drafting Sheets |
Appendix 4 Page 22 |
BOS Advice |
Appendix 5 Page 26 |
Assessment Criteria |
Appendix 6 Page 27 |
Assessment Sheet |
Appendix 7 Page 32 |
EXPERIMENTAL INVESTIGATION OVERVIEW
For this work requirement you hove to choose a topic related to physics and investigate it. You need to work out what experiments you will be performing and the apparatus needed. Your topic should be simple so that you can find out as much as possible about it. When choosing your topic keep in mind that the school has only a limited supply of basic equipment and if any specialist equipment is needed you will have to arrange it yourself.
All of your experiments should be done in a log book, which will be referred to later when you write your report. Everything should be written down in your log book.
Your report will need to have the following:
The investigation may be done inn group with a maximum group size of two and each member of the group must do their own analysis and write their own report.
The report should be between 1000 and 1200 words in length, supplemented by appropriate diagrams, graphs and tables.
Topic Choice Due: |
14th July |
Plan Due: |
20th July |
Equipment list Due: |
20th July |
Perform Experiment and Write Report: |
31st July – 11th August |
Report Due: |
16th August |
PRINCIPLES OF INVESTIGATION
This section of work, consists of the planning, execution and formal reporting of an extended experimental investigation in physics appropriate to Year 12 level. In this investigation you are given the opportunity to choose your own topic to investigate (subject to school approval). Thus, you have the opportunity to design the total task which will include; deciding the method you will adopt to solve the problem, selecting or making your own apparatus, deciding what variables have to be observed or measured and the degree of accuracy appropriate for these measurements. As with most investigation problems you may well 'hit a wall' at which time you may need to seek assistance or even abandon an unpromising line of inquiry: if this should happen, do not despair but fully record all your experimental procedure and difficulties encountered and include them in your formal report.
The three stages of the experimental investigation should be completed mainly in class in the following suggested times,
Developing a plan 40-50 minutes
Implementing the plan 240-300 minutes
Analysis and evaluation 80-100 minutes. (Total 2 Weeks)
The plan, implementation, analysis and evaluation should be completed in class time. Students should use their logbook of practical activities throughout the investigation. Further guidelines regarding logbooks can be found on page 42 of the Physics Study Design.
Finally, this task contributes 60% of your internal assessment for unit 4 and so a concerted effort over an extended period of time is essential. When selecting a topic it is essential that it has the potential to achieve a good grade when subjected to the external verification process.
The topic selected need not be ‘pure physics', however it must incorporate the classic techniques of experimental physics. The investigation must fit into ONE of the following contexts:
Before seeking school approval for your proposed investigation, please ensure such questions as listed below could be answered in the affirmative:
Will the investigation include physics measuring techniques?
Could you produce a rough set of measurements from materials readily available in the laboratory or home in an hour or so?
Will you be a thinker rather than a data recording medium when conducting the experiment?
At the end of the investigation will you have produced some useful conclusions?
In general it is better to use simple equipment that can be adapted or modified as required. Past experience would Indicate that it is better to choose a topic that generates several small soluble problems rather than a large insoluble problem. Very complicated problems can usually only be attempted after seeking considerable assistance from others. While the seeking of assistance is not forbidden, the focus of this task is on the students own practical investigation. In fact in the past the best investigations have often been conducted on topics students initially considered too easy.
WARNING:
Group work is possible provided the following guidelines are observed:
The provision for group work in the course Guidelines is a concession to assist students investigating the same phenomenon that requires intricate or difficult apparatus techniques and you would be warned against contemplating group work unless there are very good reasons for doing so.
Finally, if you are unable to select an appropriate topic for investigation assistance will be given at a later date. However if you can choose a topic from your own personal interests then you will probably gain the maximum enjoyment and satisfaction, maybe even excitement and possibly the greatest sense of achievement in all your secondary science education.
In summary, from p 31 – 32 Science Assessment Guide, the topic selected for investigation should:
Initially, it is probably a good idea to 'brain storm' alternative ways of tackling the investigation. Generally, the following steps will have to be adhered to:
The general area of research e.g. topic might be 'A bouncing basketball'
To be investigated e.g. To investigate how the bounce height of a basketball is affected by:
Tackle one problem thoroughly rather than get too ambitious in attempting to investigate say, the elasticity, velocity, kinetic energy, momentum and impulse of a bouncing basketball.
May be stated e.g. you may hypothesise that the basketball bounce height may increase with increased pressure. However a stated hypothesis is not necessarily part of an investigation.
With books, journals or people with greater expertise than yourself if you have insufficient information to commence the investigation. It is almost inevitable that you will have to do some background research before commencing your investigation. Remember that any assistance obtained before or during the Investigation is to be recorded. If the source of assistance is written it needs to be included in the Bibliography, if the source of assistance is a person, they should be mentioned in the Acknowledgements section of your report.
Required to complete the investigation will have to be obtained and/or constructed. The school's policy is to make available to you any equipment it currently owns for use within the physics lab e.g. CRO's, Multimeters etc. Specialised equipment that you may require will have to be purchased by you. In some cases the school may purchase the items for you if it perceives it can use such items in the future, but this eventually will be the exception rather than the rule. (i.e. don't count on it)
Will then be constructed and submitted to the teacher on or before a specified date.
Presenting results may be in one of several forms e.g.
e.g. the minimum temperature of a hot drink decreased as the number of added ice blocks increased.
The variable fixed by the experimenter is known as the independent variable and is placed on the horizontal axis, the resulting variable is known as the dependent variable and is placed on the vertical axis.
May be stated e.g. variable X is directly/inversely proportional to variable Y. Such a statement may become obvious when the graph of the relationship is plotted.
From the graph of the relationship it may even be possible to derive an equation relating the two variables.
A log book record is essential to record your procedure, ideas that come to you, changes in direction you decide on, the data you collect, test graphs that should be drawn as soon as the data is generated (ASAP graphs) in order to check rough results before the apparatus is dismantled. The log book is a running diary of your research and there is no doubt that the better and more complete your log book record the easier it will be to produce a tonal report. As part of the verification process log book duplicates will be collected on stated dates, see following time line, and kept in the teachers possession.
The aspects of the student-designed investigation can be managed in three stages.
Each student prepares a plan of what they intend to do that
describes:
Each student should assemble their equipment and carry out their experimental investigation. The implementation requires the student to:
Detailed records of these procedures should be kept in the student logbook.
Each student should analyse the findings of their experimental investigation, using records from their logbook. The following points should he considered in completing the evaluation:
On this page the various sections of the report are listed. This implies that the pages of the report are numbered and that the construction of the Table of Contents is best left until the rest of the report is completed.
This section is not essential but could be used:
AND / OR
Here you should clearly state what you set out to investigate while keeping the statement as brief as possible. If you have more than one aim then number them.
This will be the bulk of your report and will contain the following:
Diagrams and photographs showing apparatus set up are very helpful and along with graphs should be numbered consecutively, Fig. 1 'title', Fig. 2 'title' etc. These figures should be as close as possible to the section of the report to which they relate. In your text specific reference should be made to each diagram etc. e.g. 'as shown in Fig. 3'. If the diagram is some pages away from the textual reference, a statement 'as shown in Fig. 3 on page 5' would be appropriate. Refer to section in Unit I notes for conventions when drawing graphs.
Measurements taken during the investigation should be presented in tabulation form with the tables being numbered Table 1 'brief title', Table 2:'brief title' etc. Tables should be specifically referred to in the text. If a table is not close to its reference, the page number should be given as well, e.g. 'Table 3 on page 4 demonstrates...' If there are a large number of similar tables or graphs they may clutter up the main body of the report. Select the most relevant for the text and include the rest as Appendices at the end of the report.
The conclusion is to be approximately 250 words to be towards the end of the report. The conclusion is to state clearly if the aim/s were achieved. It is absolutely essential that the evidence upon which the conclusions are based must be stated e.g. frequency of the guitar string was proportional to the square root of the tension in the string as the graph of frequency vs tension produce a straight line intersecting at the origin as shown in Fig. 4.
As most investigations involve considerable measurements it is worthwhile to take the uncertainties of measurements into account in order to have greater confidence in your conclusions and to make your report adhere more closely to those of professional physicists.
Consider a rod whose length is being measured by a ruler as shown below:
Obviously the rod length is between 32.5 and 32.9 mm. Thus an answer of 32.70 may at first seem reasonable but on reflection it should be appreciated the 7 is the first uncertain figure and the 0 the second uncertain figure. Usually it is regarded as justifiable to retain the first uncertain figure and so the recorded answer would be 32.7 mm. To record any more decimal places is clearly unjustifiable while to retain less (33 mm) is not using the ruler to its full accuracy. Another way of recording this result is (32.7 ± 0.2) mm. Note the limit of reading of an instrument with a digital readout is one unit in the extreme right hand position of the display.
Percentage uncertainty (or tolerance) is the ratio of the absolute uncertainty in the measurement to the measurement itself expressed as a percentage.
In the previous example:
Suppose you determined the acceleration due to gravity to be (9.9 ± 0.3) ms-2. The 0.3 ms-2 uncertainty results from uncertainties in the measurements made during the investigations. The accepted value of the acceleration due to gravity is 9.8 ms-2. Percentage error is defined as:
In the previous example
However, the percentage uncertainty in this example would be:
Percentage uncertainty is a more important concept than percentage error and the one that you would tend to quote in your report at the end of the determination of some physical quantity.
Remember if the 'true' value is known it is possible to determine if your experimental value is in agreement with the accepted value e.g. (9.9 ± 0.3)ms-2 would be in agreement with the accepted value of acceleration due to gravity of 9.8 ms-2 while a determined value of (9.2 ± 0.3) ms-2 would not be in agreement with the accepted value.
Accuracy when combining measurements now has to be considered. If more details are required consult the reference or teacher for additional information.
Note: The definition of the last significant figure in a measured quantity is the first uncertain figure.
91.43 cm
+ 0.1462cm
91.5762 cm
The first uncertain figure in 91.43 is '3' while the first uncertain figure in 0.1462 is '2'. Thus the '7' in the sum of the measurements is the first uncertain figure. From the previously stated rule and because the second significant figure is greater than 4 the accepted answer would be 91.58 cm.
Consider the distance covered by a runner travelling at 5.32 ms-1 if he travels for 9.7 s.
distance = speed ´ time
=5.32 ´ 9.7
=51.604 m
The first uncertain figure in the speed is '2' this then becomes the last significant figure. Thus, 5.32 consists of 3 significant figures. Similarly, 9.7 consists of 2 significant figures. From the previous rule the answer must be rounded off to 2 significant figures. Thus the accepted answer would be 52 m.
Note: Zeros immediately after a decimal point do not count as significant figures, e.g. 0.0172 m is 3 significant figures.
Here, you should acknowledge briefly those who provided assistance in either your research or the preparation of your report. You should state their names and the reason for which you are thanking them.
At VCE level it is suggested that footnotes at the bottom of pages be avoided. However you are required to lost any book, journal article or report that you have consulted and which proved helpful in your Investigation. Although not essential it is recommended you consider annotating your reference list i.e. for each title you add a short comment on its usefulness. Finally the items should be listed alphabetically by author's surname.
The information required is:
optional
Example:
Dawson, M & Schwarz, L., Clockwork Motors , McGraw-Hill, Sydney 1973, Chapter 2. Extremely helpful, though somewhat out of date.
The details required include:
optional
Examples:
Jones, R K., 'Biophysics of Sprinting', Scientific America, Vol. XXVI, 1987, p 34-46.
The source for the two hypotheses tested. Excellent diagrams.
Kirk, Joan, 'Behind the New Athletics', The Australian, 24 August 1991, p 18. Clear description of the current use of sports technology.
The necessary information includes:
optional
Example:
Institute of Radiologists Report on Radon Levels in Sydney Households, Sydney, 1992.
Helpful in providing approximate levels expected in tests.
The necessary information includes:
The necessary information includes:
The necessary information includes:
Certain components in a report can effect the continuity for the reader and are best placed at the end as appendices. These would Include:
The appendices should be listed alphabetically or using Roman numerals I, II, III... or using letters A, B, C... Each appendix should bear a title, be specifically referred to in the main body of the text and listed with a title in the Table of Contents.
APPENDIX 1
LIST OF POSSIBLE TOPICS FOR EXTENDED INVESTIGATIONS
APPENDIX 2
TOPIC SPECIFICATION SHEET
EXPERIMENTAL INVESTIGATION
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
QUANTITY |
ITEM (one per line) |
SIZE |
PROVIDED BY |
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
Project must be approved by your teacher:
APPENDIX 3
EXPERIMENTAL INVESTIGATION APPARATUS REQUISITION
(School Copy)
NAME: _______________
Title Of Investigation:
Location Of Apparatus (To Be Completed By Laboratory Manager):
Materials Required:
QUANTITY |
ITEM (one per line) |
SIZE |
PROVIDED BY |
EXPERIMENTAL INVESTIGATION APPARATUS REQUISITION
(Student Copy)
NAME: _______________
Title Of Investigation:
Location Of Apparatus (To Be Completed By Laboratory Manager):
Materials Required:
QUANTITY |
ITEM (one per line) |
SIZE |
PROVIDED BY |
APPENDIX 4
Drafting the Report
These sheets ore NOT part of your final presentation. They are for drafting purposes only. This is to help you organise the Information in your log book into a coherent report.
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
Make a list of the principal apparatus
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________
Step No (above) |
Name of record or table |
Place of record or page in log book |
Firstly list the concepts or main ideas that you will need.
Consult your teacher before going further
Now use the space below to write a preliminary draft explaining the principles behind your investigation
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
Author |
Name of Book |
Publisher |
City |
Year |
Other references/acknowledgements
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
Now write up your report. You don't have to do it in the above order, if you feel that the order should be changed so that the report flows bettor then do it. Remember it is the REPORT that is going to be assessed.
APPENDIX 5
Board of Studies Advice Sheet
Physics
Experimental Investigation
APPENDIX 6
Experimental Investigation Assessment Criteria
The practical report is assessed on the extent to which it (the report) demonstrates
Criterion 1 (10 marks)
Plan a practical investigation, using equipment correctly and safely in conducting practical work.
Criterion 2 (15 marks)
Observe and record data accurately and estimate uncertainties.
Criterion 3 (10 marks)
Analysis and interpretation of experimental data.
Criterion 4 (10 marks)
Evaluation of the practical work.
Criterion 5 (15 marks)
Knowledge and application of appropriate physics terms, concepts and relationships.
APPENDIX 7