Mishnah - Instruction
Scholar People: This law means that soldiers cannot take over a privite residence without the owner saying it's ok. Wether they are in war or not. The purpose of this law is to stop soldiers from taking advantage of other people. To explain this method to a young child tell them of how they would feel if a relative came to visit and they were forced to share a room with them. Now this relative is rude and hateful, but you can't say anything to your parents, so you put up with. This law stops soldiers from putting people through that kind of experience. It gives the people a right to say "No". Scholar Dig: This law means that no soldier has the right to force himself into anyones house without the owners consent. He cannot do this in time of war, unless law prescribes otherwise, and peace. The purpose of this law is to aid in the establishment of civil rights. This law also protects the privacy of a citizen from infringement. No one has the right to force themselves into your house without your permission. The stipulation being under special wartime situations. |
![]() |
Gemara - Completion
Scholar Super People: The common people have the right to deny a should when peace is present. During times of war, the commoner has no choice. The Mishnah scholars covered amendment III completely. An example of how we could use the law today would be if Canada were to invade Montana, and the U.S> sent soldiers to gaurd the border, and asked the people living on the Montana/Canada border, to allow soldiers to stay in their houses, they could say no. Scholar Bills: Amendment III means that in times of peace our homes are truly our sanctuarys and nothing will change that. The Mishnah scholars left out that soldiers cannot force civillians to let them live in their homes in time of peace. For an examplel, if a soldier said, "Let me bed down in yo' crib G." during peace time you could say, "No way buck-o!" |