Take 2 - An Alternate Part 29

by Poly





Disclaimer: Not mine. Whatever isn't CC's, it's Cadillac Red's.

Spoilers: Some references to X-files mythology episodes.

Rating: PG. Discipline, no slash.

E-mail: poly.gianniba@tesco.net

Author's note: The Take 2 series have been an immense pleasure for me the last few months, always waiting for a new chapter to appear in my mailbox. The characters and their relationships were so rich and struck so many chords in me that I always had a million ideas and thoughts about the story. Trying my hands in writing a chapter in these wonderful series was not far behind and this is my first effort. Now, that the series are over, maybe this is a small consolation. A heartfelt thanks to Rachelle for letting me play in her backyard, for beta-reading and general hand-holding.

Summary: The story is an alternate chapter 29. It picks up immediately after a fourteen year old Fox ran away to his mother's house in Greenwich, believing that he had a better father and life there and being very disappointed. He earns his first punishment tour, but the crisis is far from over.



The week started ordinarily enough. Fox had some trouble getting up in the morning and was a little subdued most of the evening, but Skinner thought nothing of it. The boy had a night's sleep to make up for and that was reason enough for his less than energetic behavior. He did his chores meticulously though and he accepted his bedtime spanking without so much as a comment. Skinner found that a little strange, but he wasn't about to question his good fate. He still felt emotionally drained after the weekend and he didn't want to fight Fox more than he had to.

Looking back, Skinner felt that he should have known. But the following days were similarly unremarkable, only one incident standing out in Skinner's mind. On Tuesday when Skinner went to pick up Fox from school, he saw him talking with Max Hanes, a senior student and the school's most prominent bully. He and Fox had come to blows in the past when Max had tried to pick on some kids in Fox's presence. Fox's sense of justice had kicked in and a full-scale fight had been threatened until a teacher had separated them. Naturally, when Skinner saw them talking this time, he feared the worse, but the two kids parted amicably.

When Skinner asked Fox about it, Fox was as non-committal as ever.

"We were just talking, Dad. Just talking".



The safe house
McLean, Virginia
Thursday morning

"Fox, get up. You will be late for school".

This was the third time Walter Skinner was trying to rouse Fox and his impatience was evident in his voice. The boy was still under the covers and he had barely acknowledged his father's voice.

Skinner entered the room and approached the bed.

"Fox, we are running awfully late".

Fox picked his head under the covers.

"Dad, I can't go to school today".

Skinner sat on the bed and felt for the boy's forehead.

"Are you feeling sick?"

The boy's skin was cool and he didn't seem otherwise ill.

"No, Dad, but I can't go to school today. Please, don't ask me to explain".

Skinner was puzzled.

"Can't you tell me why?"

"No, Dad, but you have to believe me, it's really, really important. Please."

There was an urgency in the boy's demeanor that alarmed the AD. He spoke quietly and tried to calm the boy.

"Fox, you know you can tell me everything, don't you?"

The boy hardly heard the question, his voice rising to a high pitch.

"Please, Dad, don't make me go to school today". The boy was pleading in earnest now and his eyes started to well up.

Skinner had never seen Fox like this. The boy never had any trouble keeping up at school and he always relished the opportunity to socialize with the other kids. The school for him had been a very enjoyable experience.

Skinner was genuinely concerned now.

"Fox, what's wrong? Something has been bothering you. What is it, son?"

All of a sudden tongue-tied, Fox was looking at him with huge eyes. His expression was that of barely suppressed fear and was seemingly unable to utter a word.

"Fox, please, you are scaring me".

All of a sudden, the boy's expression shifted. He slowly closed his eyes and, when he opened them again, his eyes betrayed a deep resignation.

"It's OK, Dad. Nothing is wrong. I am sorry I upset you".

His words lacked any real emotion and he moved to get out of the bed. Skinner was taken aback from the sudden change, but he recovered quickly. Somehow, the resigned acceptance in Fox's behavior worried him more than his obvious agitation a few minutes earlier and he was at a loss.

"Fox, tell me what's on your mind, please".

The boy, who in the meantime was busy finding his clothes and getting ready for school, stopped abruptly and turned to look at his father.

"It's all right, Dad. I really have to go to school today. It was nothing. A bad dream".

He smiled a tentative smile and that dispelled some of Skinner's worries. Skinner got up and took the boy in his arms.

"Hurry up. We are running late".

He never noticed that Fox returned the hug a little too fiercely.



On the way to Alexandria
Thursday afternoon

Twice in a week

The same thought kept coming in his head and he couldn't shake it away. Walter Skinner gripped the steering wheel and tried to keep his mind on the road. But it wasn't an easy task and he was thankful that the traffic was light and driving didn't take as much effort. It was a little past lunch hour and most people in DC were busy working. As he would be if he hadn't received a phone call half an hour earlier from Alexandria's police department to come and pick up "a certain Fox Mulder".

Skinner's mind was still reeling from the conversation on the phone. Fox was picked up along with Max Hanes and two other kids shoplifting in one of the biggest computer megastores in Alexandria. The boy hadn't stolen anything himself, but he was with the other three boys who had tried to steal several items each.

It didn't make sense. These actions weren't like Fox at all. And not only the actions, but the company he kept as well. Fox despised Max, he had said so more than once. Max reveled in hurting people and Fox, always sweet and gentle and very conscious of other people's feelings, hated that.

v Skinner rubbed his hand over his face. He was less than five minutes from the police station and he was as confused as when he first received the telephone call.



The intense sense of déjà vu he had entering the police station didn't improve his mood. The desk sergeant remembered him all too well and his reproachful look made it very clear what he thought of his parenting skills. Skinner gritted his teeth and tried to focus on the important things. He wanted to know what was going on in that kid's mind and the rest of the world could be damned.

In a couple of minutes, Fox appeared escorted by a policeman. He had the sense to look ashamed and he never lifted his eyes from the floor the whole time they stayed in the police station. Since Fox hadn't stolen anything himself, there were no charges and he was released after a brief confirmation procedure.

The ride home was silent. Fox was looking out the window and had not once met his father's eyes. Skinner didn't trust himself to remain calm discussing the matter and he resolved to wait until they got home. At least then, he wouldn't have to worry about driving.

Once they got home, Fox tried to run up the stairs and lock himself in his room, but he wasn't fast enough. Skinner grabbed his hand and stopped him. They were definitely in a time loop or something.

"We need to talk".

Fox was looking down, biting his lip, and he was barely holding back the tears.

"What's happening, Fox? Why were you there?"

Fox didn't say anything, he was hardly breathing.

"Did you know that this was going to happen?"

More silence.

"I don't understand, Fox".

The boy suddenly exploded.

"There is nothing to understand. I am getting punished already. I can't get in any more trouble. I felt like it, that's why".

"You don't think I can punish you more?"

"I don't care. Nothing is going to change anyway. I am not scared to be punished and that's that."

For the first time this afternoon, the boy was looking Skinner in the eyes and the AD was taken aback by what he saw there. There was a desperation and a hopelessness he had never seen in the boy before. He instinctively moved to envelop the boy in his arms, but Fox moved out of reach and ran up to his room, slamming the door.

The phone started ringing that same moment and Skinner cursed under his breath.

"Skinner". His voice wasn't exactly normal, but it could pass as human, which was a small miracle in itself.

"Walter, it's me, Fiona".

As usual, the warmth of her voice lifted some of the heaviness in his heart and sighed with relief.

"Hi".

"The police called the school as well. Is he all right?"

"Frankly, I don't know. This is so out of character for him."

"I know. Are you all right?"

"Well, I am better now".

She chuckled, but then grew serious again.

"I am afraid this isn't strictly a social call. Since it happened during school time, we are forced to suspend all four kids for the next two days. I know Fox didn't do anything..."

Skinner interrupted her.

"He did enough. He cut school and he knew what was going down. He isn't that innocent, I am afraid."

"Nevertheless, as you said, this is so out of character that I hate to do this to him. More than anything else, it's the humiliation of everyone else knowing".

"He must face up to his actions. And yes, the humiliation will hurt him more than anything else."

"Take care of him, Walter."

"I will, Fiona, I promise".

"And then, we'll have to find someone to take care of you".

Skinner broke into a soft laugh.

"Do you have anyone in mind?"

"If I think hard enough..."

"Oh, I always said that you could do anything if you set your mind to it".

"Wait and see, Walter Skinner, wait and see".

And with that she hung up the phone.



Walter Skinner hoped that things would improve, but he was sorely disappointed. He tried to talk to Fox at various moments the rest of the day, but the boy remained resolutely silent. At bedtime, the boy recited his transgressions - old and new - and received his punishment with a detachment that scared the AD. Punishment was always a very emotional experience for Fox, an opportunity for reassurance and a new beginning, but this time Fox accepted everything with silent resignation. And although Skinner refused to let him go without a hug in the end, even that seemed impersonal and cold. Walter Skinner slept with a very heavy heart that night.

Friday was an equally difficult day. Skinner didn't want to leave the boy alone in the house, so he had called his parents the previous day and asked them for their help. Mr. and Mrs. Skinner were more than happy to come and visit for a couple of days, but Skinner felt that it was a lot to ask anyway. They had arrived late the previous night and they hadn't seen Fox at all. Skinner, for his part, didn't want them to have to deal with a sullen teenager, so when Fox indicated that he would stay in his room all day, his father was more than happy to accommodate him.

"Fox, I am very serious about this, I don't want you to upset them. No matter how we deal with things between us, Gran and Gram are to stay out of it. Do I make myself clear?"

Fox nodded. He wanted to reassure his father, that he was to be trusted in such a serious matter, but the truth was he wasn't sure he deserved that kind of trust. Maybe he didn't deserve anything anymore.



The safe house
McLean, Virginia
Saturday morning

Fox got down the stairs at nine o' clock. Although he was at his bedroom for the last twelve hours, supposedly sound asleep from nine o' clock on Friday evening, he didn't look well rested. He had black circles under his eyes and his cheeks had started to look hollow. He looked tired and weary and his mood certainly didn't improve when he entered the kitchen and saw his father and grandparents already there.

"Good morning, Foksik", his grandfather spoke first, not letting any of his worries color his voice. He and Walter had a long talk that morning and he couldn't make sense of the boy's behaviour more than Walter could.

"Good morning" Fox all but mumbled and he tried to avoid the stares of the three people in the room.

"You must be hungry" his grandmother said "and, even if you aren't, the smell of the pancakes will certainly bring back your appetite".

"I am not that hungry" Fox mumbled and looked wearily at his father. "I'll only have some orange juice".

"Fox, you hardly touched your food last night. Besides, Gram made the special blueberry syrup you like so much".

"I said, I am not hungry". Fox's voice rose and suddenly his stare took a steely look, so unlike his sweet nature. "And besides", now his words were slow and deliberate, having lost any uncertainty, "I don't like blueberry syrup at all. I just pretended I did not to hurt your feelings. In fact, I don't like many things. But I have to be polite and smile and be well behaved, and you never know what I really think. In fact, I don't much like you." He fixed his grandparents with an unwavering stare and stormed out of the room.

For a couple of minutes, the three adults stared speechless and it took them a while to recover. Skinner tried to clear his throat and be sensible.

"Mom, dad, he doesn't mean it".

"Walter, you don't need to apologize, we know he doesn't. Now, go find that boy," his father said.

"Yeah" Skinner said, somewhat lost, and got up to leave the room.

His mother took two steps and enveloped him in her arms.

"That boy hurts, Walter. Please make it stop".

"I'll try, mom. But I don't know if I can".

"You can, Walter. Trust me on this. When that boy is concerned, you can do anything".

Skinner looked at his mother and tried to decipher her words. In the end, he just smiled, hugged her harder and said:

"Thanks, mom. I needed that."



Skinner knocked on the door and waited for an answer. When none was forthcoming, he opened it and stepped inside. Fox was seated on the bed, staring at his hands in his lap. Something had changed from the last couple of days. All the defiance and stubbornness had gone out of him and something inside the child had broken. Skinner couldn't remember seeing him more miserable.

"Fox". Skinner waited for a sign of acknowledgement, but Fox didn't even look up.

Skinner took a couple of steps forward and Fox stiffened.

"Dad, I..." the boy trailed off.

"I know, you didn't mean it".

Obviously, that was the wrong thing to say, because Fox's anger flared again.

"Maybe I did. Why do you always have to finish my sentences? Why do you always have to know what I am thinking?"

The anger disappeared as quickly as it had come.

"I know you didn't mean it. If you did, you aren't the person I think you are".

Fox flinched visibly and, if it was possible, looked more miserable than before. Skinner was at a loss as to how to continue. Finally, he added:

"Look, I am not going to punish you".

Fox's eyes went wide.

"You aren't?"

"No, not before..."

"But you have to". Fox cut him off. "I was disrespectful and rude and mean. I tried to hurt them and I tried to hurt you. I can't be forgiven".

Now Fox was on his feet and walking the room.

"Gran and Gram have already forgiven you and so have I. But that's not why I don't want to punish you."

Fox had stopped walking and stared at his father with tears in his eyes.

"Why?"

"I really need to know why you did it".

"Not why you don't want to punish me." The boy's voice rose to a panicked pitch. "Why have you forgiven me?"

The boy was so miserable and Skinner felt his own eyes burning. He wanted nothing more than to take the misery away. He sat on the bed and said quietly.

"Fox, please, come here".

The boy didn't even think about resisting. He sat next to his father but didn't dare look at him.

"Fox, look at me".

The boy tentatively raised his eyes and Skinner took the boy's shoulders in his hands.

"Fox, I want you to pay attention, because what I am going to say is very important, more important than anything I have said to you".

Fox nodded, but his face was still a mask of misery.

"I forgave you because I love you. I always forgive you. The moment you do something wrong I have already forgiven you. I don't punish you to fix something between us, because nothing ever needs fixing. I love you, always. When you are good, I love you, and, when" Skinner smiled "you aren't so good, I still love you, just as much. You are the smartest, sweetest kid and I feel truly blessed that you are my kid. I punish you because I know you can be better sometimes. Sometimes I know that you are better than you think you are".

Fox had started crying softly and his words were merely a whisper.

"What if you are wrong? What if you are wrong and my other father was right?"

"What?"

"My other father didn't love me as much. Mom told me. Maybe I was a rotten kid and that's why he didn't love me. You said yourself that I look more and more like my old self. What if I become like I was, really rotten and mean, and you don't love me any more?"

Fox was looking at Skinner with huge eyes and Skinner felt like the world depended on his answer. Maybe not the whole world, but this little boy's world for sure. And for Skinner that was even more important.

"Fox, do you trust my judgement?"

"What do you mean?"

"Like, if I say that someone is a good person, you know he is."

Fox nodded.

"Remember I told you that I knew you very well before? Maybe I haven't told you that you were one of my best friends. That you were honest and honorable and the most caring individual I know. You weren't rotten. You couldn't be rotten if you tried."

Fox's eyes flooded once more and he hugged Skinner fiercely.

"Then, why didn't my other dad love me?"

Fox's plea was so heartbreaking and it occurred to Skinner that that sorry excuse for a father was hurting his boy again, even in this second childhood. He wanted to punch somebody. Instead he enveloped Fox in his arms, trying to soothe the pain away.

"I don't know, sweetheart. Of all the crazy things that happened, this is the craziest."

Fox cried for a long time, releasing all the anxiety and fear of the last few days. Skinner held him, cried with him, tried to comfort the boy and be comforted himself. Fox's misery had affected him in the most profound way. Nothing was more important to him than this boy's happiness.

After a while, Skinner asked:

"Fox?"

"Yes?"

"Why you were with Max that day?"

Fox went still for a minute, but then relaxed somewhat and started talking.

"I wanted to see if I was like him, mean and a really bad person. I knew what they were going to do that day and I wanted to see if I was like them".

"And are you?"

"I don't think so", Fox all but whispered. "But I don't think they are really bad either. They just want someone to take notice".

Fox went quiet but he didn't let go and Skinner smiled. Trust Fox to see the good in people even when it was very well hidden. He felt a wave of pride and kissed the boy's hair. How did he get so lucky?

Fox was drifting and it wasn't hard to know why. Skinner doubted he had any restful sleep last night and the way the boy was fading was evidence of that.

"Fox, you need some sleep".

"No". Fox's head shot back and Skinner could see a stubborn trace of anxiety in his face.

"Fox, please, not now".

"I will sleep, but I need to tell you something first".

Fox told Skinner all about last Wednesday. As it turned out, Fox had lied, skipped school and swim practice that day and had hitched a ride to DC to go and visit his old apartment. He had found his way to Alexandria and his old apartment, stayed a couple of hours and then made his way back home. He told Skinner how he wanted to find if he was anything like his old self and how he looked for evidence there.

Skinner tried to stay calm, although his heart was racing with all the things that could have happened to Fox. In the end, he asked quietly:

"Did you find what you were looking for?"

Fox shrugged.

"I don't know. We support the same team and I like some of the books there. But I already knew that. I really can't tell."

"Believe me, Fox. You look more like him with each passing day. And this is actually a good thing. A very good thing. Now, time for you to get some rest."

Skinner helped Fox into bed and bent to kiss him on the forehead.

"Dad?"

"Yes?"

"Am I in trouble?"

"You know you are, but you need some sleep first."

Fox smiled a satisfied smile and Skinner thought that it was weird his son was smiling at the mention of punishment. Sometimes things have a funny way of working out.

"Dad?"

"What is it now?"

"I found some tapes in my old apartment."

"Don't go there, kid, just don't go there."



Four hours later, Fox made his way down the stairs, the second time that morning. He strained his ears to hear where everyone was, but he could hear nothing. Finally, he heard a rustling sound from the kitchen and he moved towards it.

His grandmother was reading the newspaper on the kitchen table and she lifted her eyes when she sensed his presence.

"That's more like it", she said as she rose to meet him. Fox had the sweet air of the newly awakened and well rested. He took two steps and fell into her arms, crying softly.

"I am sorry. I am so sorry. I didn't mean it. I don't know why I wanted to hurt you". He sobbed over and over again.

"I know, sweet boy, I know. You didn't hurt me. Seeing you unhappy, that was what really hurt".

He clung to her, trying to communicate his remorse and she hugged him back, showing him that everything was all right between them. She loved Fox Mulder when he was a grown man, but nothing could prepare her for the fierce protectiveness and love she had for that boy.

Finally, Fox lifted his head and gave her a tearful smile.

"I am not unhappy now" and he offered her one of his brilliant smiles.

"You really know the way to an old woman's heart" she teased and kissed his last tears away.

At that very moment, Fox's empty stomach growled and he laughed embarrassed.

"The best sound in the world." It was her turn to laugh and push the boy to his feet.

"I am going to reheat lunch. It will only take a minute".

"Gram?" Fox stopped embarrassed.

"What is it, sweetheart?"

"Can I have the pancakes?"

Mrs. Skinner laughed heartily and gave him a peck on the chick.

"I will get to them right away. But don't tell your father I indulged you. It will be our little secret".

Fox looked mortified.

"I don't want to lie to him" and his voice held genuine regret.

For all his intelligence and brilliance, Fox was often much more innocent than other boys his age. Mrs. Skinner shook her head.

"Oh, Fox, I am only teasing. Of course, I don't want you to lie. Besides, you are a terrible liar. You always were."

Fox flushed a bright red and asked her:
"You mean, before too?"

"Yeah, before too."

An uneasy silence fell as Fox started to lose himself in thought and Mrs. Skinner nudged him.

"Pour some milk while I make the pancakes. And Fox," she stopped, trying to find the right words and not embarrass him, "do you need to bring one of the cushioned chairs from the living room?"

"Oh no, dad hasn't punished me yet", he replied, all too cheerfully for the subject matter. "But he will", he continued at the same confident tone of voice.

"Oh, all right". Mrs. Skinner tried to hide her surprise. Miracles never cease.

"Where are dad and Gran anyway?" he asked pouring some milk.

"They went for a walk after lunch, they will be back any minute now."

He started eating and not two minutes later, his father and grandfather entered from the patio door to the kitchen.

"Oh, you are up" his grandfather said and bent to kiss him.

Fox swallowed a mouthful and rose to hug his Gran.

"I am sorry about earlier" and he tried to hold back the tears, not quite pulling it off. "I don't know why I did it, but I am really, really sorry".

"It's all right, son. I know something was bothering you and I am glad it doesn't anymore. But I want you to know that we all love you very, very much, and if something makes you unhappy, you should talk to us. There is nothing we wouldn't do for you."

"I know, Gran, I know. Sorry I forgot." Fox felt relieved, like a huge weight had lifted from his heart. Next to his father's, his grandfather's approval meant the most to him and he couldn't bear the thought that he had upset him.

For his part, Walter Skinner Sr. was glad that somebody else had to administer the discipline and keep this boy in line. It tugged at his heart to see this boy crying and he wasn't sure that he would be able to do right by him. Maybe he was getting soft in his old age.

In the meantime, Skinner eyed Fox's plate and raised an eyebrow to look at his mother. But she stared back challenging him to question her decision. He thought better of it and he realized that he couldn't take her up on it. He lowered his eyes and tugged his father by the sleeve.

"Let's go to the living room and leave the boy to eat".

In five minutes, Fox had finished, did the dishes and started hovering in the living room. Skinner kept talking with his father and pretended that he hadn't noticed Fox hopping around. He knew what was in the boy's mind and an evil streak made him want to let the boy sweat a little. But Fox really couldn't take it much longer.

"Dad, can I talk to you upstairs for a while?" he said as nonchalantly as possible.

Skinner looked up to see the boy's face barely concealing his anxiety. He felt a pang of guilt and berated himself for his selfishness. He wasn't looking forward to the punishment, but that was no reason for dragging out Fox's ordeal. His eyes took on the most kind expression.

"Sure, Fox, I will be up in a second."

Fox ran up the stairs and Skinner rose facing his father.

"I really hate this".

"I know, but in a strange way, Fox counts on you. He needs to know that you will make him face his responsibilities."

"Yeah. Well, better not keep him waiting any longer".

Skinner started for the stairs, but his father's voice stopped him.

"Walter, it will work out, you'll see".

Skinner gave his father a small smile.

"Thanks, dad".



Skinner found Fox at exact the same spot he had found him this morning, seated on the bed, head bowed. But the boy had an air of serenity about him that he lacked for days. He looked up and smiled at his father.

"I am not good at waiting, I guess", he said without preamble and got up.

"I know, I am sorry I kept you waiting".

Skinner moved to the bed and Fox started feeling a familiar twist at his stomach. But before he had any more time to think about it, Skinner spoke again.

"Fox, come here and sit down for a second".

The boy sensed that something was different from all the other times and he did as his father said without question.

Skinner hesitated for a second, didn't know quite what to say and then started talking following his instinct and his instinct alone.

"Fox, I need your help".

Fox's eyes widened.

"Well, it's not the first time and you usually help me without even realizing it, but today I need your help more than usual."

A million questions passed in Fox's eyes, but Skinner chose to answer only the most important of them.

"You are such an easy person to love, Fox. I didn't know how to be a parent, but you helped and guided me and I can honestly say that this is the most rewarding experience of my life".

Fox started to tear up.

"How can you say that? I always worry you and upset you and make you angry".

Skinner hugged the boy and kissed his head.

"You do worry me sometimes, but only because I love you so much. And for me, the most important thing of all is for you to be safe and become the wonderful person I know you really are. I need your help, son. I need to know that when I punish you, you really learn something. Punishment is no good if it doesn't help you next time to do the right thing."

Now, Fox was crying openly.

"I don't mean to worry you, dad. But sometimes, I don't think. Punishment really hurts and I don't like it, but I want to own up to my mistakes. I want you to be proud of me and you wouldn't be proud otherwise. And" the boy stopped and lowered his head, "seeing you sad, it's worse than any punishment".

Skinner felt his throat tighten and for a moment he couldn't find his voice. He took a deep breath and the boy's face in his hands, looking him in the eyes.

"I am always proud of you, remember that. And to show you that I really trust you to face your responsibilities, I will let you choose your punishment. Whatever you say it goes."

Fox was stunned for a second. He felt his heart racing and he tried to think through all the implications. He could get away with it, but he knew he deserved to be punished. His actions had consequences and something was terribly wrong with the world if he wouldn't face them.

Skinner was waiting patiently, looking the range of emotions on his son's face. He knew the boy was struggling inside and he was almost surprised on how quickly he came to a decision.

"I know I have been very bad. I lied to you and ran off to Alexandria and put myself in danger. And I know how serious that is. So, I really deserve fifty licks with the Persuader and a punishment tour."

Skinner drew a sudden breath.

"And I really mouthed off this morning, trying to hurt Gram and Gran". Fox stopped for a second, overwhelmed with the memory and the emotions. "So another fifty licks seems appropriate".

Skinner shook his head. Some things never change.

"You always were too hard on yourself. Lying and putting yourself in danger are very serious offences, but you told me about it yourself and that should count for something. So I will give you fifty bare-hand spankings. As for this morning, you were upset and distressed, so I think I should go easy on you."

"That's no excuse" Fox interrupted with indignation. "I really tried to hurt Gram and Gran, and that is inexcusable. You shouldn't hurt people who love you. You shouldn't hurt anyone," he finished in a quieter voice.

Skinner felt himself overwhelmed with pride. The boy had a heart of gold and he really couldn't take credit for that. But he felt proud nevertheless.

"You are right and I am really glad you feel this way. I am even glad that you are hard on yourself. It means that every lesson is sinking in. But I don't want to be hard on you. Do me this favor, will you?"

Fox looked at him with wide, solemn eyes and nodded. He got up and without any reluctance, he pushed his jeans and shorts down and positioned himself over his father lap. Fox was growing fast and the position was getting more awkward every day, but Skinner managed a good grip on the boy.

"Since we discussed what this punishment is about, you don't have to repeat it now. I am going to give you sixty smacks. You don't have to count, but it might help you focus your mind".

Fox nodded, but he kept silent, steeling himself.

Skinner brought his hand down on the boy's bottom and Fox yelped more from surprise than anything else. Skinner picked up a rhythm and kept going, counting the blows out loud. He wasn't hitting really hard, he had delivered much more severe spankings, but today his heart wasn't in it. He somehow knew that whatever lesson Fox had learned that day, he had learned it long before the spanking. The boy had made some good decisions and Skinner didn't feel like punishing him for them.

Fox, on the other hand, was biting his lip and waiting for the harder blows to come. When Skinner reached thirty and hadn't picked up force, Fox started crying softly. It suddenly dawned on him how much Skinner hated punishing him and how he was responsible for Skinner being unhappy once more. He lost himself in his misery and he didn't even realize when Skinner finished. He didn't attempt moving and Skinner started to feel a little anxious.

"Come on, son" he said pulling Fox in his arms. "I wasn't even hitting you that hard".

Fox cried harder and buried himself in his father's embrace.

"I know. I am sorry, I am so sorry. I know how you hate it and I am sorry you have to punish me so much."

Skinner smiled. Only Fox would think apologizing for something like that.

"It's OK, son. It's over now, for you and me."

Gradually, Fox quieted down. He raised his head and looked at his father.

"I am going to be good. You won't have to punish me again, I promise."

Skinner knew that Fox wouldn't be able to keep that promise. He also knew that he had every intention to try. He kissed his son and said:

"I know you will try. I have every faith in you. Now, go wash your face."

Fox went to the bathroom and after a while he came out with a towel drying his face.

"Dad?"

"Yeah?"

"Do you miss him?"

"Who?"

"Me, from before. You said we were friends".

Skinner didn't think of lying.

"Sometimes."

The boy looked sad.

"I am sorry".

Skinner got up and approached his son.

"Don't be. I was blessed with both of you".

"When I grow up, will we be friends again?"

Skinner laughed.

"Of course we will. I am counting on it."

"Then, you wouldn't be able to spank me anyway".

Fox's face was open and hopeful and Skinner barked a laugh.

"I wouldn't be too sure of that, son. Not sure at all".

THE END

1