Abraham, Hagar and Sarah


Many a Jewish and Christian reader who opens the Qur'an for the first time is surprised to find, in the otherwise rather strange book, familiar figures, among them Abraham. With further reading he will find well-known stories but sometimes also unknown ones or variations from the details and perspectives he is used to. He might then find that the Qur'an frequently only mentiones individual episodes in order to illustrate certain theological and ethical statements, and very often all that remains is a short hint at a story supposed to be known. Many readers and even experts then give in to the temptation to understand these as hints at the Biblical account, especially since the Bible is explicitely mentioned in the Qur'an as a Scripture of Revelation, and very often the fact is ignored that even in context with the Bible there are oral traditions supplementing it that have not been sufficiently researched yet. After Abraham, the Bible follows the family history through Isaac, Jacob (Israel) and the twelve tribes of the Children of Israel with their specific religious experience which is the root of two world religions and are also important for Islam. It now becomes intersting when the traditions of other nations are investigated who trace their genealogy back to Abraham, this time through Hagar and Ismail as well as his third wife Qeturah and her sons. They are the tribes and nations of the Arab peninsula the culture of whom was bookless until the advent of the Prophet Muhammad (s) but who nevertheless and in spite of a totally different religious development preserved their version of the story of thei ancestors in tales and rituals (by the way, there are even tribes who trace their ancestors back through a fourth wife of Abraham's called Sabah linked with the name of that South Arabian country the queen of which had a diplomatic exchange with king Solomon). Thus, when the Qur'an refers to a story that is supposed to be known, it is mostly known from the Arab tradition. I will now try to ouline the story from this perspective.

The Qur'anic account begins with Abraham's search for God within an environment where heavenly bodies and other deities were worshipped.

(Remember,) how Abraham said to his father Azar: "Are you taking images for gods? Then I see you and your people in manifest error." So We showed Abraham the kingdom of the heavens and the earth so that he might be one of those who gain certainty. For when the night covered him, he saw a star. He said (to himself), "This might be my Sustainer." But when it set, he said, "I do not love those that set." When he then saw the moon spreading its light, he said (to himself), "This might be my Sustainer." But when it set (as well), he said, "If my Sustainer were not guiding me, I would be one of those who go astray." When he then saw the sun spreading its light, he said (to himself), "This might be my Sustainer. It is the greatest." But when it set (as well), he said, "Ma people, I am free from all that you associate with God. I turn my face towards Him who created the heavens and the earth, and I do not belong to the idol-worshippers." (Surah 6:75-79)

Consequently there is a conflict in the course of which Abraham decides to give an illustrating lesson to the polytheists in order to make them think.

And already We had given Abraham his inner guidance, for We knew him. (Remember) how he said to his father and his people, "What are those images you are subservient to?" They replied, "We found our ancestors serving them." He said, "You and your ancestors are in manifest error." They replied, "Are you bringing the truth, or are you mocking?" He said, "Rather your Sustainer is the Sustainer of the heavens and the earth who created them. I am one of those who testify for that. By God, I will turn against your idols when you have turned your backs." So he broke them to pieces except for the biggest one so that they could turn to it. They said, "Who has done that to our gods? He is certainly an evildoer." They said, "We heard a youngster talk about them. His name is Abraham." They said, "Then bring him in front of the people so that they witness." They asked, "Did you do this to our gods, Abraham?" He replied, "It must have been the biggest of them. Do ask them, if they can speak." So they turned to each other, saying, "You are certainly not right." And they had to hang down their heads in shame (admitting), "You do know that those do not speak." He said, "Do you then worship, besides God, things that can neither benefit nor harm you? Fie upon you and what you worship besides God! Do you not understand?" They said (among themselves), "Burn him and help your gods if you want to do something!" We said, "Fire, be cool and without any harm for Abraham!" They wished him evil, but We made them loosers, and we saved him and Lot to the land that We blessed for the worlds, and We gave him Isaac and moreover Jacob and made them all righteous. (Surah 21:51-72)

Abraham leaves his home and his father together with his wife Sarah and his nephew Lot, praying for forgiveness for his father and wishing him peace. There are several Arab accounts of his travels, and it is interesting that he is said to have travelled on the caravan route along the Western side of the Arab peninsula at least to Southern Hijaz or even Yemen. We also hear about a stay in Egypt including the episode where the king who takes Sarah for Abraham's sister claims her for himself but is kept away from her by a miracle until he understands the real situation. To make up for it, he gives Sarah a slave-girl.

This girl is said to have been a princess who was deeply impressed with Abraham's and Sarah's faith in the One God and volunteered in order to be able to leave the country with them. An indication for such an emigration is her name Hagar ("emigrant") with which she is known.

In the course of time, possibly in connection with Sarah's unfulfilled wish for children, Hagar becomes Abraham's second wife and the mother of his first son Ismail. This is the background of some of the rituals central to Islamic practice. Abraham leaves Hagar and Ismail who still is a baby in a barren valley on the Hijaz-road. Various reasons for this journey are mentioned in the traditions, but the main reason is seen in a command from God which is trustingly followed by Abraham. When the baby becomes thirsty, Hagar starts running between two hills to look for signs of water or help, worried and with prayers. Finally she discoveres in the very place where the baby had kicked his feet a well, and an angel comes to comfort and encourage her. After Abraham's return, that place where God's help was experienced in such a visible manner is marked with a black stone, and the story is remembered whenever people rest at this well and later on, when a settlement has grown around the well, whenever travellers arrive. The settlement started when Hagar and Ismail settled there. At the same time people felt that it was a sacred place. This is reflected in Abraham's long prayer in the Qur'an.

(Remember) how Abraham said, "My Sustainer, make this place a place of security and peace and protect me and my children from serving idols - my Sustainer, they have led many people astray. Now, whoever follows me belongs to me, and whoever rejects me - You are forgiving, merciful. Our Sustainer, I have settled part of my descendants in a barren valley near Your Sacred House, our Sustainer, so that they establish prayer. Therefore make the hearts of the people turn to them and provide them with fruits so that they may be grateful. Our Sustainer, You di know what we conceal and what we reveal - nothing is hidden from God, neither on earth nor in heaven. Praise be to God who granted me, despite my old age, Ismail and Isaac; my Sustainer does answer the prayer. My Sustainer, make me and my children establish prayer, our Sustainer, and answer my prayer. Our Sustainer, forgive me and my parents and the faithful on the day of reckoning." (Surah 14:35-41)

The pilgrimage ritual of running between the two hills of Safa and Marwa is there to remind of the experience of Mother Hagar who runs, worried but trusting in God, to and fro to serch for distant help that she then finds immediately lose to herself. All men and women who perform the pilgrimage until the present day get into the role of their spiritual ancestress and experience how they rune about in life in search of what can nourisch and sustain them while God is with them all along; after that they refresh themselves with water from the well of Zamzam which today gives enough water for millions of pilgrims. Both the story and the ritual were already in the lifetime of the Prophet Muhammad (s) a ne essential part of life in Mecca, self-evident enough not to be retold in the Qur'an once more.

Equally self-evident is the circumcision of boys that goes back to Abraham and Ismail and was and is practiced among all descendants of Abraham. It combines - at least from the Islamic perspective - both hygienic and ritual aspects.

But the pilgrimage rites also refer to other parts of the story of Abraham which, according to Arab tradition, is geographically linked with this place. As a human being who lives completely in God's presence with a pure heart, Abraham is seen as Khalîl Allah, God's Friend, and shows this in his unconditional trust during all tests of life, one of which is of a special importance for Muslims.

And We gave him the good news of a gentle son. When he was old enough to work with him, (Abraham) said, "My dear son, I have seen in a dream that I am to sacrifice you. Now see what your opinion is." He replied, "My father, do what you have been told. God willing you will find me patient." When both had surrendered and (Abraham) had laid (his son) down on his forehead, We called to him, "Abraham! You have already fulfilled your dream." Thus we recompense those who do good. And we replaced (the son) by a great sacrifice, and We preserved Abraham's reputation among later generations: Peace be with Abraham. Thus We recompense those who do good. He was one of Our faithful servants. And We gave him the good news of Isaac, a prophet, one of the peacemakers, and We blessed him and Isaac. among their descendants there are those who do good and those who are obviously unjust against themselves. (Surah 37:101-113)

This experience is referred to in the Festival of Sacrifice, the greatest Islamic festival. After the congregational festival prayer in the mortning, those who can afford it slaughter a sheep (or several individuals have part in a bigger animal, e.g. a cow) and share the meat: one third is for the poor who can thereby have part in the feast and eat meat at least once a year, one third is for friends and neighbours, and one third is for the members of one's own family. In the sermon that is held in that morning, the topic is usually the meaning of sacrifice. One aspect is to let go of something a person is attached to. This can only be meaningful, from an Islamic perspective, when it benefits others (like the meat that is shared with others). The readiness for sacrifice is tested: Abraham is confronted with the question whom he loves more, God or his own self personified in his son, a question many a human being has seen him/herself confronted with. But God does not demand human sacrifice as it is sometimes demanded by manmade idols (including modern idols like consumerism, progress or certain 'isms), and He does not demand self-sacrifice. Islâm does not mean self-destruction but Surrender to God, being at peace with God's will that says Yes to the human being as a creature, a surrender that leades to peace - salâm.

The Festifal of Sacrifice is a festival of joy and gratefulness. But also on personal occasions for special joy and gratefulness, e.g. the birth of a child, a passed exam, the recovery from a serious disease etc., a sheep is slaughtered if one can afford it, and the meat is distributed, often in connection with a meal. Nowadays many Muslims make use of the alternative possibility to send the equivalent in money to places where people are needy.

The Festival of Sacrifice is also a component of the Great Pilgrimage (Hajj). The logistic problems connected with the immense number of pilgrims who slaughter a sacrificial animal and the relatively small number of local poor people is nowadays solved by preserving the meat and taking it to areas where it can be used to feed the poor.

In the context of this story there is another tradition that is also remembered in a pilgrimage rite. When Abraham and his son were on their way to the place of sacrifice, the devil came and tried to dissuade them from what they were about to do, and they drove him away by throwing stones. The three places where this is said to have happened are nowadays marked with columns that are symbolically stoned by the pilgrims as an expression for the uninterrupted struggle against one's own bad inclinations incumbent on each and every human being.

The last sentences of the Qur'anic passage on the sacrifice and the fact that this story is specially connected with the pilgrimage to Mecca certainly leads to questions. Indeed, according to Arab tradition, Ismail is the son referre to in this passage. However, it is interesting to note that the name of the son in question does not occur in the Qur'an at all. From that we can conclude that, while it is only natural for the descendants of the two brothers to see each their own ancestor in this role, but this is neither the point necessary for an understanding of the story as the story of an existential human experience nor shoulc it be a reason for quarrel. In original Islamic thinking there is no claim to exclusivity. Both Ismail and Isaac are mentioned as prophetic figures, and Jacob, Joseph and his brothers, the tribes of the Children of Israel, Moses and Aaron etc. are expressedly mentioned as part of the history of God and human beings. However, the Qur'an does not follow one single tradition of experience but concentrates on God's unity behind the variety of humankind as well as the prophetic element which is doubtless present in Isaac, Jacob and some of their children and descendants all the way through to Zakary, John and Jesus but also in other branches of the family from which non-Biblical prophets like Hud and Salih originate including finally Muhammad (s) as well as in all other nations the prophets of which are recognized in the Qur'an. The Qur'an confirms the special role of the Children of Israel in history as a model for their neighbouring nations while at the same time pointing out God's loving care for all nations and generations of humankind as manifested in the teachers and messengers He raised among them.

On the other hand, even for biological descendants of Abraham the decisive point is the attitude and behaviour of the individual during his/her lifetime like faithfulness to the One God and ethical behaviour towards fellow human beings and fellow creatures. The Qur'an emphasizes again and again the immediate individual responsibility of the human being that is closely linked with his/her dignity and can even be the foundation of closer ties than mere physical kinship. Abraham's prayers as mentioned in the Qur'an show again and again how important spiritual kinship was for him.

And (remember) how Abraham was tested by his Sustainer through words which he followed; (thereupon) He said, "I am going to make you a model (Imam) for humankind." Abraham asked, "And what about my descendants?" He said, "My covenant does not include the unjust ones (among them)." Surah 2:124)

Here I would like to remind of the Bible where polytheism and disregard for God's commandments were seen as breaking the covenant with God and repeatedly criticized by the prophets. However, the possibility for repentance and forgiveness was of course left open. Polytheism and social injustice are exactly the main points of Qur'anic criticism against the pre-Islamic Arabs (except for those who had turned to Judaism or Christianity or the Hanifs who were in search of individual ways towards the One, remembering the faith of their ancestor Abraham).

Abraham's friendship with God is manifested outwardly in his concern for his fellow human beings and inwardly in his familiarity with God.

Our messengers came to Abraham with good news. They said, "Peace!" He replied, "Peace!", and he did not hesitate to bring a roasted calf. But when he saw that they did not stretch out their hands (to eat), he found it strange and was afraid. But they said, "Do not fear. We have been sent to Lot's people." And his wife stood there laughing, for We had promised her Isaak and after Isaac Jacob. She said, "Woe to me! Am I to bear a child, being an old woman and my husband an old man? This is an amazing thing!" They said, "Are you amazed at God's decision? God's mercy and His blessings rest on you, people of the household. He is praiseworthy, famous." Afer the fear had left Abraham and the good news had reached him, He debated with Us about Lot's people. Abraham was gentle, merciful, turned to (God). (Surah 11:70-75)

The story of the guests who are immediately presented with a roasted calf by Abraham finds its echo in numerous traditions telling us about his proverbial hospitality. Hospitality and generosity have always been among the highest values with the Arabs and got a new accent through Islam.

It is the closeness to God which lies at the basis for gratefulness and joy and therefore of generosity. Gratefulness for all that we experience as God's gifts is one of the main Qur'anic motives to serve God and a most important station on the mystical path of self-education that leads from repentance and patience through gratefulnes and other stations to the love for God. In the case of Abraham, closeness and familiarity are progressed to a point where he, after getting acquainted with God's intentions, overcomes his fears - including the fear to be alienated from his friend or to annoy Him - and starts to debate with God, literally negotiating the fate of the "Wicked Cities" with Him even though the people have transgressed all limits and would not even be interested in his intercession.

A similar closeness and familiarity can be felt when Sarah laughs at the news that is too good to be true, just as one laughs at a good friend's joke. Except that in this case it is God's serious intention to grant her, despite her old age, the son she had been longing for, together with an outlook on later generations. Thus both Sarah and Hagar, each in their own way, become witnesses for God as opening new ways and possibilities where everything had seemed to be closed.

Finally the Qur'an refers to the construction of the Ka'ba as the first house of prayer for humankind dedicated to the One God. Being a simple empty building, it is seen as a symbol for the human heart, not only because it is the heart of the Muslim word, the Muslim community standing up in a worldwide circle around it during prayer, but also exactly because it is empty, that is, free of idols, just as the individual's heart should be empty in order to become "God's house. The circambulation of the Ka'ba is one of the pilgrimage rites that should make us aware of the fact that not the ego is in the centre but God with whom our hearts are linked, and that we are parts of an manyfold humanity searching for paths into His presence.

And (remember) how We made (God's) House a place of assembly and a place of security and peace for human beings: "Take the Abraham's position as a position of prayer." And We told Abraham and Ismail, "Purify My house for those who circambulate it, who withdraw there for meditation and who bow and prostrate (in prayer)." And (remember) how Abraham said, "My Sustainer, make this a place of security and peace and provide those of its inhabitants who believe in God and the Last Day with fruits." He replied, "I will also give something to those who deny, for temporary use, but then I will let him reach the pain of the fire - an evil destination." And (remember) how Abraham and Ismail constructed the fundaments of the House, (saying,) "Our Sustainer, accept this from us. You are the Hearing, the Knowing. Our Sustainer, make both of us surrender to you, and make our descendants a community surrendering to you and show us our ways of worship and turn to us. You are the Turning, the Merciful. Our Sustainer, raise among them a messenger from among themselves to explain Your signs to them and to teach them the Scripture and Wisdom and to purify them. You are the Mighty Friend, the Wise." And who would turn away from the attitude of Abraham except someone who deceives himself? We have chosen him already in this world, and in the life to come, he will be one of the just ones. (Surah 2:125-126)

The black stone that hat marked the place where Hagar's prayer was answered and she and Ismail was given a provision for life was put into one corner of the Ka'ba, and when pilgrims kiss and touch it, it is like being in touch with all those human beings who touched it before, all the way back to Abraham, Hagar and Ismail. The circambulation is then finished with a prayer at the place where Abraham is said to have stood and prayed. But beyond this, Abraham's Position is an attitude of the heart from which we are to bring our prayers before God.

We have already seen how important it is for Abraham to include his descendants into his close relationship with God. Surrendering to God, in Arabic, is muslim, and this is exactly the word used in the text when it says, "Make both of us surrender to You, and make our descendants (lit. "the descendants of both of us", dual) a community surrendering to You." Islâm in its literal meaning is an attitude, independant of formal membership on a religious community, a potential that drives human beings (and, by the way, other creatures as well) to live in harmony with God and His creation, but often disregarded by a human being for selfish reasons. The teachings of the religions, from the Qur'anic perspective, now show us ways to overcome this selfishness and to make peace with God. The Qur'an confirms definitely that the teachings of other religions, especially those of the Abrahamic tradition that are accesiible in the Bible, originate in a genuine divine revelation and with a genuine prophetic teacher, among many others Moses and Jesus who are, together with Noah, Abraham and Muhammad, among God's most important messengers. The crtitcal Qur'anic approach on certain points of the doctrine and practice within the Jewish and Christian communinties correspond, on on the whole, to the critical attitude of the Biblical prophets, especially where polytheism and social injustice are concerned, while the communities themselves are recognized and invited for dialogue and constructive cooperation, while the responsibility for their matters liew with them on the basis of their own revealed values. Besides, this criticism is meant as a mirror for the Muslim community.

Abraham's and Ismail's request for a prophetic teacher for their descendants can, in retrospect, be referred to the Prophet Muhammad (s) who was raised among the Children of Ismail in the tribe of Quraish in order to confront the religious and social evils of his time and to remind people of the One God, starting from his native city Mecca but with a further perspective. It was certainly not his intention to found a new religious community on top of the many already existing ones the disunity between which is criticised in the Qur'an but to remind of essential aspects that can bridge differences and make a constructive coexistence in variety possible. When we read the Qur'an in the chronological sequence of its revelation, we find that this perspective is followed even after it has become obvious, in Medina, that the community of the Prophet (s) does have to organize itself as an independent religious community and struggle for its identity, and after conflicts with the Jewish tribes within the city that could hardly be bridged as well as threats from the side of the (Christian) military forces of Byzantium. The basic idea of coexistence in variety where variety is used for a constructive competition for the implementation of good values has made it possible, despite all tensions and conflicts, that Jewish and Christian groups within the classical Islamic empire could unfold their religious, social and cultural life (it is only recently that this basic idea seems to be pushed into the background, but this imlies pushing an essential aspect of Islam into the background).

In this context, the experience of Abraham and his family members is used in the Qur'an to show a perspective beyond the existing differences and disputes, a perspective of what really matters:

It will neither be according to your wishes nor according to the wishes of the People of the Scripture. Whoever does evil will be taken to account, and he will find neither friend nor helper besides God. But whoever does good, man or woman, and is faithful - they will enter the garden and not suffer the slightest bit of injustice. And who has a more beautiful religion than a person who surrenders to God, does good and follows the attitude of Abraham the Sincere? And God took Abraham for His friend. (Surah 4:123-125)

Back to Islamic Studies Index
Home Page 1