WOMEN IN MUSLIM HISTORY
V - Future Perspectives
It cannot be the aim of this series to rest on our historical laurels.
While it is important, on one side, to correct a wrong historical image,
to know the example of our mothers and sisters from former ages, and to
illustrate the ideals and possiblities of Qur'an and Sunnah with examples
for their realization, we must not, on the other hand, ignore the fact
that there was no linear development towards the ideal but many things
that needs criticism and change.
A. In the Past
- The possibilities for education and development of their potential
was not open to all women (and men). Sometimes it was just a matter of
missing communication links or financial means, sometimes tight personal
circumstances or social conventions blocked the way. Many activities were
depending on a person's own initiative. Often there was an immense gap
between urban centres of cultural life with mosques, schools, libraries,
public meetings etc. on one side and the "province" on the other where
illiteracy was widespread and practical knowledge and wisdom was
transmitted
orally from one generation to the next together with superstition and
undue trust in human authorities. Often there was also a deep gap between
social classes (incompatible with the Islamic principles of social
justice).
- There was an interaction between this situation and the forces that
were
opposing Islam, like power interests and mechanisms of oppression. In very
much the same way as in the history of other religions, it happened that
rulers twisted the law in their favour, exploiting their subjects in the
name
of religion, while the people had neither the knowledge nor the courage to
do anything about it. Women were more or less left to themselves while men
were given a chance for a career and competition in the army and the
administration. In the long run, however, misuse of power, violence,
ignorance, oppression, corrruption and exploitation results in the decay
of nations and cultures. In this case, they led to the decay of Muslim
society that was followed by the colonial age.
B. In the Present
What is left is nations who have lost much of the knowledge about their
cultural roots in general, who have forgotten the greater part of their
values and ideals, whose religious rites and social conventions have to
some extent lost their meaning, whose identity has been replaced by a
treacherous nationalism. This also implies a widespread ignorance
concerning
the essence and intention of Islam so that ordinary believers who otherwise
have a genuine love for God and the Prophet do not have the courage and the
possibility to question traditional habits and challenges from outside in
the light of Qur'an and Sunna. Very un-Islamic ideas are sometimes taken
for and defended as "Islamic" teachings, among other things the prevalent
double standards concerning men and women.
- Worldwide, religious and human values are confronted with materialist
values. Materialist values promise immediate, tangible success while
ehtical ideas, at first sight, seem to be connected with limitations
because
they transcend individual interests, pointing to the wellbeing of all and
a future shaped in the consciousness of responsibility. Materialist
standards
interpret the past and the present in their own way without considering the
development (ethical, spiritual, cultural, or human) that does not fit into
the system of buying and selling. Thus, they are like the eschatological
figure of the one eyed Dajjal who cannot perceive the dimension of depth.
The spiritual gap is then filled with commercialized religious forms.
This makes orientation difficult especially for young people whose life
experience is not yet enough to see though the slogans they are confronted
with, much less to develop visions of a future of their own.
- With industrialization, a work situation has developed that tends to
destroy family structures without offering alternatives. This makes it
difficult especially for elderly people who often remain left to themselves
or taken to nursing homes where they feel unwanted and not able to benefit
society with their life experience. Even worse are the disadvantages for
children who have no chance to grow into a society with a healthy
relationship between the generations and to discover the changes of life.
Last but not least, the situation proves to be of disadvantage for women.
If they give priority to their role as mothers, they are often isolated
for several years with their young children, being left to themselves to
solve their problems, their work that is done out of sight of the public
neither being paid nor being properly recognized. Improved facilities for
aduld education do not really make a significant difference. On the other
hand, a paid job implies a long absence from home, most often resulting
in a double burden of work that hardly leaves time enough for recreation
and most often does not often an opportunity for unfolding their potential
for most jobs are certainly not meant for self-realization. Besides, the
demand for "equal pay for equal work" has, as yet, not been put into
practice anywhere in the world, women being discriminated against even
when their qualification is equal to that of the men in question. All this
is true both for "industrialized countries" and for "developing countries".
- The result is increasing loneliness and resignation and, at the same
time, an increasing concentration on one's own ego. This makes the
solution of problems even more difficult because it starts a chain reaction
of fears, depression, expectations, frustration and fanaticism that can
cause a person to get caught in a net of dependence. Even today there are
Muslim women who use their potential and their possibilities for their
own benefit and for the benefit of others, but at the same time, there are
too many of them who do not even know their potential and their
possibilities.
How Do We Shape Our Future?
It is a general human experience that complaints alone do not bring about
changes. And while looking for a scapegoat can give a ccertain feeling of
relief because it seems to relativate one's personal responsibility, it
leads to prejudices and demonization rather that to real solutions that
consider the complexity of a situation of which the social status of
woman is a symptomatic part.
"God does not change the situation of a people before they change what
is within themselves" - with these words, the Qur'an expresses a law
operative in human society. Changing ourselves has an intellectual and
spiritual as well as a social and political component that are closely
linked with each other.
- "Striving for knowledge is a sacred duty for every Muslim, man and
woman," said God's Messenger (s). Although he did not only enjoin this
to his companions but also made arrangements for the Muslims to learn and
teach all kinds of knowledge, this sentence was often forgotten, ignored
and even misused in later times, first of all in the interest of rulers,
for "knowledge is power" that might be used to question existing
structures.
Thus, believers have often been warned against e.g. reading the Qur'an on
their own and to think about it, with terrible threats concerning the
dangers of errors, while certain scholars were paid by the rulers to claim
a monopoly to explain the Qur'an in the interest of their employers and
quite contrary to the commandment of the Qur'an itself to study and
reflect and not to follow authorities uncritically, linked with the
repeated promise that God is ready to guide the sincere seeker and to
forgive his/her errors and mistakes. Similarly, the relations between
theology and other fields of knowledge has often been cut off with the
pretext that critical research could threaten faith - even though the
Qur'an repeatedly points out the laws in nature, history and even within
ourselves as "signs of God", enjoining us to study them and to draw
conclusions from them. "Signs for people who use their intellect,"
says the Qur'an, pointing out to us the necessity to acqire knowledge and
to use it in a responsible manner. Today, we must call this aspect to
mind. "Knowledge is the believer's lost camel," said the Prophet
(s), "whoever finds it should hold it." This does include the
knowledge of our cultural roots and our strugle for our identity. People
who acquire and teach knowlege were compared by the Prophet (s) with those
who are in jihad in God's path. Whoever has the privilege to acquire
knowledge is like one who acquires material wealth and equally obliged to
share it with others.
- Knowledge should not make us arrogant. It can only reach its full
quality when it is not appropriated for selfish ends but used in a
meaningful
way. This requires self-knowledge and self-education. We must become aware
of our standards and aims. Here it is essential to be conscious of God's
presence, to know that we are not left to ourselves and that we are
responsible before him according to our dignity as His representatives
on earth. This should give us the motivation and courage to stand up for
the realization of our ideals once we have understood or rediscovered
them. Practically, this means that we balance our own legitimate interests
and aims like peace, justice, love etc. the realization of which is our
task on earth. We should therefore unfold our potential, refine our
character, control ourselves, understand the real problems and practice
solidarity with those who are less privileged.
- Besides educating ourself, there is a possibility of positively
educating others, especially our children. They are the first to have a
right not only to inherit our theoretical knowledge but profit from our
example. Even from our mistakes they can learn to deal with things like
that as faithful human beings by asking their creator for forgiveness and
help and to keep up the struggle. Whether they are our physical children
or other human beings: education is always an exchange that tests our
sincerity. An important factor for education is community life that demands
qualities like compassion, solidarity patience, courage, trust,
perseverance
and the readiness for cooperation. Last but nor least, we shoulc keep in
mind that God's Messenger (s) enjoined us to give an equally good education
to boys and girls.
- Even through individual efforts concerning the first three points as
well as self-help a lot can be achieved. In the long run, however, social
and political considerations and steps are necessary, because mere
information about Islamic principles and teachings cultivated individually
or in small groups while stereotyped images are cultivated by the mass
media is no more than a drop in the ocean. This is especially true
concerning women. It is important for us to contrast the prevalent
images with visible examples of our own efforts to realize our visions,
e.g. by improving women's education the way it is intended by Qur'an and
Sunna, to support them in emergencies and by using our knowledge and
abilities positively and publicly in the scientific, social and political
field. Those of our brothers who are not yet used to this idea for
traditional reasons should try to remember the examples of women in the
time of the Prophet (s) and the following generations or at least realize
that their own children will be at a great disadvantage if their mothers
are kept uneducated and ignorant of the world. Both men and women should
be aware that ultimately, in any case, our human responsibility bears
more weight than any considerations of "social control".
- In a time when social structures and circumstances are changing
quickly, we must develop visions of our own and bring in our own
impulses. Qur'an, Sunna and our experience in history enable us to review
both our present traditions and ideas and those of our non-Muslim
environment critically. Admittedly this takes us, at first, unto some
no man's land. At the same time it takes us closer to the experience of
the prophets and friends of God who, in loving and unremittingly laid the
foundation to rich Muslim cultures.
Islamic Studies Index
Home Page