Reviewed by Arlo Vinchenzi, Imperial Pain Technician
Click HERE, HERE, HERE to see pictures from the episode.
Well, this was a VERY simple episode. Sure, it was artsy,
intellectual, had a good point to make and really made it,
but in the end, the plot can be summed up as thus:
Captain Sheridan is tortured and interrogated.
That's it.
Really.
The first time I saw this episode, I was like, "Okay, this
is all fine and dandy, I get the picture, they're torturing
him, like I didn't know that already, now can we PLEASE go
somewhere ELSE? Cut to the station, cut to the fleet,
heck, cut to the Festival of G'Quan on Narn, I don't CARE,
just CHANGE THE FRAGGING SCENERY!"
I'm not sure if Straczynski was trying to make US feel the
same disconnected, unending, trapped hopelessness that
Sheridan was feeling, but in general it's not a good idea
to torture your AUDIENCE!
The second time, however, knowing ahead of time that it was
going to be like that, I got a bit more out of it. I got
the "1984" references (a wonderful primer for those in...my
line of work...), I liked the performance that Wayne
Alexander put on as the "doomed" Drazi (a wonderful bit of
irony--he ALSO played the INQUISITOR in the Season Two
episode "Comes the Inquisitor"! yikes.), and there are
some good lines that I did not remember from the first
time:
Interrogator: "You've been interrogated before?"
Sheridan: "Yes."
Interrogator: "Anyone I know?"
Or...
Sheridan: "You CAN fight the system!"
Interrogator: "But can you win?"
Sheridan: "Every time I say...NO."
(LOVE that line!)
There were some delightfully scary things in it, too. Such
as: using his father to control him, how he has to be
REALLY broken, for real, in his mind, in case he gets
scanned, how they will kill him afterwards, when no-one
cares, in the night, and of course the ending. He keeps
hearing about this "Room 17" (a "1984" reference), where
prisoners die, and when he is finally dragged off there,
after ALL this hoo-ha--tears, prayers, shaking voices, a
stretcher and everything--
--it turns out to be EXACTLY the same type of room! Just
the interrogator has changed. He starts asking exactly the
same questions.
And so it continues...
Click HERE to return to the
main Season Four Reviews page.